Bruster's Real Ice Cream Menu

4.5

(475+ Reviews)

$Ice cream shop, Dessert, Dessert shop

Customer Favorites Bruster's Menu Nathan's Menu Combo Meals Beverages

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- Pint
  $9.40
- Quart
  $13.75
- Hot Dog
  Served on Martin's Potato Rolls.
  $5.55
- Regular Cup
  3 scoops of the flavor of your choice
  $6.60
- Hot Fudge Brownie Sundae
  Brownie, vanilla ice cream, hot fudge, whip cream, and a cherry.
  $9.45
- Medium Milkshake
  At Bruster's, we stand behind the tradition of handcrafting drinkable desserts with skill and care. you'll notice the difference with your first sip.
  $8.40
- Banana Split Sundae
  Fresh ice cream. Vanilla , Chocolate and StrawberryWith Pineapple, Chocolate, Strawberry , Fresh Banana,Whip Cream , Cherry and pretzel.
  $9.45
- Large Cup
  4 scoops of the flavor of your choice
  $7.40
- Medium Blast
  Soft serve vanilla ice cream with a candy of your choice mixed in.
  $8.85
- Small Blast
  Soft serve vanilla ice cream with a candy of your choice mixed in.
  $7.75
- Large Waffle Bowl
  Fill a fresh made waffle bowl with four scoops of the premium daily flavor of your choice
  $8.75
- Large Crinkle Cut Fry
  $6.60
Bruster's Menu
- Quart
  $13.75
- Pint
  $9.40
- Banana Split Sundae
  Fresh ice cream. Vanilla , Chocolate and StrawberryWith Pineapple, Chocolate, Strawberry , Fresh Banana,Whip Cream , Cherry and pretzel.
  $9.45
- Regular Cup
  3 scoops of the flavor of your choice
  $6.60
- Medium Milkshake
  At Bruster's, we stand behind the tradition of handcrafting drinkable desserts with skill and care. you'll notice the difference with your first sip.
  $8.40
- Small Cup
  2 scoops of the flavor of your choice.
  $5.80
- Large Waffle Bowl
  Fill a fresh made waffle bowl with four scoops of the premium daily flavor of your choice
  $8.75
- Hot Fudge Brownie Sundae
  Brownie, vanilla ice cream, hot fudge, whip cream, and a cherry.
  $9.45
- Large Cup
  4 scoops of the flavor of your choice
  $7.40
- Medium Blast
  Soft serve vanilla ice cream with a candy of your choice mixed in.
  $8.85
- Peanut Butter Banana Sundae
  3 scoops of chocolate ice cream, warm peanut butter, hot fudge, crushed heath candy, banana, whipped cream, and a cherry.
  $9.45
- Small Waffle Bowl
  Fill a fresh made waffle bowl with two scoops of the premium daily flavor of your choice
  $7.15
- Peanut Butter Cup Sundae
  Vanilla ice cream, Reese's peanut butter cups,peanut butter,hot fudge,whip cream, and a cherry.
  $8.80
- 6 Pack Oreo Ice Cream Sandwiches
  You can choose from Vanilla, Chocolate, or Strawberry ice cream.
  $18.75
- Small Blast
  Soft serve vanilla ice cream with a candy of your choice mixed in.
  $7.75
- Regular Sundae
  Vanilla ice cream, your choice of 1 topping, whip cream, and a cherry.
  $7.25
- Regular Waffle Bowl
  Fill a fresh made waffle bowl with three scoops of the premium daily flavor of your choice
  $7.95
- Small Milkshake
  At Bruster's, we stand behind the tradition of handcrafting drinkable desserts with skill and care. you'll notice the difference with your first sip.
  $7.75
- Chocolate Chip Cookie Sundae
  Chocolate chip cookie, vanilla ice cream, hot fudge, whip cream, and a cherry. Heat cookie 20-25 seconds in the microwave.
  $9.45
- Dino Sundae
  Made with vanilla ice cream, chocolate syrup, and a sugar cookie.
  $6.25
- Freeze
  Italian Ice, sorbet, or sherbet mixed with your choice of beverage. Check out our flavor choices of the day and put in the notes which Italian ice, sorbet, or sherbet you would like us to use.
  $8.25
- Turtle Sundae
  Vanilla ice cream, caramel, hot fudge, pecans, whip cream, and a cherry.
  $8.80
- Dirt Sundae
  1 Scoop of Vanilla Ice Cream, topped with crushed Oreos and a Gummy Worm
  $5.70
- Small Malted Shake
  A small milkshake with malt powder added.
  $8.45
- Medium Malted Shake
  Regular milkshake with malt powder added.
  $9.20
- Ice Cream Float
  $8.25
- Parfait
  Our soft creamy vanilla layered with your choice of our Italian ice, sherbet, or sorbet.Check out our flavor options and put in the comments which Italian ice, sherbet, or sorbet you would like us to use.
  $8.75
- Ice Cream Pie
  Pie serves 6-8 peoplePlease call store for available pie flavors before placing order. 717-261-1484We can customize writing on the pie as well at the time you call to choose your cake. (Not all pies are decorated with Oreos.)
  $28.75
- 8' Ice Cream Cake
  Cake serves 12-16 peoplePlease call store for available cake flavors before placing order. 717-261-1484We can customize writing on the cake as well at the time you call to choose your cake. (Not all cakes are decorated with Oreos.)
  $38.75
Nathan's Menu
- Large Crinkle Cut Fry
  $6.60
- Regular Crinkle Cut Fry
  $5.29
- Hot Dog
  Served on Martin's Potato Rolls.
  $5.55
- 15 Jumbo Corn Dog Nuggets
  15 pieces
  $16.25
- 9 Jumbo Corn Dog Nuggets
  9 pieces
  $11.65
- 5 Piece Chicken Tender
  5 pieces
  $9.50
- 9 Mozzarella Sticks
  $9.60
- 3 Piece Chicken Tender
  3 pieces
  $7.75
- Burger
  Served on Martin's Potato Rolls
  $6.15
- Regular Onion Ring
  $5.45
- 6 Jumbo Corn Dog Nuggets
  6 pieces
  $8.45
- Large Onion Rings
  $6.70
- Chicken Sandwich
  Served on Martin's Potato Rolls
  $7.20
- 6 Mozzarella Sticks
  $6.99
- 15 Mozzarella Sticks
  $16.09
Combo Meals
A combo meal comes with fries or onion rings and a beverage.
- 1 Hot Dog Combo Meal
  Choose a regular fry or onion ring and a regular beverage.
  $11.55
- Chicken Sandwich Combo Meal
  $13.05
- Burger Combo Meal
  $12.60
- 6 Jumbo Corn Dog Nugget Combo Meal
  $13.85
- 2 Hot Dog Combo Meal
  $15.55
- 3 Piece Chicken Tender Combo Meal
  $12.85
Beverages
- Large Soda
  Pepsi products
  $4.30
- Regular Soda
  Pepsi products
  $3.45
- Large Nathan's Lemonade
  $4.30
- Regular Sweet Tea
  $3.45
- Large Sweet Tea
  $4.30
- Regular Nathan's Lemonade
  $3.45