Black Sheep Bagels Menu

4.6

(150+ Reviews)

Omelette Whole Wheat Flats Acai Bowl Chips Muffin Smoked Salmon and Cream Cheese Flats Breakfast Sandwiches Featured Items Specialty Sandwiches Cream Cheese & Butter Drinks Paninis Parfaits Cold Cuts by the pound Bagels Create Your Own Sandwich Salads

Omelette
- Cheese Omelette
  3 eggs, cheese.
  $13.19
- The Western
  Ham, cheese, peppers and onions.
  $13.19
- Farm Fresh
  Turkey bacon, spinach, avocado and salsa.
  $13.19
- The Peconic Omelette
  Jalapeños, avocado, diced tomato, pepper Jack, mozzarella, chipotle hot sauce.
  $13.19
- The Nofo Omelette
  Roasted red peppers, sautéed spinach, fresh mozzarella, egg whites.
  $13.19
- Loco Pollo
  Grilled chicken, avocado, salsa and pepperJack cheese.
  $13.19
- The Main Road Omelette
  Sautéed spinach, onions, broccoli, goat cheese.
  $13.19
- Steak And Eggs
  London broil roast beef, peppers, onions, provolone.
  $13.19
- The Italian Omelette
  Ham, pepperoni, salami, provolone, red onion, tomato.
  $13.19
- South Beach
  Tomatoes, onions, olives and peppers.
  $13.19
- The Leo
  Lox and red onions.
  $15.54
Whole Wheat Flats
- Whole Wheat Flats (Dozen)
  $32.40
- Whole Wheat Flats (Each)
  $2.70
Acai Bowl
- The Tropical
  Acai, homemade gluten free granola, banana, mango, kiwi, pineapple, coconut flakes.
  $13.14
- The Original
  Acai, homemade gluten free granola, bananas, strawberries, blueberries, coconut flakes.
  $13.14
- The Date Night
  Acai, homemade gluten free granola, nutella, strawberry, sliced almonds.
  $13.14
- The Elvis
  Acai, homemade gluten free granola, banana, peanut butter, strawberry, chocolate chips.
  $13.14
Chips
- Buffalo Ranch Potato Chips
  $1.98
- Sweet Onion Potato Chips
  $1.98
- Original Sea Salt Potato Chips
  $1.98
- Honey BBQ Potato Chips
  $1.98
- Sea Salt And Vinegar Potato Chips
  $1.98
- Jalapeño Potato Chips
  $1.98
- Sweet Chili Potato Chips
  $1.98
- Hals Potato Chips
  $1.98
- BBQ Potato Chips
  $1.98
- Sour Cream And Onion Potato Chips
  $1.98
Muffin
- Triple Chocolate Brownie
  $4.20
- Chocolate Chip Muffin
  $4.20
- Corn Muffin
  $4.20
- Double Chocolate Chip Muffin
  $4.20
- Blueberry Crumb Muffin
  $4.20
Smoked Salmon and Cream Cheese
- Smoked Salmon And Cream Cheese
  Smoked salmon on your choice of bagel with your choice of cream cheese\n\n* time and temperature sensitive item
  $14.99
Flats
- Flats (Each)
  $2.70
- Flats (Dozen)
  $32.40
Breakfast Sandwiches
- Egg Whites With Bacon, Ham Or Sausage, Cheese
  $11.40
- The Hungry Woman
  Egg whites, Turkey bacon, spinach, Swiss.
  $11.99
- B.L.T (Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato)
  $10.79
- Egg And Cheese
  $7.19
- Bacon Egg And Cheese
  $10.20
- They Spicy Hobo
  Spicy. Two eggs, bacon, pepper Jack cheese, hash brown and hot sauce.
  $11.40
- The Black Sheeps Sandwich
  2 eggs, bacon, sausage, hash browns and syrup on a French Toast bagel
  $11.99
- Two Eggs
  $5.98
- Egg Whites And Cheese
  $8.39
- The Powerhouse
  Two egg whites, Turkey, lettuce, tomato and hot sauce in a wrap.
  $11.40
- Two Egg Whites
  $7.19
- North Fork Special
  Smoked salmon, cream cheese, red onion, capers, tomato on a bagel.
  $17.94
- Ham Egg And Cheese
  $10.20
- The Hungry Man
  Three eggs, bacon, ham, sausage, cheese and hash brown on a hero.
  $13.19
- Hobo
  Two eggs, bacon, cheese and hash brown.
  $11.40
- Sausage Egg And Cheese
  $10.20
Featured Items
- Tofu Scallion
  Per pound.
  $15.60
- Tofu Veggie Cream Cheese
  Per pound.
  $15.60
Specialty Sandwiches
- The Mattituck
  Honey Turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato, avocado, ranch in a wrap.
  $14.34
- Pastrami Reuben
  Pastrami, coleslaw and melted Swiss on rye.
  $16.79
- Pepper Turkey Fajita
  Pepper Turkey, sautéed onions, peppers, provolone, chipotle hot sauce in a wrap.
  $14.34
- The South Hampton Hero
  Roast beef with melted muenster on garlic hero with tomato and peter luger sauce.
  $14.34
- Breaded Chicken
  Fried cutlet, mozzarella, coleslaw, balsamic.
  $16.34
- Chicken Quesadilla
  Grilled chicken with melted muenster salsa and chipotle mayo
  $14.34
- The Southold Wrap
  Breaded chicken cutlet in buffalo sauce, blue cheese and lettuce in a wrap.
  $14.34
- Greek Chicken Wrap
  Grilled chicken with lettuce, tomato, onion and tzatziki sauce in a wrap.
  $14.34
- Hampton Bays
  Turkey, ham, Swiss, Russian and coleslaw on rye.
  $14.34
- Uncle Phil
  Roast beef, peppers, onions, jalapeno cream cheese in a sundried tomato wrap.
  $14.34
- The Montauk
  Roast beef, Swiss, Russian and coleslaw on rye
  $14.34
- The Love Lane Wrap
  Fried egg plant, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, boars head dressing in a wrap.
  $14.34
- Chicken Fingers And Curly Fries
  comes with 4 chicken tenders and 2 handfull's of seasoned Curly fries with 1 dipping sauce. extra sauce is $0.75 extra per sauce\n-Buffalo\n-Boom Boom sauce\n-Sweet and sour\n-Honey Mustard\n-Sweet Baby Rays BBQ sauce
  $15.54
- The Black Sheeps Sandwich
  2 eggs, bacon, sausage, hash brown, syrup on French toast bagel
  $14.34
- The Aquebogue
  Fried chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella, bacon, lettuce, tomato, bbq sauce.
  $16.34
- The Spicy Roast Beef
  Spicy. Grilled roast beef with onions, cheddar, bacon and horseradish mayo.
  $16.34
- The East Hampton
  Pastrami, Turkey, coleslaw and Russian on rye.
  $16.79
- The Jamesport
  Grilled chicken, pepper Jack cheese, bacon, tomato, sweet baby rays bbq sauce.
  $16.34
- Pastrami Southwestern
  Pastrami, pepper Jack cheese on grilled rye with coleslaw in a wrap.
  $16.79
- The Hot Italian
  Hot ham, pepperoni, salami, red onion, lettuce, tomato, melted provolone.
  $16.34
- Egg Salad
  Egg salad with smoked salmon, red onion, tomato.
  $16.34
- The Quogue
  Pastrami, onions, melted Swiss, coleslaw on grilled rye.
  $16.79
Cream Cheese & Butter
- Vegetable Cream Cheese By The Pound
  $3.60
- Scallion Cream Cheese By The Pound
  $3.60
- Honey Cranberry Cream Cheese On A Bagel
  $6.30
- Smoked Salmon
  Thin Sliced Acme Smoked Salmon\n*note temperature sensitive item*
  $16.50
- Tofu Cream Cheese On A Bagel
  $5.70
- Strawberry Cream Cheese On A Bagel
  $7.19
- Tofu Vegetable Cream Cheese On A Bagel
  $7.19
- Tofu Cream Cheese By The Pound
  $3.60
- Butter On A Bagel
  $4.20
- Tofu Vegetable Cream Cheese By The Pound
  $3.90
- Honey Cranberry Cream Cheese By The Pound
  $3.90
- Butter By The Pound
  $3.00
- Scallion Cream Cheese On A Bagel
  $5.70
- Strawberry Cream Cheese By The Pound
  $3.90
- Tofu Scallion Cream Cheese On A Bagel
  $7.19
- Jalepeño Cream Cheese By The Pound
  $3.90
- Jalepeño Cream Cheese On A Bagel
  $6.30
- Plain Cream Cheese By The Pound
  $3.30
- Cucumber Dill Cream Cheese On A Bagel
  $6.30
- Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese By The Pound
  $3.90
- Olive Cream Cheese By The Pound
  $3.90
- Tofu Scallion Cream Cheese By Pound
  $3.90
- Lox Cream Cheese By The Pound
  $4.80
- Plain Cream Cheese On A Bagel
  $5.10
- Lox Cream Cheese On A Bagel
  $8.39
- Olive Cream Cheese On A Bagel
  $6.30
- Cucumber Dill Cream Cheese By The Pound
  $3.90
- Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese On A Bagel
  $6.30
- Vegetable Cream Cheese On A Bagel
  $5.70
Drinks
- Nesquik
  $3.90
- Yerba Mate
  $5.40
- Canned Drinks
  $2.40
- Bottle Drinks
  $3.30
- Coffee
  Drip coffee available in 12oz, 16oz, 20oz.\n\n* please note coffee may be cool by the time it arrives depending on the speed and efficiency of the door dash driver
  $3.00
- Montauk
  $3.30
- Natalies Orange Juice
  $4.20
- Pure Leaf
  Brewed using freshly picked tea leaves so every sip is as sweet as the last.
  $3.90
- Snapple
  $3.30
- Vitamin Water
  Vitamin and nutrient-enhanced water beverage with electrolytes and other good stuff.
  $3.90
- Water
  $2.10
- Essentia 20 Oz Water
  $3.60
- Iced Coffee
  $4.50
- Gatorade
  A crisp, satisfying taste to quench thirst and energize without caffeine
  $3.30
- Celcius
  $5.40
- Orange Juice
  $3.90
- Hals
  $3.30
- Red Bull 8.4oz
  $4.20
Paninis
- The AC/DC Panini
  Breaded chicken, bacon, cheddar, ranch on home baked white bread.
  $15.54
- The Slightly Stoopid Panini
  Breaded chicken cutlet, chipotle gouda chipotle mayo, bacon tomato.
  $15.54
- The Foo Fighters Panini
  Grilled chicken, sautéed spinach, roasted red peppers fresh mozzarella, balsamic dressing.
  $15.54
- The David Grohl Panini
  Roast beef, melted muenster, onions horseradish sauce on a hero.
  $15.54
- The Elton John Panini
  Turkey, coleslaw, Russian on whole grain bread.
  $15.54
- The Slash Panini
  Ham, Swiss, mustard on rye.
  $15.54
- The Coheed Cubano
  Ham, Swiss, pickles, onions, mustard.
  $15.54
- The Billy Joel Panini
  Grilled chicken, avocado, tomato, tzatziki sauce on whole grain bread.
  $15.54
- The Beatles Panini
  Fried eggplant, sautéed spinach, roasted red peppers fresh mozzarella, balsamic glaze.
  $15.54
- The Dave Matthews Panini
  Sautéed spinach, tomato, fresh mozzarella and pesto on a rosemary garlic ciabatta topped with balsamic glaze.
  $15.54
Parfaits
- Classic Parfait
  Vanilla yogurt, gluten free granola, strawberries, blueberries, coconut flakes
  $8.39
Cold Cuts by the pound
- Roast Beef
  $4.50
- Smoked Pastrami
  $7.50
- Bologna
  $4.50
- Ham
  $4.50
- Turkey
  $4.50
- Honey Turkey
  $4.50
- Pepperoni
  $4.50
- Genoa Salami
  $4.50
Bagels
- Pretzel Bagel
  $4.20
- Jalapeno Cheddar Bacon
  $4.20
- Cinnamon French Toast Bagel
  $2.40
- Whole Wheat
  Each.
  $2.10
- Onion
  Each.
  $2.10
- Bagel Dozen
  $25.20
- Pretzel Bagel
  $4.20
- Pumpernickel Everything
  Each.
  $2.10
- Whole Wheat Everything
  Each.
  $2.10
- French Toast Bagel
  $2.70
- Asiago Cheese
  $4.20
- Mozzarella Garlic Herb
  $4.20
- Salt
  Each.
  $2.10
- Whole Wheat Sesame
  Each.
  $2.10
- French Toast Bagel
  $2.70
- Mozzarella Garlic Herb Bagel
  $4.20
- Garlic
  Each.
  $2.10
- Egg Everything
  Each.
  $2.10
- Jalapeno Cheddar
  $4.20
- Sesame
  Each.
  $2.10
- Egg Bagel
  Each.
  $2.10
- Jalapeno Cheddar
  $4.20
- Pumpernickel
  Each.
  $2.10
- Poppy
  Each.
  $2.10
- Asiago Cheese
  $4.20
- Plain
  Each.
  $2.10
- Cinnamon Raisin
  Each.
  $2.10
- Cinnamon French Toast Bagel
  $2.70
- Everything
  Each.
  $2.10
Create Your Own Sandwich
- Create Your Own Sandwich
  $10.79
Salads
- Potato Salad By The Pound
  $3.00
- Egg Salad Sandwich
  $10.79
- Chicken Salad Sandwich
  $11.99
- Whitefish Salad By The Pound
  $5.40
- Coleslaw By The Pound
  $3.00
- Macaroni Salad By The Pound
  $3.00
- Tuna Salad Sandwich
  $11.99
- Whitefish Salad Sandwich
  $13.19
- Egg Salad By The Pound
  $4.20
- Chicken Salad By The Pound
  $4.80
- Tuna Salad By The Pound
  $4.80