Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
Lunch Pasta
Your choice of pasta and sauce
$10.99
NY Hand Tossed Pizza
Medium
$19.99
Lunch Alfredo
Fettuccine Alfredo with pasta options including angel hair to gluten-free. Choose between house, Caesar salad with various dressings or soup of the day. Available 11am-3pm.
$11.99
Lunch Lasagna with One Roll.
Lasagna served with a roll. Options: house or Caesar salad with choice of dressings; soup of the day. 11am-3pm.
$9.99
Legendary Garlic knots
(4) Crispy clouds of garlic, olive oil, butter and parmesan .
$9.99
Pauly's Lunch
2 one topping slices of pizza and a drink.
$9.99
Lunch Caesar Salad in a Bread Bowl
Crisp romaine lettuce, crunchy croutons, and shaved parmesan cheese, served in a bread bowl with Caesar dressing.
$10.99
Mozzarella Sticks
(6) Breaded, fried and served with a side of marinara.
$11.99
Lunch Spaghetti
With Sunday sauce or meat sauce with one roll.
$12.99
Lunch Stromboli
Golden-brown rolled pizza dough filled with pepperoni, mozzarella, and vegetables, served with marinara sauce.
$10.99
Lunch Specials 11am-3pm
Lunch Specials 11am-3pm
Lunch Pasta
Your choice of pasta and sauce
$10.99
Lunch Pasta with Broccoli with Garlic & Olive Oil
with olive oil and parmesan.
$11.99
Pauly's Lunch
2 one topping slices of pizza and a drink.
$9.99
Lunch Lasagna with One Roll.
Lasagna served with a roll. Options: house or Caesar salad with choice of dressings; soup of the day. 11am-3pm.
$9.99
Lunch Spaghetti
With Sunday sauce or meat sauce with one roll.
$12.99
Soup, Salad and One Roll
Served with a cup of our soup of the day, House or caesar salad & a freshly baked legendary garlic knot. Add a protein to your salad for an additional fee.
$8.99
Lunch Caesar Salad in a Bread Bowl
Crisp romaine lettuce, crunchy croutons, and shaved parmesan cheese, served in a bread bowl with Caesar dressing.
$10.99
Lunch Alfredo
Fettuccine Alfredo with pasta options including angel hair to gluten-free. Choose between house, Caesar salad with various dressings or soup of the day. Available 11am-3pm.
$11.99
Lunch Pepperoni Bread
Stuffed bread with pepperoni slices and herbs, served with a side of marinara sauce.
$10.99
Lunch Stromboli
Golden-brown rolled pizza dough filled with pepperoni, mozzarella, and vegetables, served with marinara sauce.
$10.99
Appetizers
Cauliflower Fritta
Battered breadcrumb and parmesan cauliflower florets.
$12.99
Arancini
(2) Risotto stuffed with mozzarella, parmesan, breaded and fried.
$16.99
Mozzarella Caprese
Alternating layers of fresh mozzarella, basil and tomatoes drizzled with balsamic glaze.
$14.99
Meatball Boat
(2) Grandma's homemade meatballs with Sunday sauce and shaved parmesan.
$13.99
Spinach artichoke dip
Spinach, artichoke, parmesan, alfredo and mozzarella cheese served with toast points.
$13.99
Bruschetta
Tomato, basil and feta drizzled with balsamic reduction. Served with toast points.
$12.99
Legendary Garlic knots
(4) Crispy clouds of garlic, olive oil, butter and parmesan .
$9.99
Calamari
lightly breaded and flash fried with feta or gorgonzola. Traditional or fire.
$19.99
Bowl of Fries
Salted crinkle cut fries.
$10.99
Caesar Fries
Waffle fries tossed with caesar dressing, bacon and shaved parmesan.
$12.99
Mozzarella Sticks
(6) Breaded, fried and served with a side of marinara.
$11.99
Salads
Enjoy any salad in a bread bowl.
Warm Spinach Salad
Large portion of spinach, tomato, onion, fresh mushrooms, with warm bacon vinaigrette dressing. Add chicken, shrimp, eggplant for an additional charge.
$19.99
Caesar Salad
Large portion of romaine hearts, croutons, parmesan and croutons.
$18.99
House Salad
Large portion of salad mix, tomato, cucumber, onion and tomato and dressing.
$16.99
Gorgonzola Salad
Large portion of tomato, olives, cucumber, spring mix, onion and gorgonzola.
$19.99
House Made Soup of The Day
call restaurant for current soups
House Made Soup of The Day
Cup
$8.99
Heroes
Heros served with choice of Italian potato or pasta salad.
Meatball Parmigiana Hero
Size choice: half or whole. served with italian pasta salad or fries. submarine sandwich filled with meatball parmigiana.
$14.99
Chicken Parmigiana Hero
Half or whole submarine sandwich, breaded chicken, marinara, melted mozzarella. served with italian pasta salad or fries.
$14.99
Eggplant Parmigiana Hero
Half or whole eggplant parmigiana hero; served with italian pasta salad or fries.
$14.99
Shrimp Parmigiana Hero
Half or whole submarine sandwich, shrimp parmigiana, with italian pasta salad or fries.
$16.99
Bennys Italian Combo
salami, ham, capicola, mozzarella, balsamic glaze.
$16.99
Sausage, peppers, onions Hero
Half or whole submarine sandwich, italian sausage, peppers, onions. served with italian pasta salad or fries.
$14.99
Artichoke Grill Hero
sautéed artichoke, spinach, peppers, provolone in garlic aioli.
$14.99
Buffalo Chicken Hero
Tossed in a wing sauce with buffalo ranch
$14.99
Sammies Club Hero
Ham, turkey, bacon, provolone, lettuce, tomato, oil and vinegar.
$14.99
Burger
Big P Burger
1/2 pound burger, bacon, lettuce tomato and cheese.
$18.99
Wings
Bone-in Wings
10 Wings
10 wings, choice of sauce: buffalo, bbq, garlic parmesan, mango habanero, plain. served with celery sticks, blue cheese dip.
mozzarella, roasted tomatoes, onions, fresh basil ricotta base with a balsamic glaze.
$34.99
Cauliflower Craze (Sicilian)
Roasted cauliflower, garlic, ricotta, mozzarella with an olive oil base.
$36.99
White Pie (Sicilian)
Mozzarella, garlic, provolone and parmesan with a ricotta olive oil base.
$34.99
Nickaroni (Sicilian)
Pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon, meatball, salami and mozzarella with a red sauce base.
$36.99
Roman (Sicilian)
Chicken and mozzarella with a pesto base.
$34.99
Gypsy Danger (Sicilian)
ham, bacon, jalapeño, pineapple, onion, mozzarella and jerk aioli base.
$34.99
Zorro (Sicilian)
smoked brisket, cheddar, onion, bacon and hot honey with a BBQ sauce base.
$36.99
Bills Mafia (NY Hand-Tossed)
Buffalo sauce base with breaded buffalo chicken, mozzarella with choice of blue cheese crumbles or buffalo ranch. LETS GO BUFFALO
$27.99
Bills Mafia (Sicilian)
Buffalo sauce base with breaded buffalo chicken, mozzarella with choice of blue cheese crumbles or buffalo ranch. LETS GO BUFFALO
$36.99
Dinners
Dinners served with side of pasta and choice of soup or salad and 2 garlic knots.
Parmigiana
Your choice of Chicken, Shrimp or Eggplant with sunday sauce and mozzarella.
$33.99
Chicken Marsala
Mushroom marsala wine sauce
$34.99
Piccata
Your choice of Chicken, Shrimp or Eggplant with lemon caper white wine.
$34.99
Shrimp Scampi
sautéed in a garlic, butter, parmesan white wine.
$39.99
Chicken Marie
chicken, eggplant, spinach, mozzarella in a light alfredo plum sauce.
$39.99
Chicken Scarpiello
sausage, chicken pepperoncini, in a white wine caper sauce.
$39.99
Pasta
Served with salad and 2 garlic rolls. Select Your Pasta, Select Your Sauce, Specialty Sauce. Choose Ravioli or Tortellini for an additional charge. Add Chicken or shrimp for an additional charge. Add any regular pizza topping and any specialty Pizza topping for an additional charge.
Create Your Own Pasta
Choose pasta: angel hair to gluten-free. sauce: meat to alfredo. includes soup of the day, caesar, or house salad.
$24.99
Baked Spaghetti
Options: sauce choice (10 varieties including meat, pesto, and specialty sauces like plum alfredo), soup or salad (soup of the day, caesar, house). oven-baked spaghetti.
$29.99
Baked Lasagna
Sauce options: meat, sunday, garlic olive oil, pesto, 5 speciality sauces. includes soup or salad: day's, caesar, house. layered pasta.
$29.99
Baked Ziti
Sauce options: meat, sunday, garlic/olive oil, pesto, 5 speciality sauces. includes soup or salad: day's soup, caesar, house. oven-baked pasta.
$29.99
Baked Ravioli
Ravioli options: meat, sunday, garlic/olive oil, pesto, 5 speciality sauces. includes soup or salad.
$29.99
Manicotti
Manicotti with choice of sauce: meat, sunday, garlic olive oil, pesto, specialty clam or alfredo options. soup or salad included.