Butera's - Bay Shore Menu

8 Third Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706
  • SOUP OF THE DAY

    • SOUP OF THE DAY

      Please ask your server
  • APPETIZERS

    • Roasted Prosciutto Wrapped Fresh Mozzarella

      With eggplant caponata, balsamic glaze & ciabatta toast
      $14.00
    • Thai Calamari

      Fried calamari tossed with a spicy Thai sauce with scallion, black & white sesame seeds
      $18.00
    • Buffalo Style Chicken Meatballs

      Chicken meatballs in a spicy “Buffalo” sauce with bleu & gorgonzola cheese dressing, focaccia crostini
      $13.00
  • FALL SALADS

    • Warm Kale, Roasted Butternut & Beet

      Kale, roasted butternut squash, roasted beet, walnuts, goat cheese & warm white wine vinaigrette
      $16.00
    • Grilled Chicken Fall Root Vegetable

      Sliced grilled chicken, Roasted beet, carrot, parsnip, arugula, feta cheese & sliced almond
      $26.00
    • Roasted Vegetable & Lentil Grain Bowl

      Lentils, butternut squash, cauliflower, arugula, frisee, farro, quinoa & crispy parsnips with vinaigrette
      $22.00
    • Grilled Shrimp Roasted Cauliflower & Brussel Sprout

      Grilled shrimp, mixed greens, roasted cauliflower, Brussel sprouts, pistachios, croutons & house vinaigrette
      $29.00
  • AUTUMN ENTRÉES

    • Lump Crab & Roasted Tomato Chicken

      Lump crab, roasted tomato & bread crumb topped Romano chicken breast in a lemon wine sauce with a roasted Brussel sprout, carrot & potato “stufato”
      $29.00
    • Shrimp & Bay Scallop Baked Cavatappi

      Shrimp & Bay Scallops with roasted cauliflower, butternut squash & tomato in a wine sauce over cavatappi pasta, topped with mozzarella & seasoned bread crumb
      $30.00
    • Butera’s Sunday Gravy

      Baby back ribs, beef braciole, Italian sausage and chicken meatballs – all slow braised in a rustic tomato sauce over fresh rigatoni pasta
      $32.00
  • DESSERTS

    • House Baked Apple Crumble With Vanilla Ice Cream

      $11.00
  • BAR MENU

    • FOCACCIA POMODORO

      fresh pomodoro sauce, pecorino, mozzarella, Greek oregano, basil
      $12.00
    • BURRATA

      with red & yellow grape tomatoes, grilled marinated red peppers; topped with balsamic glaze, basil & sundried tomato pesto, crostini
      $14.00
    • HOUSEMADE FRESH RICOTTA

      extra virgin olive oil, roasted tomato, fresh thyme, basil, pecorino & charred ciabatta toast (Made fresh daily, limited quantity)
      $12.00
    • MOZZARELLA FRITTA

      breaded fresh mozzarella medallions fried crisp, with marinara sauce
      $12.00
    • CHICKEN MEATBALL POT

      chicken meatballs, marinara, herb ricotta, fresh mozzarella
      $18.00
    • CHICKEN MEATBALL SLIDERS

      (3) marinara, mozzarella, on house made slider buns
      $10.00
    • SHRIMP LIMONCELLO

      sautéed jumbo shrimp, lemon, garlic and Limoncello sauce, toasted almonds
      $16.00
    • PRINCE EDWARD ISLAND MUSSELS

      fresh tomato, basil, garlic & wine sauce, bruschetta points
      $16.00
    • CALAMARI FRITTI

      fried crisp, lemon, marinara
      $15.00
    • BAKED CLAMS OREGANATA

      baked whole top neck clams (6), bread crumb, wild Greek oregano
      $13.00
    • GRILLED PESTO GLAZED CALAMARI

      grilled calamari, broccoli rabe, cannellini beans
      $15.00
    • BAKED EGGPLANT INVOLTINI GRATINATO

      pomodoro sauce, fresh mozarella, toasted bread crumb
      $13.00
    • PULLED SHORT RIB & HERB RICOTTA CROSTINI

      short rib ragu, herb ricotta, grana Padano & crispy onion
      $13.00
    • TUNA CROSTINI

      seared rare yellow fin tuna, caponata, fennel red pepper slaw, ricotta salata & remoulade
      $16.00
  • FOCACCIA SANDWICHES

