Buttercup BakeShop Menu

973 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10022
  • ✨ SPONTANEOUS BAKING! ✨

    • Rainbow Cookie Cake Slice

      CONTAINS ALMOND FLOUR + ALMOND PASTE!\nOur version of a rainbow cookie in the best form it could take - a cake. Enjoy a slice, it won't last long. ;)
      $10.00
    • Strawberry Shortcake Pudding *New Item

      Strawberry Shortcake Pudding is a creamy blend of vanilla pudding, sweet strawberry compote, and crumbled shortcake, and whipped cream. A classic dessert and irresistible treat!
      $6.00
  • Main Menu

    • 1 Dzn Bar And Cookie Platter

      A platter of 6 of our favorite bars and 6 of our favorite cookies. All in one platter.\nPlease specify if you would like this assortment to be NUT-FREE!!
      $39.00
    • 1 Dzn Bar Platter - Assorted

      Assorted mix of 12 bars. Will include flavors that include nuts unless requested otherwise!!
      $54.00
    • Lemon Vanilla Bundt Cake

      A fresh lemon zesty cake and a vanilla glaze.
    • Cinnamon Maple Bundt Cake

      A moist, rich cinnamon maple bundt cake with cinnamon glaze on top!
    • 1 Dozen Premium Cupcakes Full Size

      A dozen of our top flavor cupcakes of the day. Please specify if you would like these to be nut-free!
      $47.00
    • 1 Dozen Traditional Assortment NUTFREE Full Size

      A dozen traditional cupcakes, free of nut.
      $45.00
    • 1 Dozen Mini Cupcakes NUTFREE MINIS

      A nut free assortment of mini cupcakes.
      $20.00
    • 1 Dozen Premium Mini Cupcakes Nut-Free MINIS

      A dozen of our top flavors in mini.\nA dozen of our top flavors in mini.\n(coconut, chocolate espresso, salted caramel, lemon raspberry, red velvet, chocolate raspberry, lemon)
      $24.00
  • Brownies, Bars, and Squares

    • 1 Dzn Bar And Cookie Platter

      A platter of 6 of our favorite bars and 6 of our favorite cookies. All in one platter.\nPlease specify if you would like this assortment to be NUT-FREE!!
      $39.00
    • Lemon Tart Squares

      Our tart lemon squares topped with fine powdered sugar on a soft flaky crust. A topseller.
      $4.75
    • S'mores Campfire Bar

      Our top selling bar: Graham cracker crust, marshmallows, rich ganache, topped with torched meringue and chocolate fudge drizzle. Messy, but yummy.
      $5.50
    • Gooey Choc Chip Bar

      A lovely chewy bar mixed with brown sugar and packed with chocolate chips.
      $4.00
    • Magic Coconut Bar

      Shredded coconut, walnuts and chocolate chips caramelized in layers in a graham cracker crust.
      $4.25
    • Fudge Brownie

      Rich and moist fudge brownies each infused with a hint of creamy dark chocolate.
      $3.99
    • Pecan Pie Bars

      A rich square slice of Pecan pie in a bar!
      $5.50
    • Butter Cake Bar * New Bar Alert!

      Golden butter cake crust topped with gooey butter cake filling.
      $4.00
    • Cherry Cheesecake Brownie

      Fudge brownie base, cherry cheesecake filling on top
      $4.50
    • 1 Dzn Bar Platter - Assorted

      Assorted mix of 12 bars. Will include flavors that include nuts unless requested otherwise!!
      $54.00
    • Peanut Butter Bar *New Item!!

