Bruster's Real Ice Cream Menu

4.6

(625+ Reviews)

Take Home Special Order Flavors Traditional Shakes and Malts Create Your Own Shake Non-dairy Milkshakes Ice Cream Sandwiches Ready Now Cakes Ready Now Pies Create Your Own Sodas Gift Cards Sodas

Take Home
Get your favorite flavors Hand-packed-to-order. Be the hero of your next get-together and brighten someone's day!
- Pint
  16 oz (5 to 6 Scoops)
  $8.99
- Quart
  32 oz (10 to 12 Scoops)
  $13.99
- Half Gallon
  64 oz (20 to 24 scoops)
  $23.99
Special Order Flavors
Your favorite flavor not on the menu? No problem! We can make any flavor from our over 150 recipes. Minimum purchase and 48 hours advance notice required.
- Request Your Flavor
  64 oz. (20 to 24 Scoops)
  $23.99
Traditional Shakes and Malts
Step back in time to a classic soda fountain. We craft our traditional milkshakes using our own fresh-made ice cream, add topping, and blend to creamy perfection.
- Vanilla Milkshake
  Our Vanilla Milkshakes are made the old-fashioned way: hand-spun with our fresh-made Vanilla ice cream and a touch of vanilla syrup.
  $6.99
- Vanilla Malt
  Our Vanilla Malt features a classic combination: our own freshly made Vanilla Ice Cream, malt powder, and a touch of vanilla syrup, all blended to perfection.
  $6.99
- Chocolate Milkshake
  The richness of our fresh Vanilla ice cream combines with the smooth sweetness of Hershey's Chocolate Syrup for an irresistible flavor.
  $6.99
- Chocolate Malt
  Our Chocolate Malt is a rich and decadent treat. We combine our own freshly made Vanilla Ice Cream with Hershey's chocolate syrup, malt powder, and blend it to perfection.
  $6.99
- Strawberry Milkshake
  Experience our fresh Strawberry ice cream (made with real fruit) and a generous helping of strawberry topping all blended to perfection.
  $6.99
- Strawberry Malt
  Experience our fresh Strawberry ice cream (made with real fruit) and a generous helping of strawberry topping all blended to perfection.
  $6.99
Create Your Own Shake
HandSpun and made-to-order. Your choice of any available flavor. Endless possibilities!
- Small Milkshake
  16 oz (3 Scoops)
  $6.99
- Medium Milkshake
  22 oz (4 Scoops)
  $7.99
- Large Milkshake
  32 oz (6 Scoops)
  $9.99
Non-dairy Milkshakes
Indulge! Made with our fresh-made creamy vegan ice cream and blended with refreshing Oat Milk, these shakes are a delightful treat for everyone.
- Small Non-dairy Milkshake
  16 oz (3 Scoops)
  $6.99
- Medium Non-dairy Milkshake
  22 oz (4 Scoops)
  $7.99
- Large Non-dairy Milkshake
  32 oz (6 Scoops)
  $9.99
Ice Cream Sandwiches
- Single Sandwich
  3" Cookie Wafers sandwich a generous scoop of your choice of fresh-made Ice Cream
  $4.99
- Single Sandwich (Non-Dairy)
  3" Cookie Wafers sandwich a generous scoop of your choice of fresh-made Non-dairy Ice Cream
  $4.99
- Sandwich 6-Pack
  A pack of six Cookie Sandwiches; Mix and match your choice of Ice Cream flavors (Dairy or Non-Dairy).
  $22.99
Ready Now Cakes
Our selection of Cakes available for you to pickup or deliver today. No changes or substitutions.
- Cookies & Cream Cake (8" Round)
  Layers of moist Chocolate Cake, Chocolate Fudge, and Cookies & Cream ice cream. Serves 12 to 16.
  $47.99
- Cookies & Cream Cake (8" Round)
  Layers of moist Yellow Cake, Chocolate Fudge, and Cookies & Cream ice cream. Serves 12 to 16.
  $47.99
- Cone Cake (8" Round) w/Cotton Candy Explosion
  Layers of moist Yellow Cake, Marshmallow Cream, and Cotton Candy Explosion ice cream. Serves 12 to 16.
  $47.99
- Confetti Design (8" Round) w/Cookies & Cream
  Layers of moist Yellow Cake, Chocolate Fudge, and Cookies & Cream ice cream. Serves 12 to 16.
  $47.99
- Confetti Design (8" Round) w/Chocolate
  Layers of moist Chocolate Cake, Chocolate Fudge, and Chocolate ice cream. Serves 12 to 16.
  $47.99
- Confetti Design (8" Round) w/Vanilla
  Layers of moist Yellow Cake, Chocolate Fudge, and Vanilla ice cream. Serves 12 to 16.
  $47.99
- Drizzle Design (8" Round) w/Cookes & Cream
  Layers of moist Chocolate Cake, Chocolate Fudge, and Cookies & Cream ice cream. Serves 12 to 16.
  $47.99
- Drizzle Design (8" Round) w/Double Fudge Brownie
  Layers of moist Chocolate Cake, Chocolate Fudge, and Double Fudge Brownie ice cream. Serves 12 to 16.
  $47.99
Ready Now Pies
Our selection of Pies available for you to pickup or deliver today. No changes or substitutions.
- Cookies & Cream Pie
  Our classic Cookies & Cream ice cream and rich Chocolate Fudge in a Chocolate Cookie Pie Crust. Serves 6 to 8.
  $39.99
- Turtle Pie w/Butter Pecan
  Our creamy Butter Pecan ice cream and gooey Caramel in a Graham Cracker Pie Crust. Serves 6 to 8.
  $39.99
Create Your Own
Request a special Ice Cream Cake or Pie with your choice of flavors and design. Minimum 48 hours advance purchase required.
- Create a Cake (8" Round)
  Serves 12 to 16
  $47.99
- Create a Cake (1/4 Sheet)
  Serves 20 to 24
  $74.99
- Create a Pie (9")
  Serves 6 to 8
  $39.99
- Create a Non-Dairy Pie (9")
  Featuring our fresh-made Non-dairy Ice Cream made with Oat Milk. Vegan; Serves 6 to 8
  $39.99
Sodas
Your favorite fizzy drink chilled for maximum refreshment
- A&W Cream Soda
  A classic American soft drink with a creamy, smooth vanilla flavor (12 fl oz Can)
  $1.05
- A&W Root Beer
  Made with aged vanilla for a sweet and smooth taste (12 fl oz Can)
  $1.05
- A&W Root Beer Zero Sugar
  A sweet, indulgent, and guilt-free taste with a smooth, creamy finish (12 fl oz Can)
  $1.05
- Canada Dry Ginger Ale
  Made with the crisp, refreshing ginger taste you've always loved (12 fl oz Can)
  $1.05
- Coke
  A delicious, crisp, sparkling cola for the refreshment you want (12 fl oz Can)
  $1.05
- Coke Zero
  Great taste with zero sugar and calories (12 fl oz Can)
  $1.05
- Diet Coke
  A delicious, crisp, sparkling cola for the refreshment you want without the calories (12 fl oz Can)
  $1.05
- Dr. Pepper
  A signature blend of 23 flavors makes every sip of Dr Pepper truly unique (12 fl oz Can)
  $1.05
- Mountain Dew
  A citrus-flavored, carbonated soft drink that's "bold" and "refreshing" (12 fl oz Can)
  $1.05
- Sprite
  A lemon-lime soda with 100% natural flavors (12 fl oz Can)
  $1.05
- Sunkist Orange
  A bold, sweet orange flavor that's great for satisfying thirst
  $1.05
Gift Cards
Share the sweetness with a Bruster's gift card. Perfect for any occasion!
- $10 Gift Card
  Share the sweetness with a Bruster's gift card!
  $10.00
- $20 Gift Card
  Give the gift that's sure to put a smile on their face: Bruster's ice cream!
  $20.00
Sodas
Your favorite fizzy drink chilled for maximum refreshment
- A&W Cream Soda
  A classic American soft drink with a creamy, smooth vanilla flavor (12 fl oz Can)
  $1.05
- A&W Root Beer
  Made with aged vanilla for a sweet and smooth taste (12 fl oz Can)
  $1.05
- A&W Root Beer Zero Sugar
  A sweet, indulgent, and guilt-free taste with a smooth, creamy finish (12 fl oz Can)
  $1.05
- Canada Dry Ginger Ale
  Made with the crisp, refreshing ginger taste you've always loved (12 fl oz Can)
  $1.05
- Coke
  A delicious, crisp, sparkling cola for the refreshment you want (12 fl oz Can)
  $1.05
- Coke Zero
  Great taste with zero sugar and calories (12 fl oz Can)
  $1.05
- Diet Coke
  A delicious, crisp, sparkling cola for the refreshment you want without the calories (12 fl oz Can)
  $1.05
- Dr. Pepper
  A signature blend of 23 flavors makes every sip of Dr Pepper truly unique (12 fl oz Can)
  $1.05
- Mountain Dew
  A citrus-flavored, carbonated soft drink that's "bold" and "refreshing" (12 fl oz Can)
  $1.05
- Sprite
  A lemon-lime soda with 100% natural flavors (12 fl oz Can)
  $1.05
- Sunkist Orange
  A bold, sweet orange flavor that's great for satisfying thirst
  $1.05