    • SLICED GRILLED STRIP STEAK

      sautéed spinach, melted mozzarella, crispy onions
      $18.00
    • CHICKEN PARMESAN

      $16.00
    • CHICKEN CUTLET “BLT”

      breaded cutlet, bacon, American cheese, lettuce, tomato & basil aioli
      $16.00
    • GRILLED CHICKEN, SPINACH, ROASTED PEPPER & MOZZARELLA

      $16.00
    • ZUCCHINI PARMESAN

      $15.00
    • EGGPLANT GRATINATO

      baked eggplant, fresh mozzarella, pomodoro sauce
      $15.00
    • CLASSIC ROASTED PEPPER, MOZZARELLA, TOMATO & BASIL PESTO

      $15.00
  • GRILLED PIZZA

    • MARGHERITA

      marinara sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil
      $14.00
    • CHICKEN MEATBALL

      chicken meatball, ricotta, mozzarella, marinara
      $16.00
    • PEPPERONI PICCANTE

      pepperoni, cherry peppers, marinara, mozzarella
      $16.00
    • FOCACCIA POMODORO

      house made focaccia, pomodoro sauce, pecorino, mozzarella, oregano, basil
      $12.00
    • BUTERA’S CAULIFLOWER GLUTEN FREE CRUST

      eggplant, caramelized onion, marinara, mozzarella
      $16.00
  • BURGERS

    • ITALIAN BURGER

      10 oz burger, sautéed peppers & onion, mozzarella
      $16.00
    • AMERICAN CHEESEBURGER

      10 oz burger, American cheese, tomato, lettuce, red onion
      $16.00
  • FOR THE TABLE

    • BUTERA’S SUNDAY SALAD

      iceberg, tomato, olives, cucumber, red onion, pepperoncini, focaccia croutons
      $17.00
    • CHICKEN MEATBALL POT

      chicken meatballs, marinara, herb ricotta, fresh mozzarella
      $19.00
    • PRINCE EDWARD ISLAND MUSSELS

      fresh tomato, basil, garlic & wise sauce, bruschetta points
      $19.00
  • APPETIZERS

    • BURRATA

      red, yellow grape tomatoes, grilled marinated red peppers, balsamic glaze, basil pesto, sundried tomato pesto, crostini
      $15.00
    • HOUSEMADE FRESH RICOTTA

      extra virgin olive oil, roasted tomato, fresh thyme, basil, pecorino & charred ciabatta toast (Made fresh daily, limited quantity)
      $13.00
    • MOZZARELLA FRITTA

      breaded fresh mozzarella medallions, marinara sauce
      $13.00
    • ARANCINI

      fresh mozzarella and marinara stuffed risotto rice ball
      $13.00
    • SHRIMP LIMONCELLO

      sautéed jumbo shrimp, lemon, garlic and Limoncello sauce, toasted almonds
      $17.00
    • CALAMARI FRITTI

      fried crisp, lemon, marinara sauce
      $16.00
    • BAKED CLAMS OREGANATA

      baked whole little neck clams, bread crumb, wild Greek oregano
      $14.00
    • GRILLED PESTO GLAZED CALAMARI

      grilled calamari, broccoli rabe, cannellini beans
      $16.00
    • BAKED EGGPLANT GRATINATO

      pomodoro sauce, fresh mozzarella, toasted bread crumb
      $14.00
    • PULLED SHORT RIB & HERB RICOTTA CROSTINI

      short rib ragu, herb ricotta, grana padano, crispy onion
      $14.00
    • TUNA CROSTINI

      seared rare yellow fin tuna, caponata, fennel red pepper slaw, remoulade
      $17.00
    • TODAY’S SOUP