      Delicious and rich Peanut Butter Bar with peanut butter chips!
      $4.50
    • Brookie *New

      A blend of your favorite Ooey Gooey Chocolate Chip Cookie Bar and Fudge Brownie!
      $4.75
    • Chocolate Butter Cake Bar

      $4.50
  • Bundt Cakes

    • Lemon Vanilla Bundt Cake

      A fresh lemon zesty cake and a vanilla glaze.
    • Orange Vanilla Bundt Cake Slice

  • Cakes by the Slice

    • Rainbow Cookie Cake Slice

      CONTAINS ALMOND FLOUR + ALMOND PASTE!\nOur version of a rainbow cookie in the best form it could take - a cake. Enjoy a slice, it won't last long. ;)
      $10.00
  • Candles / Sparkler

    • Individual Candle

      Single individual candle
    • Number Glitter Candles (0 - 9)

      Choose your COLOR and NUMBER
      $1.99
    • H-A-P-P-Y B-I-R-T-H-D-A-Y Candles

      Candles individually spell out happy birthday
      $3.79
    • Metallic Gold Or Silver Candles

      Metallic gold shiny 10 pack\nPlease choose your color
      $3.50
    • Celebration Sparkler (1 Single)

      Celebration candle, will stay lit anywhere from 10-40 seconds (depending on your karmic connection) These candles don't smoke during lighting, they are considered LOW smoke upon diffusing of flame. Suitable for indoor use ONLY. single sparkler
      $4.00
    • Beer Candle

      Beer shaped candle
      $3.25
    • Champagne Candles

      Champagne shaped candles
      $3.25
    • Trick Candles (Re-Lights)

      $2.99
  • Notecard

    • Notecard Custom

      Add your own personalized message
      $2.50
  • Famous Puddings

    • Famous Banana Pudding

      Layers of luscious vanilla pudding with vanilla wafers and bananas.
    • Oreo Cookies And Cream Pudding

      $6.00
    • Chocolate Trifle Pudding

      $6.00
  • Mini Cheesecakes

    • Oreo Crumb Mini Cheesecake

      Oreo cookies and cream interior, oreo crumb topping. Chocolate based crust. Feeds 1-2
      $7.99
    • Marble Swirled Cheesecake

      A swirl of Chocolate Marble Ganache. Feeds 1-2
      $7.99
    • Strawberry Swirl

      Strawberry cheesecake swirled with our homemade strawberry jam. Feeds 1-2
      $7.99
    • Red Velvet Cheesecake

      Chocolate crumb crust / Red velvet cheesecake with cream cheese frosting and red velvet cupcake crumbs on top. Feeds 1-2
      $7.99
    • Quadruple Chocolate Cheesecake

      A chocolate crumb base, chocolate cheesecake, topped with a ganache fudge and chocolate shavings on top. Feeds 1-2
      $7.99
    • Pumpkin Spice Cheesecake *Staff Favorite

      Our favorite pumpkin spice cheesecake topped with crushed walnuts and cream cheese icing.
      $7.00
    • Vanilla Bean Cheesecake

      Vanilla Bean Cheesecake topped with our Vanilla Buttercream. Feeds 1-2
      $7.99
    • Raspberry Marzipan Cheesecake * Staff Fav

      Raspberry swirled Cheesecake made with Marzipan (almond paste). Feeds 1-2
      $7.99
  • Macarons

    • 1dz Assorted Macarons

      Flavors might include:\nPistachio, Salted Caramel, Mocha, Mango, Lemon, Raspberry, Oreo cookies, Red velvet, Chocolate, Coconut, Vanilla, Strawberry Cheesecake. Varries.
      $40.00
    • 6 Pack Macarons Assorted

      An assortment of 6 Macarons. Flavors might include: Oreo, Mango, Lemon, Raspberry, Strawberry Cheesecake, Coconut, Vanilla, Satled Caramel, Mocha, Chocolate, Pistachio, Fruity Pebbles
      $21.00
    • 4 Pack Macarons

      4 Pack of Macaron assortment
      $14.00
    • Individual Macaron

      Please choose one
      $3.50
  • Gluten Free (Friendly) Cupcakes and Bars

    • Gluten Free Chocolate / Vanilla

      Chocolate moist cake with a rich vanilla buttercream
      $4.11
    • Gluten Free Gooey Chocolate Chip Blondie Bar

      $4.12
    • Gluten Free Chocolate Fudge Brownie Bar

      $4.11

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms