Brothers BBQ Menu

2402 NY-32, New Windsor, NY 12553

Appetizer Soup/Salad Burger Sandwich From Our Pit Southern Sides Desserts Kids Menu Na Beverages Brothers Favorites Wraps Sliders Lunch Desserts

Appetizer
- Beaufort Shrimp
  Gulf shrimp seasoned with our house rub grilled then glazed with BBQ sauce served with our horseradish cream sauce.
  $16.80
- Boneless Wings
  Buttermilk fried boneless chicken chunks tossed in your choice of sauce. Served with celery, carrots, and homemade blue cheese dressing
  $18.00
- Brothers Cheese Fries
  Hand cut French fries smothered with Monterey Jack and Cheddar cheese, topped with apple wood smoked bacon and served with homemade ranch dressing
  $16.80
- Hungry Helpers
  Smoked sausage wrapped in applewood bacon tossed in our bbq sauce.
  $13.14
- Nachos
  Tortilla chips, topped with our BBQ meat of the day, smothered with Monterey jack and cheddar cheese, topped with smoked Pico de Gallo, and sour cream. Ask your sever for the meat of the day!
  $16.80
- Smoked Wings
  Chicken wings hickory smoked until juicy and tender, then deep fried 'til crispy and tossed in your choice of sauce. Served with celery, carrots, and homemade blue cheese dressing
  $18.00
- Sticky Ribs
  Our St. Louis ribs smoked low n slow and caramelized in our house BBQ sauce
  $18.00
- Uncle Bo Shrimp
  Gulf shrimp seasoned with our house rub grilled then glazed with BBQ sauce served with our horseradish cream sauce.
  $16.80
- Deep Fried Wings
  $18.00
Soup/Salad
- Caesar Salad
  Romaine lettuce, Parmesan cheese, and homemade cornbread croutons, tossed with our homemade Caesar dressing.
  $12.00
- Dads Iceburg
  Just like dad made at home, a hunk of iceberg smothered with blue cheese dressing, chopped tomatoes, and apple wood smoked bacon
  $14.40
- Brothers Greens
  Mixed Greens and Romaine topped with diced tomato, onion, Monterey jack and cheddar cheese, served with homemade balsamic vinaigrette
  $12.00
Burger
- Classic
  8oz blend of porterhouse, chuck, and brisket burger topped with your choice of cheese. Please use special instructions to notify if you would like to add Lettuce Tomatoes Pickles and/or Onions. Served on a brioche bun, with French fries. Add apple wood smoked bacon $2
  $15.54
- Smokehouse
  $19.14
- Big Tex
  $20.34
- Porko Burger
  8oz blend of porterhouse, chuck, and brisket burger, topped with cheddar, apple wood smoked bacon, pulled pork, fried onion strings, and our famous BBQ sauce. Served on a brioche bun, with French fries.
  $20.34
Sandwich
- Bro Ribber
  Chunks of tasty rib meat caramelized in our bbq sauce and served on a brioche bun.
  $18.00
- Chopped BBQ Sandwich
  Smoked pork chopped up and dressed with our eastern North Carolina vinegar based sauce, topped with homemade coleslaw and pickles, served on a brioche bun.
  $18.00
- Rooster Sandwich
  House marinated chicken breast grilled and glazed with BBQ sauce, served on a brioche bun.
  $16.80
- Fried Chicken Sandwich
  Buttermilk marinated chicken breast, fried golden brown, topped with apple wood smoked bacon and cheddar, served on a brioche bun.
  $17.94
- Gunslinger
  $20.34
- Shrimp Po Boy
  $19.14
- Brisket Sandwich
  Our tender pepper-crusted hickory smoked brisket sliced and piled high on a brioche bun.
  $20.40
- Pulled Pork Sandwich
  Our smoked until tender pork pulled to order, served on a brioche bun.
  $18.00
- Frankie Boy
  $19.14
- BIG BOY Sandwich
  Can’t decide? Don’t, get them all. Pulled pork, brisket, sausage, and apple wood smoked bacon, stacked high and topped with our BBQ sauce. Served on a brioche bun.
  $21.60
From Our Pit
- Smoked Yard Bird
  Half chicken brined for 12 hours, then rubbed and smoked until juicy and tender.
  $21.54
- Pulled Pork Plate
  Our super tender smoked pork, hand-pulled to order
  $22.74
- Chopped BBQ Plate
  A North Carolina staple, what the brothers grew up on. Our fresh smoked pork chopped and dressed with our eastern North Carolina vinegar based sauce.
  $22.74
- Brothers Smoked Brisket
  Pepper-crusted and smoked low and slow for over 15 hours, until perfectly tender and juicy. Sliced to order.
  $27.60
- Brothers Legendary Half Rack Ribs
  Your choice of Baby Back or St. Louis ribs seasoned with our house dry rub smoked and slow for over 5 hours until they’re juicy, tender and almost fall of the bone.
  $26.40
- Brothers Legendary Full Rack Ribs
  Your choice of Baby Back or St. Louis ribs seasoned with our house dry rub smoked and slow for over 5 hours until they’re juicy, tender and almost fall of the bone.
  $38.40
- Texan Smoked Sausage
  Straight from the South Side Market in Elgin Texas these sausages are specially handcrafted for us. A duo of Texas style beef sausage and Jalapeno Cheddar Sausage smoked then kissed on the grill.
  $20.40
- 2 Meat Combo
  Choose two of your favorite smoked meats: pulled Pork, brisket, ribs, smoked chicken, chopped BBQ, or sausage.
  $28.80
- 3 Meat Combo
  Choose three of your favorite smoked meats: pulled pork, brisket, ribs, smoked chicken, chopped BBQ, or sausage.
  $33.54
- Uncle Dave
  A sampler of our most popular smoked meats: ribs, pulled pork, brisket, smoked chicken, and sausage.
  $42.00
- Pulled Pint
  $21.60
- Chopped BBQ Pint
  $19.20
- Pound Of Brisket
  $32.39
- Whole Smoked Chicken
  $26.40
Southern
- Aunt Edna's Fried Chicken
  Just like our Great Aunt Edna used to make for us, its crispy, juicy, and fried to order, a brothers favorite served with your choice of two sides
  $20.40
- Aunt Caroline's Fried Shrimp
  Gulf shrimp dredged in seasoned flour, fried to perfection, and served with your two sides
  $22.74
- Mama's Shrimp Grits
  Gulf shrimp sautéed with bacon, peppers, and onions, served over our cheesy grits. Just like when we were kids
  $23.94
- Smoken Rooster Entree
  Our house marinated chicken breasts grilled and glazed with BBQ sauce. Served with your choice of two sides.
  $20.34
Sides
- Smoked Baked Beans
- Cole Slaw
- Big Jay's Collard Greens
- Fries
- Grits
- Mac N Cheese
- Potato Salad
- Green Beans
- Yams
- Extra BBQ Sauce
- Bottle BBQ Sauce
  $8.00
- 1 Piece Cornbread
  A single piece of cornbread, often enjoyed for its sweet and savory taste, baked to achieve a moist and tender texture.
  $4.00
Desserts
- Brownie Sundae
  A warm thick fudge and chocolaty brownie served with vanilla ice cream and fudge sauce
  $12.00
- French Toast Bread Pudding Ala Mode
  $10.74
Kids Menu
- Kids Nuggets
  $8.39
- Kids Ribs
  $8.39
- Mac & Cheese
  $8.39
- Kids Ice Cream
  $3.54
- Cheese Burger
  $8.39
- Kids Hot Fudge Sundae
  $8.39
- Kids Hot Dog
  $8.39
- Grilled Cheese
  $7.20
Na Beverages
- Fountain Soda
  $4.20
- Kids Soda
  $2.34
- Sweet Tea
  $4.20
- Lemonade
  $4.20
- Milk
  $4.20
- Apple Juice
  $4.20
- Orange Juice
  $4.20
- Cranberry
  $4.20
- Coffee
  $4.20
- Hot Tea
  $4.20
- Bottled Water
  $6.00
Brothers Favorites
- Soup & Salad
  Choice of Brisket Chili or Soup of the Day. Side salad options: Brothers Greens, Caesar, or Dads Iceberg.
  $13.00
- Brisket Chopped Cheese
  Chopped smoked brisket, melted cheddar cheese, and saut√©ed onions on a toasted bun, typically finished with a drizzle of bbq sauce.
  $15.00
- Tex- Mex Quesadilla
  Grilled chicken, oaxaca cheese, avocado, pico de gallo, and beans in a flour tortilla, with a touch of cilantro.
  $14.00
- Brothers Mac Bowl
  Creamy macaroni and cheese with a choice of brisket or pulled pork.
  $16.00
- Chili Cheese Dogs
  All-beef hot dog topped with homemade chili and cheddar cheese.
  $14.00
- Wings & Fries
  Chicken wings served with fries. Multiple sauce options available, including BBQ, Buffalo, and more.
  $14.00
Wraps
- Smoked Chicken Salad Wrap
  Smoked chicken breast, poblano peppers, corn, yogurt/mayo blend, and cilantro wrapped in a flour tortilla.
  $15.00
- Chicken Caesar Wrap
  Tender chicken and crisp romaine in creamy Caesar dressing, wrapped snugly.
  $15.00
- Buffalo Chicken Blue Cheese Wrap
  Crispy chicken, buffalo sauce, lettuce, tomato, and blue cheese dressing wrapped in a tortilla.
  $15.00
Sliders
- BBQ Sliders
  Juicy sliders featuring your choice of pulled pork, brisket, or chopped BBQ served on a soft bun.
  $16.00
- Po Boy Sliders
  Crispy Cajun shrimp, slaw, pickles, and chipotle mayo on mini buns.
  $16.00
Lunch Desserts
- Pecan Pie
  Classic Southern dessert made with a rich filling of pecans in a flaky pastry crust.
  $8.00
- French Toast Bread Pudding
  Classic bread pudding made with French toast, typically topped with berries and bourbon anglaise.
  $8.00
- Brownie Sundae
  Chocolate brownie topped with vanilla ice cream, hot fudge, caramel sauce, and chopped pecans.
  $8.00

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

Brothers BBQ Menu

Appetizer

Beaufort Shrimp

Boneless Wings

Brothers Cheese Fries

Hungry Helpers

Nachos

Smoked Wings

Sticky Ribs

Uncle Bo Shrimp

Deep Fried Wings

Soup/Salad

Caesar Salad

Dads Iceburg

Brothers Greens

Burger

Classic

Smokehouse

Big Tex

Porko Burger

Sandwich

Bro Ribber

Chopped BBQ Sandwich

Rooster Sandwich

Fried Chicken Sandwich

Gunslinger

Shrimp Po Boy

Brisket Sandwich

Pulled Pork Sandwich

Frankie Boy

BIG BOY Sandwich

From Our Pit

Smoked Yard Bird

Pulled Pork Plate

Chopped BBQ Plate

Brothers Smoked Brisket

Brothers Legendary Half Rack Ribs

Brothers Legendary Full Rack Ribs

Texan Smoked Sausage

2 Meat Combo

3 Meat Combo

Uncle Dave

Pulled Pint

Chopped BBQ Pint

Pound Of Brisket

Whole Smoked Chicken

Southern

Aunt Edna's Fried Chicken

Aunt Caroline's Fried Shrimp

Mama's Shrimp Grits

Smoken Rooster Entree

Sides

Smoked Baked Beans

Cole Slaw

Big Jay's Collard Greens

Fries

Grits

Mac N Cheese

Potato Salad

Green Beans

Yams

Extra BBQ Sauce

Bottle BBQ Sauce

1 Piece Cornbread

Desserts

Brownie Sundae

French Toast Bread Pudding Ala Mode

Kids Menu

Kids Nuggets

Kids Ribs

Mac & Cheese

Kids Ice Cream

Cheese Burger

Kids Hot Fudge Sundae

Kids Hot Dog

Grilled Cheese

Na Beverages

Fountain Soda

Kids Soda

Sweet Tea