      $9.00
  • GRILLED PIZZA

    • MARGHERITA

      marinara sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil
      $15.00
    • CHICKEN MEATBALL

      chicken meatball, ricotta, mozzarella, marinara
      $17.00
    • PEPPERONI PICCANTE

      pepperoni, cherry peppers, marinara, mozzarella
      $17.00
    • FOCACCIA POMODORO

      house made focaccia, pomodoro sauce, pecorino, mozzarella, oregano, basil
      $13.00
    • BUTERA’S CAULIFLOWER GLUTEN FREE CRUST

      eggplant, caramelized onion, marinara, mozzarella
      $17.00
  • PASTA ENTREES

    • RIGATONI SHORT RIB RAGU

      fresh rigatoni, herb ricotta, crispy onion, slow cooked tomato, short rib, soffritto
      $27.00
    • RIGATONI BUTERA

      fresh rigatoni, crumbled chicken sausage, green peas, pink sauce, shaved grana padano
      $25.00
    • RIGATONI BROCCOLI RABE CHICKEN MEATBALL

      fresh rigatoni, cannellini bean, fresh tomato, garlic & oil
      $28.00
    • PENNE CHICKEN & SHRIMP A LA VODKA

      diced chicken, shrimp, vodka & bacon tomato cream sauce
      $29.00
    • PENNE SHRIMP, BROCCOLI & ASPARAGUS

      fresh tomato, light side garlic, onion & wine sauce
      $29.00
    • PAN BAKED PENNE EGGPLANT & BURRATA

      eggplant, caramelized onion, marinara, burrata cheese
      $26.00
    • FETTUCINI LUMP CRAB BAY SCALLOP

      bay scallops, lump crab meat, rosa sauce
      $29.00
    • LINGUINE SEAFOOD “SCOGLIO”

      shrimp, scallops, mussels, clams, calamari, marinara and basil
      $33.00
    • LINGUINE VONGOLE

      Littleneck clams, garlic, parsley & extra virgin olive oil
      $28.00
    • ZUCCHINI “LINGUINE”

      crumbled chicken sausage, asparagus, spinach, roasted tomato, wine sauce
      $27.00
    • BAKED GNOCCHI ROSA

      house made ricotta gnocchi, spinach, mushroom, pink sauce, diced fresh mozzarella, pecorino
      $27.00
    • NONNA’S PAN BAKED LASAGNA

      sausage, chicken meatballs, meat ragu, ricotta & mozzarella
      $29.00
    • RAVIOLI POMODORO

      cheese ravioli, fresh pomodoro sauce, diced fresh mozzarella, pecorino & basil (v)
      $26.00
  • MAINS

    • NEW YORK STRIP STEAK

      grilled Prime 14oz. boneless strip steak, grilled asparagus, crispy roasted potato, crispy onion, Chianti wine sauce
      $42.00
    • MIXED GRILL

      grilled sliced prime strip steak, house made chicken sundried tomato sausage, shrimp, with fresh tomato, basil & fresh mozzarella risotto
      $34.00
    • DOUBLE CUT PORK CHOP “SCARPARIELLO”

      28oz Hatfield Premium Reserve pork, red & cherry peppers, potato, rosemary balsamic wine sauce
      $39.00
    • VEAL PARMESAN

      breaded veal scallopine, marinara, mozzarella, linguine
      $34.00
    • VEAL “MILANESE” STYLE

      breaded veal, arugula, potato, roasted red pepper, tomato & fresh mozzarella salad
      $34.00
    • CHICKEN PARMESAN

      breaded chicken breast, marinara, mozzarella, linguine
      $28.00
    • ROMANO CRUSTED CHICKEN PICCATA

      mushroom, lemon caper wine sauce, arugula, frisée & roasted tomato insalata, crispy roasted potato
      $29.00
    • GRILLED CHICKEN, SPINACH, ROASTED PEPPER

      grilled chicken breast, mozzarella, crispy roasted potato
      $29.00
    • BAKED EGGPLANT GRATINATO

      baked eggplant, marinara, fresh mozzarella, bread crumb, basil, linguine (v)
      $26.00
    • ZUCCHINI PARMESAN

      crispy panko-crusted zucchini, marinara, fresh mozzarella, linguine (v)
      $26.00
    • SEARED SEA SCALLOPS

      asparagus, leek, green pea & bacon risotto
      $33.00
    • GRILLED SHRIMP CAPRESE

      jumbo shrimp, roasted tomato, fresh mozzarella, basil pesto, bread crumb, orzo
      $31.00
    • PISTACHIO CRUSTED SALMON

      pistachio breadcrumb crust, mushroom, leeks, limoncello sauce, tomato herb risotto cake
      $32.00
    • LOW CARB GRILLED SALMON

      light oil sautéed asparagus, broccoli & sundried tomato
      $32.00
    • TUNA

      seared rare, sliced, sesame-crusted yellow fin tuna, eggplant, tomato, olives, potato, remoulade, crispy capellini garnish
      $33.00
    • BRONZINO

      seared bronzino filet, a fennel, mushroom, & grape tomato farrotto, baby greens insalata, roasted tomato vinaigrette
      $33.00
  • SALADS

    • MISTA

      mixed greens, grape tomato, olives, cucumber, radish, vinaigrette
      $10.00
    • CAESAR

      romaine, anchovies, crouton, classic dressing, shaved grana padano
      $14.00
    • ARUGULA

      fennel, fresh mint, pistachio, shaved ricotta salata, lemon, extra virgin olive oil
      $14.00
    • BUTERA WEDGE

      romaine, gorgonzola & bleu cheese dressing, bacon, grape tomato, olives, croutons
      $15.00
    • WARM MUSHROOM, ASPARAGUS & ROASTED PEPPER

      sautéed mushroom, asparagus, roasted pepper, mixed greens, crouton, vinaigrette (v)
      $16.00
    • FARRO SALAD

      farro, roasted pepper, grape tomato, chick pea, fresh mozzarella, arugula, frisée, hazelnut vinaigrette (v)
      $15.00
    • ADD TO ANY SALAD

  • SALAD ENTREES

    • GRILLED SHRIMP

      greens, fresh mozzarella, grape tomato, onion, almonds, bruschetta points
      $27.00
    • WARM CHICKEN FRISÉE

      spinach, greens, roasted pepper, fresh mozzarella, warm vinaigrette
      $24.00
    • WARM SEARED SEA SCALLOP

      greens, shiitake mushrooms, cannellini beans, grape tomato, warm white wine vinaigrette, bruschetta points
      $29.00
    • BALSAMIC GLAZED SALMON MEDALLIONS

      lentils, black beans, grape tomatoes, Moroccan spice, arugula, frisée, vinaigrette
      $27.00
    • RARE SEARED SESAME CRUSTED TUNA SALAD

      seared sliced sesame-crusted tuna, mixed greens, roasted peppers, crispy capellini garnish, vinaigrette
      $27.00
  • SIDES

    • CRISPY ROASTED PECORINO POTATOES

      $10.00
    • BROCCOLI RABE GARLIC & OIL

      $12.00
    • SPINACH GARLIC & OIL

      $11.00
    • BROCCOLI GARLIC & OIL

      $11.00
    • CHICKEN MEATBALL MARINARA

      $13.00
    • RISOTTO

      $14.00
    • PASTA

      $9.00
  • DESSERT

    • TIRAMISU

      $9.00
    • CHOCOLATE BROWNIE SUNDAE

      $9.00
    • TARTUFO

      $8.00
    • RAINBOW COOKIE CHEESECAKE

      $9.00
    • AFFOGATO WITH BISCOTTI

      $8.00
  • LUNCHEON SALADS

    • WARM MUSHROOM, ASPARAGUS & ROASTED PEPPER

      sautéed mushroom, asparagus, roasted pepper, mixed greens, crouton, vinaigrette (v)
      $13.00
    • FARRO SALAD

      roasted pepper, grape tomato, chick peas, fresh mozzarella, arugula, frisée, hazelnut vinaigrette (v)
      $13.00
    • GRILLED SHRIMP

      greens, fresh mozzarella, tomato, onion, almonds, bruschetta points
      $20.00
    • WARM CHICKEN FRISÉE

      spinach, greens, roasted pepper, fresh mozzarella, warm vinaigrette
      $16.00
    • WARM SEARED SEA SCALLOP

      greens, mushrooms, cannellini beans, tomato, warm white wine vinaigrette, bruschetta points
      $20.00
    • BALSAMIC GLAZED SALMON MEDALLIONS

      lentils, black beans, grape tomatoes, Moroccan spice, arugula, frisée, vinaigrette
      $20.00
    • RARE SEARED SESAME CRUSTED TUNA SALAD

      seared sliced sesame crusted tuna, mixed greens, roasted peppers, crispy capellini garnish, vinaigrette
      $20.00
    • MISTA

      mixed greens, grape tomato, olives, cucumber, radish, vinaigrette
      $9.00
    • ARUGULA

      fennel, fresh mint, pistachio, shaved ricotta salata, lemon & extra virgin olive oil
      $13.00
    • ADD

  • GRILLED PIZZA

    • MARGHERITA

      marinara sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil
      $15.00
    • CHICKEN MEATBALL

      chicken meatball, ricotta, mozzarella, marinara
      $17.00
    • PEPPERONI PICCANTE

      pepperoni, cherry peppers, marinara, mozzarella
      $17.00
    • FOCACCIA POMODORO

      house made focaccia, pomodoro sauce, pecorino, mozzarella, oregano, basil
      $13.00
    • BUTERA’S CAULIFLOWER GLUTEN FREE CRUST

      eggplant, caramelized onion, marinara, mozzarella
      $17.00
  • PASTA

    • PENNE MARINARA

      $15.00
    • PENNE BROCCOLI

      garlic & oil, crispy ceci (chick peas), pecorino romano
      $17.00
    • PENNE CHICKEN MEATBALL MARINARA

      $17.00
    • PENNE VODKA

      tomato cream sauce, bacon, proscuitto
      $17.00
    • PAN BAKED PENNE

      marinara, ricotta, melted mozzarella
      $17.00
  • FOCACCIA SANDWICHES

    • SLICED GRILLED STRIP STEAK

      sautéed spinach, melted mozzarella, crispy onions
      $19.00
    • CHICKEN PARMESAN

      $17.00
    • CHICKEN CUTLET “BLT”

      breaded cutlet, bacon, American cheese, lettuce, tomato & basil aioli
      $17.00
    • GRILLED CHICKEN, SPINACH, ROASTED PEPPER & MOZZARELLA

      $17.00
    • ZUCCHINI PARMESAN

      $16.00
    • EGGPLANT GRATINATO

      baked eggplant, fresh mozzarella, pomodoro sauce
      $16.00
    • CLASSIC ROASTED PEPPER, MOZZARELLA, TOMATO & BASIL PESTO

      $16.00
    • GRILLED SAUSAGE, BROCCOLI RABE & MOZZARELLA

      $17.00
  • GRAIN BOWLS

    • CHICKEN FARRO QUINOA

      chick pea, black bean, red onion & tomato insalata, sautéed spinach & mushroom, farro & quinoa, sliced almond vinaigrette
      $17.00
  • BURGERS

    • ITALIAN BURGER

      10 oz burger, sautéed peppers & onion, mozzarella
      $16.00
    • AMERICAN CHEESEBURGER

      10 oz burger, American cheese, tomato, lettuce, red onion
      $16.00
  • BRUNCH SALADS

    • WARM MUSHROOM, ASPARAGUS & ROASTED PEPPER

      sauteed mushroom, asparagus, roasted pepper, mixed greens, crouton, vinaigrette (v)
      $13.00
    • FARRO SALAD

      roasted pepper, grape tomato, chickpeas, fresh mozzarella, arugula, frisee, hazelnut vinaigrette (v)
      $13.00
    • GRILLED SHRIMP

      greens, fresh mozzarella, tomato, onion, almonds, bruschetta points
      $20.00
    • WARM CHICKEN FRISEE

      spinach, greens, roasted pepper, fresh mozzarella, warm vinaigrette
      $16.00
    • WARM SEARED SEA SCALLOP

      greens, mushrooms, cannellini beans, tomato, warm white wine vinaigrette, bruschetta points
      $20.00
    • BALSAMIC GLAZED SALMON MEDALLIONS

      lentils, black beans, grape tomatoes, Moroccan spice, arugula, frisee, vinaigrette
      $20.00
    • RARE SEARED SESAME CRUSTED TUNA SALAD

      seared sliced sesame-crusted tuna, mixed greens, roasted peppers, crispy capellini garnish, vinaigrette
      $20.00
    • MISTA

      mixed greens, grape tomato, olives, cucumber, radish, vinaigrette
      $9.00
    • ARUGULA

      fennel, fresh mint, pistachio, ricotta salatta, lemon, extra virgin olive oil
      $13.00
    • Add

  • BRUNCH MAINS

    • SAUSAGE, PEPPER, ONION, POTATO FRITTATA (Italian Omelet)

      ciabatta toast, baby greens
      $16.00
    • ROASTED PEPPER, ASPARAGUS, MUSHROOM FRITTATA

      ciabatta toast, baby greens
      $16.00
    • GRILLED PIZZA ALL’ UOVO

      sliced tomato, two eggs, bacon, potato & mozzarella
      $17.00
    • CHALLAH FRENCH TOAST

      challah French toast, strawberry compote
      $14.00
  • GRILLED PIZZA

    • MARGHERITA

      marinara sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil
      $15.00
    • CHICKEN MEATBALL

      chicken meatball, ricotta, mozzarella, marinara
      $17.00
    • PEPPERONI PICCANTE

      pepperoni, cherry peppers, marinara, mozzarella
      $17.00
    • FOCACCIA POMODORO

      housemade focaccia, pomodoro sauce, pecorino, mozzarella, oregano, basil
      $13.00
    • BUTERA’S CAULIFLOWER GLUTEN FREE CRUST

      eggplant, caramelized onion, marinara, mozzarella
      $17.00
  • BURGERS

    • ITALIAN BURGER

      10 oz burger, sautéed peppers & onion, mozzarella, french fries
      $16.00
    • AMERICAN CHEESEBURGER

      10 oz burger, American cheese, tomato, lettuce, red onion, french fries
      $16.00
  • FOCACCIA SANDWICHES

    • SLICED GRILLED ITALIAN CHEESE STEAK

      thinly sliced sirloin, sauteed spinach, melted mozzarella, crispy onions
      $19.00
    • CHICKEN CUTLET “BLT”

      breaded cutlet, bacon, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, basil aioli,
      $17.00
    • CHICKEN PARMESAN

      $17.00
    • GRILLED CHICKEN, SPINACH, ROASTED PEPPER & MOZZARELLA

      $17.00
    • ZUCCHINI PARMESAN

      $17.00
    • EGGPLANT GRATINATO

      baked eggplant, fresh mozzarella, pomodoro sauce
      $16.00
    • CLASSIC ROASTED PEPPER, MOZZARELLA, TOMATO & BASIL PESTO

      $16.00
    • GRILLED SAUSAGE, BROCCOLI RABE & MOZZARELLA

      $17.00
  • PASTAS

    • PENNE MARINARA

      $15.00
    • PENNE BROCCOLI

      garlic & oil, crispy ceci (chick peas), pecorino romano
      $17.00
    • PENNE CHICKEN MEATBALL MARINARA

      $17.00
    • PENNE VODKA

      tomato cream sauce, bacon, prosciutto
      $17.00
    • PAN BAKED PENNE

      marinara, ricotta, melted mozzarella
      $17.00
  • GRAIN BOWLS

    • CHICKEN FARRO QUINOA

      chickpea, black bean, red onion & tomato insalata, sauteed spinach & mushroom, farro & quinoa, sliced almond vinaigrette
      $17.00

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms