Checkle Logo
Checkle
Search
For Businesses

Coney Island Bagels Menu

$Bagel shop, Breakfast, Cafe
2829 Coney Island Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11235
Order Online

  • Make It Your Way

    • Build-A-Bagel (Or Anything)

      Feel free to make anything you want.
      $1.56

    • 2 Eggs Breakfast Sandwich

      2 Fresh Eggs on a Bagel( or your choice of bread). Completely customizable.
      $4.99

    • 2 Eggs On Plate With Homefries

      2 Eggs any style, on a platter with Homefries and Toast.
      $7.24

  • Breakfast Specialties

    • Special* Bagel With Apple Pie Cheesecake Cream Cheese

      Fresh bagel with apple pie cheesecake cream cheese.
      $5.95

    • Special* Bagel W/ Roasted Garlic And Herbs CC

      Fresh Bagel with Roasted Garlic & Herbs Cream Cheese.
      $5.95

    • Special* Bagel With Cucumber Dill Cream Cheese

      Fresh Bagel with our Special Cucumber Dill Cream Cheese
      $5.95

    • Bagel With Cream Cheese

      Our Fresh Bagels with your choice of a selection of Delicious Cream Cheeses.
      $4.69

    • Bagel With Butter

      Fresh Bagel with High Grade Butter.
      $3.05

    • BEC

      The Classic Bacon, Egg, and Cheese.
      $8.75

    • 2 Eggs Breakfast Sandwich

      2 Fresh Eggs on a Bagel( or your choice of bread). Completely customizable.
      $4.99

    • 2 Eggs On Plate With Homefries

      2 Eggs any style, on a platter with Homefries and Toast.
      $7.24

    • Fresh Lox & Cream Cheese

      Catsmo Fresh Lox and Cream Cheese on a Bagel.
      $10.61

    • Pancakes(Full Size)

      Stack of 3. Served with Syrup and Butter.
      $8.06

    • Pan-Wich BEC

      Pancake Sandwich with 2 Eggs, Bacon, and American Cheese. Served with Syrup.
      $10.94

    • Silver Dollar Pancakes

      Silver Dollar-Style Mini Pancakes. Served with Syrup and Butter.
      $9.11

    • French Toast

      Fresh Made-to-Order French Toast. Served with Syrup and Butter.
      $8.06

    • PB & J Bagel

      Peanut Butter and Grape Jelly on a fresh Bagel.
      $6.24

    • Oatmeal

      Quaker Oats Oatmeal, made with Water or Milk.
      $4.36

    • Grilled Cheese

      Super Tasty Grilled Cheese with American Cheese, on White Bread.
      $4.99

    • Croissant With Nutella

      Fresh Baked Croissant with Nutella Spread.
      $6.86

    • BLT On A Bagel

      Bacon, Lettuce, and Tomato on a Fresh Bagel.
      $7.19

    • Mini Bagel With Spread

      Mini bagel, choice of plain, everything, or sesame. Spread options include butter, plain, or flavored cream cheese.
      $1.89

    • Special* Bagel With Maple Candied Pecan Cream Cheese

      Fresh bagel with maple candied pecan cream cheese.
      $4.95

  • Omelet Station

    • Build Your Own Omelet

      Build your own Omelet. Served with Home Fries and Toast.
      $7.24

    • Veggie Omelet

      Fresh Omelet made with Garden Vegetables. Served with Home Fries and Toast.
      $10.99

    • Western Omelet

      Fresh Omelet with Ham, Peppers, and Onion. Served with Home Fries and Toast.
      $11.24

    • Healthy Omelet

      Fresh Omelet with Egg Whites, Turkey Bacon, Spinach, and Swiss. Served with Homefries and Toast
      $12.49

    • Italian Omelet

      Fresh Omelet with Sausage, Tomato, and Roasted Peppers.
      $11.24

    • Greek Omelet

      Fresh Omelet with Olives, Feta Cheese, and Tomato. Served with Home Fries and Toast.
      $11.24

  • Fresh & New Specials

    • Special* Deluxe Fresh Lox Bagel

      Fresh Bagel with Gold Label Fresh Smoked Salmon, Dill Cucumber Cream Cheese, Capers, Seasonal Tomato
      $13.95

    • CIB Snack Wrap

      Chicken Cutlet, American Cheese, Lettuce, Ranch Dressing in a Wrap, Snack-wrap Style! (Can Substitute for BBQ Sauce)
      $10.61

    • Smash Burger W/ Fries

      Smash burger served with fries, typically includes a beef patty on a brioche bun with lettuce, tomato, onions, and a blend of condiments.
      $13.49

    • Special* Cubano Hero

      Home-made Pulled Pork, BH Ham, Imported Swiss, Mustard, and Pickle Chips pressed on an Italian Hero. Can't miss!
      $14.95

  • Og Classic Artisan Sandwiches

    • Chicken Surprise

      Fresh Chicken Cutlets with Bacon and American Cheese.
      $10.99

    • Chicken Primavera

      Fresh Grilled Chicken with Fresh Mozzarella, Pesto, and Tomato.
      $10.99

    • The Gong

      Buffalo Chicken Breast, Melted Cheddar, Avocado, Teriyaki (Recommended on a Sesame Bagel)
      $11.99

    • Crazey Combo

      Hot Roast Beef, Roasted Turkey, Imported Bacon, Melted American Cheese (Recommended on Everything Bagel)
      $12.99

    • #10

      Cold Roast Beef, Muenster Cheese, Peter Luger Sauce, Red Onion. (Recommended on an Original Wrap)
      $11.99

    • All-American

      Cold Roast Beef, Roasted Turkey, Original Ham, Swiss and American Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato. (Recommended on Hero Bread)
      $13.74

    • Sheepshead Bay

      Hot Homemade Roast Beef with Melted Cheddar and Brown Gravy. (Recommended on Plain Bagel)
      $11.99

    • Italian Classic

      Prosciutto, Soppressata, Pepperoni, Fresh Mozzarella, Roasted Peppers. (Recommended on Sesame Bagel)
      $13.74

    • NY Pastrami Sandwich

      Hot Pastrami with Melted Swiss and Cole-slaw. (Recommended on Pumpernickel Bagel)
      $12.49

    • Chicken Parm

      Fresh Chicken Cutlets with House Tomato Sauce, Fresh Mozzarella, Pecorino Romano, and Fresh Basil. (Recommended on Hero Bread)
      $11.99

    • Tuna Melt

      Fresh Tuna Salad with melted American Cheese. (Recommended on Everything Bagel)
      $9.99

    • Philly Cheese-Steak

      Thin Sliced Chuck Roast grilled up with American Cheese, Grilled Onions & Mixed Peppers, and Mayo. Recommended on Sesame Bagel.
      $11.99

    • Hamburger With Fries

      Traditional Hamburger on a Bun, served with French Fries, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, and Pickles.
      $11.99

  • Select Salads

    • Garden Salad

      Fresh Romaine Lettuce with Tomatoes, Cucumber, Bell Peppers, and Red Onion.
      $7.44

    • Simple Green Salad

      Fresh Romaine Lettuce and Cherry Tomatoes.
      $7.99

    • Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad

      Romaine Lettuce, Grilled Chicken, Tomato, Pecorino Romano, Croutons
      $12.49

    • Grilled Chicken Avocado Salad

      Romaine Lettuce, Grilled Chicken, Tomato, Avocado, Cheddar
      $13.69

    • Tuna Garden Salad

      Fresh Garden Salad with our Original Tuna Salad.
      $11.99

    • Shrimp Garden Salad

      Fresh Garden Salad with our House Shrimp Salad.
      $13.11

  • Side Orders

    • Bacon Side Order

      5 strips of Boar's Head Imported Bacon.
      $6.86

    • Sausage Side Order

      Boars's Head Imported Sausage
      $6.24

    • Turkey Bacon Side Order

      Side order of Turkey Bacon.
      $7.49

    • French Fries

      Fresh Made-to-Order French Fries.
      $5.61

    • Home Fries Order

      Homemade Home Fries with Russet Potatoes, Onions, and Peppers
      $5.61

    • Hashbrowns Side Order

      Fresh Fried Hashbrown Patties.
      $6.24

    • Chicken Wings & French Fries

      Fried Chicken Wings and French Fries, Made-to-Order
      $12.49

  • Fresh Bagels & Bread

    • Fresh Baked Bagel

      Our Famous Hand-rolled, Kettled Cooked Bagel, made with the finest ingredients in Brooklyn.
      $1.56

    • Flagel

      Our same Famous Bagels, flattened before baking.
      $1.99

    • Mini-Bagel

      Mini-Bagels: perfect miniature versions of our Hand-rolled, Kettle Cooked beauties.
      $1.25

    • Bialys

      Bell's Bialys, traditional.
      $1.56

  • Handcrafted Cream Cheese Spreads

    • Special* Apple-Pie Cheesecake Cream Cheese

      Fresh Cream Cheese made with a Caramel Apple Pie filling and Homemade Graham Cracker Crust.

    • Special* Roasted Garlic & Herbs Cream Cheese

      Cream Cheese Spread made with Slow Roasted Garlic and a Herb Medley.

    • Special* Cucumber Dill Cream Cheese

      Cream Cheese with Fresh Dill, Cucumbers, and Seasoning.

    • Plain Cream Cheese

      Cream Cheese Spread; available in qtr lb., half lb., and one lb. sizes.

    • Scallion Cream Cheese

      Scallion cream cheese, available in qtr lb., half lb., or one lb. options.

    • Veggie Cream Cheese

      Garden Vegetable Cream Cheese Spread

    • Lox Spread

      Fresh Lox Spread made with locally smoked Catsmo Salmon.

    • Lox Scallion Spread

      Handcrafted cream cheese with lox and scallions. Available in quarter, half, or one-pound sizes.

    • Jalapeño Cheddar Cream Cheese

      Spicy jalapeño mixed with sharp cheddar in a creamy spread. Sizes: quarter lb, half lb, or one lb.

    • Olive Cream Cheese

      Olive cream cheese available in qtr lb., half lb., or one lb. options.

    • Strawberry Cream Cheese

      Strawberry Cream Cheese with Fresh Strawberries.

    • Choco Choco Chip

      Chocolate infused Cream Cheese with Belgian Chocolate Chunks.

    • Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese

      Cream Cheese with a Cinnamon Infusion, mixed with Walnuts and California Raisins.

    • Tofu Cream Cheese

      Plant-based Cream Cheese spread. Vegan friendly.

    • Tofu Veggie Cream Cheese

      Plant-based Cream Cheese and Garden Vegetables

    • Tofu Scallion Cream Cheese

      Plant-based Cream Cheese and Scallions Spread.

    • Special* Maple Candied Pecan CC

      Homemade Cream Cheese with Whipped Real Maple Syrup and Candied Pecans.
      $14.49

  • Fresh Lox By The Pound

    • Gold Label Smoked Salmon

      Gold Label Smoked Salmon has made Catsmo what it is today. Instead of using a brine, it's hand-salted \r\nand smoked with the perfect blend of apple and cherry woods. More importantly, the salmon we use has never been frozen, giving it an undeniably silky texture and deep orange color!

  • Fresh Salads/Spreads

    • Original Tuna Salad

      Original Tuna Salad with Mayo and Veggies.

    • Spicy Tuna Salad

      Tuna Salad made with Spicy Peppers, and Mustard Mayo.

    • Plain Tuna

      Tuna Fish and Mayo, no vegetables.

    • Italian Tuna Salad

      Tuna Salad made with Red Onion, Lemon Juice, and Olive Oil.

    • Chicken Salad

      House Roasted Chicken Breast with Mayo and Vegetables.

    • Chipotle Chicken Salad

      Chicken Salad made with Chipotle and Cherry Peppers.

    • Egg Salad

      Homemade Boiled Egg Salad.

    • Whitefish Salad

    • Baked Salmon Salad

    • Shrimp Salad

      Tiger Shrimp Salad with Mayo and Scallions.

    • Seafood Salad

      Tiger Shrimp, Pollock , Citrus, Olive Oil

    • Potato Salad

      Homemade Classic Potato Salad

    • Macaroni Salad

      Homemade Classic Macaroni Salad

    • Cole-Slaw

      Homemade Classic Cole-slaw

    • Chickpea Salad

      Chickpea Salad with Cucumber and Tomato.

  • Cold Cuts/ Chicken By The Pound

    • Original Ham

      Boar's Head Ham sliced to order.

    • Virginia Ham

      Boars Head Virginia Ham

    • Ovengold Turkey

      Boar's Head Ovengold Turkey sliced to order.

    • Maple Honey Turkey

      Boar's Head Maple Honey Turkey sliced to order.

    • Salsalito Turkey

      Boar's head salsalito turkey sliced to order

    • Cracked Pepper Mill Turkey

      Boar's Head Cracked Pepper Turkey sliced to order.

    • Salsalito Turkey

      Boar's Head Salsalito Turkey sliced to order

    • Blazin Buffalo Chicken

      Boar's Head Blazin Buffalo Chicken sliced to order

    • House Roast Beef

      Homemade Roast Beef sliced to order.

    • House Fresh Chicken Cutlets

      Homemade Breaded Chicken Cutlets, made FRESH!

    • House Grilled Chicken Cutlets

      Homemade Marinated and Grilled Chicken Cutlets

    • Pastrami

      Boar's Head Pastrami sliced to order.

    • Bologna

      Boar's Heas Bologna sliced to order.

    • Genoa Salami

      Boar's Head Genoa Salami sliced to order.

    • Pepperoni

      Boar's Head Pepperoni sliced to order.

    • Soppressata Sweet

      Boar's Head Sweet Soppressata sliced to order.

    • American Cheese

      Boar's Head American Cheese sliced to order.

    • Monterey Pepper Jack

      Monterey Pepper Jack sliced to order.

    • Imported Swiss

      Boar's Head Imported Swiss sliced to order.

    • Lacey Swiss

      Boar's Head Lacey Swiss sliced to order

    • Muenster

      Boar's Head Muenster Cheese sliced to order.

    • Deli Mozzarella

      Boar's Head Mozzarella sliced to order.

    • Provolone

      Boar's Head Provolone sliced to order.

    • Sharp Cheddar

      Boar's Head Wisconsin Cheddar sliced to order

  • Baker's Basket

    • All Butter Croissant

      Fresh Baked All Butter Croissant
      $2.81

    • Chocolate Croissant

      Fresh Baked Croissant with Chocolate.
      $3.13

    • Cheese Danish

      Fresh Baked Danish with Cheese filling.
      $3.13

    • Apple Turnover

      Fresh Baked Puff Pastry with Apple Filling.
      $3.13

    • Blueberry Danish

      Fresh Baked Danish with Blueberry & Cheese Filling.
      $3.13

    • Raspberry Danish

      Fresh Baked Raspberry Bear Claw
      $3.44

    • Large Cookie

      Large Cookie from Randa Bakery. (Selection)
      $3.44

    • Yogurt Muffins

      Yogurt Muffins baked locally. (Selection)
      $3.57

    • 7-Layer Cookies

      The BEST Rainbow Cookies from Sal & Jerry's Bakery.

    • Sal & Jerry Cookies

      One pound of small cookies from Sal & Jerry's Bakery.
      $9.99

    • Large Fudge Brownie

      Home-made Chocolate Brownie
      $3.74

  • Fruit, Chips & Snacks

    • Special* Fall Fruit Salad

      Cotton Candy Grapes, Fuji Apples and Granny Smith Apples, Blackberries, Pomegranate Seeds, Orange Zest
      $7.25

    • Strawberry Yogurt Parfait

      Strawberry Low-fat Yogurt with side of Oat Granola.
      $4.99

    • Hal's Kettle Chips

      Hal's Kettle Chips(Assorted)
      $2.49

    • Candy

      Selection of Candy.
      $2.50

    • Gum/Mints

      A selection of refreshing mints and gum, typically offered in various minty flavors to freshen your breath.
      $3.13

    • Bare Fruit Chips

      Crisp and lightly sweetened, bare fruit chips are made from thinly sliced fruits that are baked to perfection, offering a crunchy and wholesome snack alternative.
      $4.49

    • Bag Of Chips

      Assorted Bags of Chips
      $3.11

    • La Fermiere Yogurt

      A family owned French Yogurt known for its traditional savoir-faire. Combining the finest ingredients to bring together a delicious all natural premium yogurt
      $5.49

  • Hot Coffee/Tea*

    • Fresh Coffee

      Hot coffee, choice of small, medium, or large. Milk options include regular, almond, hazelnut, French vanilla creamer, skim, 2%, or served black.

    • Flavored Hot Coffee

      Hot(french vanilla, hazelnut).

    • Lipton Black Tea

      Black Tea from Lipton.

    • Herbal Hot Tea

      Herbal hot tea in three sizes. Choice of green, breakfast black, Earl Grey, to chai spice, and more. Optional milk additions from black to French vanilla creamer.

    • Box Of Coffee

      Serves 15 people
      $35.93

  • Iced Drinks*

    • Iced Coffee

      Fresh Brewed Iced Coffee. Brewed Double Strength and Flash Chilled to lock in flavor and freshness.

    • Fresh Squeezed Lemonade

      Fresh Squeezed Lemonade. Super Refreshing!

    • Fresh Brewed Iced Tea

      Fresh brewed, served iced. Choice of black or green tea. Available in small or large.

    • Decaf Iced Coffee

      Fresh Brewed Decaffeinated Iced Coffee.

    • Arnold Palmer

      Fresh Brewed Black Tea with Fresh Squeezed Lemonade.

    • Fiddy Fiddy

      Fresh Brewed Peach Black Tea with Fresh Squeezed Lemonade.

  • Fresh Squeezed Juices*

    • Fresh Orange Juice

      Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice

    • Fresh Carrot Juice

      Fresh Squeezed Carrot Juice

    • Fresh Cucumber Celery Juice

      Fresh Pressed Cucumber and Celery Juice.

    • Fresh Carrot Orange Juice

      Fresh Squeezed Carrot and Orange Juice.

  • Bottled Water/Seltzer

    • Poland Spring Water

      Poland Spring

    • Essentia

      Essentia still water with Electrolytes

    • Core Water

      Core still water with Electrolytes.
      $4.99

    • Waiakea Still Water

      Waiakea still water. Choose from 500ml or 1 liter sizes.

    • Smart Water

    • Hal's NY Seltzer( Assorted)

      20oz Hal's Seltzer, made in NY.
      $3.13

    • Canada Dry Seltzer Can

      A refreshing sparkling water, offering a crisp and clean taste for hydration.
      $1.56

    • Canada Dry Seltzer Bottle

      Canada Dry Seltzer in the bottle
      $3.13

    • Spindrift Sparkling Water

      Spindrift Sparkling Water with Real Squeezed Fruit
      $4.36

    • Vitamin Water

      Hydrating Lemon Water
      $3.11

    • Vita Coco

      Coconut Water, not from concentrate, in sustainable packaging.
      $4.36

  • Refreshing Soft Drinks

    • Can Of Soda (Assorted)

      Assorted Cans of Soda/Seltzer
      $1.88

    • 20 Oz Bottles Of Soda(Assorted)

      20oz Bottles of Soda. Assorted Selection.
      $3.13

    • 2 Liter Soda

      2 Liter Soda. Assorted Selection.
      $4.99

    • Mexican Coca Cola Glass

      Coca Cola in the Glass bottle. Made in Mexico.
      $3.74

    • Mexican Sprite Glass

      Sprite in the Glass Bottle. Made in Mexico.
      $3.74

    • Boylans Soda

      Soda made with real cane sugar. Served in a glass bottle.
      $3.74

    • Sparkling Ice Beverage

      Sparkling Beverage with Zero Sugar
      $3.44

    • Arizona Bottle 16.9oz

      Assorted Arizona Bottles
      $3.13

    • Arizona Bottle 34oz

      Arizona 34oz bottle in seven flavors including original lemon, peach, and green tea ginseng. Fruit punch, watermelon, mango, and sweet tea options available.
      $4.38

    • Arizona Cold Brew Tea

      Arizona cold brew tea selections including lemon, peach, and green tea variations. Sweet tea option available.
      $3.74

    • Snapple Bottle (Assorted)

      Assorted Snapple bottles: tea and juice flavors including lemon, peach, and raspberry—options with zero sugar available. Selections also feature unique tastes like go bananas, grapeade, and raspberry peach.
      $3.44

    • Pure Leaf Tea

      Pure Leaf Tea in 18.5oz Bottle
      $3.13

    • Aloe-Vine Beverage

      Aloe Vera mixed beverages.
      $2.49

    • Yoo-Hoo Chocolate Drink

      Yoo-hoo Chocolate drink in the glass bottle.

    • Bai Antioxidant Beverage

      Bai Antioxidant Beverage Selection
      $3.44

  • Sports Drinks

    • Gatorade 20oz

      Gatorade Sports Drink 20oz Bottle
      $3.13

    • Gatorade Large

      Gatorade Sports Drink 28oz Bottle
      $4.38

    • Electrolit Beverage

      Hydration-focused sports drink available in flavors: lemon lime, blue raspberry, fruit punch, grape, guava, strawberry kiwi.
      $4.99

  • Energy/Coffee (Bottled)

    • Red Bull Selection

      Red Bull Energy Drink, Assorted Flavors and Sizes.
      $3.74

    • Monster Energy

      Monster Energy Cans
      $4.38

    • Celsius Sparkling Energy

      Variety of flavors including mango passionfruit, berry blends, citrus, and exotic fruits. Refreshing choice for an energy boost.
      $4.38

    • Manhattan Special Coffee Soda

      Manhattan Special Coffee Soda in a glass bottle.
      $3.44

    • Starbucks Frappuccino

      Starbucks Frappuccino in the glass bottle.

    • Starbucks Espresso & Cream

      Starbucks Espresso and Cream in a can.
      $4.38

    • Starbucks Doubleshot Energy

      Starbucks Doubleshot Energy Beverage 15oz
      $6.24

  • Refreshing Juices (Bottled)

    • Martinelli's Apple Juice

      Martinelli's 100% Apple Juice in Glass Bottle.
      $4.36

    • Naked Juice

      Non-Gmo Juices 15 2oz
      $5.63

    • Natalie's Grapefruit Juice

      16oz bottle of Pure Grapefruit Juice.
      $6.49

    • Natalie's Guava Lemonade

      Natalie's guava lemonade is a tropical blend of guava and lemon, typically includes natural sweetness and citrus zest.
      $6.49

    • Natalie's Mango-Orange Juice

      Made with fresh mangoes and oranges, Natalie's mango-orange juice typically includes a blend rich in vitamin C and antioxidants.
      $6.49

    • Natalie's Orange Juice

      16oz bottle of Pure Orange Juice.
      $6.49

    • Natalie's Pineapple-Orange Juice

      Natalie's pineapple-orange juice is made from fresh pineapples and oranges, typically rich in vitamin C and folate, supporting immune function and overall wellness.
      $6.49

    • Natalie's Strawberry Lemonade

      Natalie's Strawberry Lemonade. All-natural.
      $6.49

    • Tropicana 12oz Bottle

      Tropicana in a 12oz bottle. Choose from: no pulp, some pulp, calcium, apple, grape, cranberry cocktail, lemonades, and island punch options.
      $3.36

    • Tropicana 14oz Carton

      Classic Tropicana Juices in the Carton.
      $3.36

    • Tropicana 15oz Bottle

      15oz Tropicana in various flavors: Orange, Pineapple Orange, Apple, Ruby Red Grapefruit, Grape, Strawberry Kiwi, and Cranberry.
      $3.36

    • Tropicana 32oz Bottle

      Tropicana 32oz Bottles Selection
      $4.61

    • Tropicana 52oz

      Tropicana 52oz Bottles Selection
      $8.11

    • Tropicana Lively Lemonade 52oz

      Tropicana Lemonade in 52oz Bottle
      $6.86

    • V8 Vegetable Juice

      V8 Juice in the bottle.
      $3.49

  • Milk/Dairy

    • Half Gallon Milk( Assorted)

      Tuscan Half Gallon Milk, Assorted %
      $4.99

    • Gallon Whole Milk

      Tuscan Whole Milk Gallon
      $6.24

    • Quart Whole Milk

      Tuscan Quart of Whole Milk
      $4.99

    • Half & Half

      Tuscan Half & Half

    • Nesquik

      Nesquik Assorted Milks
      $3.44

    • Coffee Mate Creamer

      Flavored Coffee Creamers
      $8.74

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6
Loading...

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms