Bill Gray's Penfield Menu

4.3

(1,225+ Reviews)

Customer Favorites Bill's Famous Burgers Sandwiches Great Plates®Chicken Seafood Side Orders Beverages Condiments on the Side

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- World's Greatest Cheeseburger®
  5 oz ground steak served on a fresh-baked Di Paolo hard roll topped with 2 slices of American cheese & your choice of toppings
  $9.19
- French Fries Regular
  Regular or Basket
  $6.49
- Cheeseburger Plate
  (2) 3 oz Cheeseburgers served on top of 2 side items of your choice
  $17.29
- Bottled Soda
  Pepsi Products
  $3.89
- Curly Fries Regular
  Regular or Basket
  $6.49
- Onion Rings Regular
  Regular or Basket
  $6.89
- Chicken Tenders 5pc Only
  5pc or 10pc with your choice of dipping sauce
  $11.49
- French Fries Well Done Regular
  Regular or Basket
  $6.49
- Bacon Cheeseburger
  The World's Greatest Cheeseburger® topped with crispy bacon
  $11.49
- Milkshakes Regular
  Small, Medium or Large
  $8.09
Bill's Famous Burgers
- World's Greatest Cheeseburger®
  5 oz ground steak served on a fresh-baked Di Paolo hard roll topped with 2 slices of American cheese & your choice of toppings
  $9.19
- Bacon Cheeseburger
  The World's Greatest Cheeseburger® topped with crispy bacon
  $11.49
- Bubba Double Cheeseburger
  50¢ from every Bubba Double Cheeseburger purchase is donated to the Wease Cares Children’s Fund
  $14.99
- Mushroom Swiss Burger
  The Ground Steak Burger topped with Swiss cheese and grilled mushrooms
  $11.19
- Bubba Double Bacon Cheeseburger
  50¢ from every Bubba Double Bacon Cheeseburger purchase is donated to the Wease Cares Children’s Fund
  $17.29
- Honey BBQ Bacon Cheeseburger
  The World's Greatest Cheeseburger® topped with crispy bacon and honey BBQ sauce
  $11.49
- Grilled Cheeseburger Melt
  5 oz ground steak served on grilled white bread topped with 2 slices of American cheese
  $9.19
- Bacon Bleu Burger
  The Ground Steak Burger topped with crispy bacon, bleu cheese dressing
  $11.49
- Impossible Burger
  Served on a fresh baked Di Paolo hard roll topped with your choice of toppings
  $9.19
- Vegetarian Burger
  Served on a multigrain roll
  $9.19
- Black Bean Burger
  Served on a multigrain roll
  $9.19
- Ground Steak Burger
  5 oz ground steak served on a fresh baked Di Paolo hard roll topped with your choice of toppings
  $7.89
- Plate Burger
  The World's Greatest Cheeseburger® topped with french fries and mac salad
  $11.49
Sandwiches
- Crispy Chicken Fillet Sandwich
  Breaded chicken fillet served on a fresh-baked Di Paolo hard roll
  $9.19
- Grilled Chicken Breast Sandwich
  Served on a multigrain roll
  $10.39
- Crispy Buffalo Chicken Fillet Sandwich
  Breaded chicken fillet tossed in Buffalo sauce & served on a fresh-baked Di Paolo hard roll
  $9.19
- Italian Sausage
  Served on a fresh baked Di Paolo hard roll topped with your choice of toppings
  $8.99
- Philly Sliced Steak & Cheese
  Served on a fresh baked Di Paolo hoagie roll topped with grilled peppers, grilled onions & your choice of cheese
  $11.39
- Red Hot Dog
  ¼ lb Zweigle's® Red Hot Dog served on a fresh baked Di Paolo hoagie roll
  $8.09
- White Hot Dog
  ¼ lb Zweigle's® White Hot Dog served on a fresh-baked Di Paolo hoagie roll
  $8.09
Great Plates®
- Cheeseburger Plate
  (2) 3 oz Cheeseburgers served on top of 2 side items of your choice
  $17.29
- Chicken Tender Plate
  3pc Chicken Tenders served on top of 2 side items of your choice
  $17.29
- Grilled Cheese Plate
  (2) Grilled Cheese Sandwiches on white bread served on top of 2 side items of your choice
  $17.29
- Red Hot Dog Plate
  (2) ¼ lb Zweigle's® Red Hot Dogs served on top of 2 side items of your choice
  $17.29
- Cheeseburger & White Hot Dog Plate
  (1) 3 oz Cheeseburger & (1) ¼ lb Zweigle's® White Hot Dog served on top of 2 side items of your choice
  $17.29
- Ground Steak Burger Plate
  (2) 3oz Ground Steak Burgers served on top of 2 side items of your choice
  $17.29
- Impossible Burger Plate
  (1) Impossible Burger served on top of 2 side items of your choice
  $17.29
- Cheeseburger & Ground Steak Burger Plate
  (1) 3 oz Cheeseburger & (1) 3 oz Ground Steak Burger served on top of 2 side items of your choice
  $17.29
- Veggie Burger Plate
  (1) Vegetarian Burger served on top of 2 side items of your choice
  $17.29
- Ground Steak Burger & Red Hot Dog Plate
  (1) 3 oz Ground Steak Burger & (1) ¼ lb Zweigle's® Red Hot Dog served on top of 2 side items of your choice
  $17.29
- Ground Steak Burger & White Hot Dog Plate
  (1) 3 oz Ground Steak Burger & (1) ¼ lb Zweigle's® White Hot Dog served on top of 2 side items of your choice
  $17.29
- Red & White Hot Dog Plate
  (1) ¼ Zweigle's® Red Hot Dog & (1) ¼ Zweigle's® White Hot Dog served on top of 2 side items of your choice
  $17.29
- Cheeseburger & Red Hot Dog Plate
  (1) 3 oz Cheeseburger & (1) ¼ lb Zweigle's® Red Hot Dog served on top of 2 side items of your choice
  $17.29
- White Hot Dog Plate
  (2) ¼ lb Zweigle's® White Hot Dogs served on top of 2 side items of your choice
  $17.29
Chicken
- Chicken Tenders 5pc Only
  5pc or 10pc with your choice of dipping sauce
  $11.49
- Chicken Tenders 10pc Only
  5pc or 10pc with your choice of dipping sauce
  $22.89
- Buffalo Chicken Tenders 10pc Only
  5pc or 10pc tossed in Buffalo sauce with your choice of dipping sauce
  $22.89
- Buffalo Chicken Tenders 5pc Only
  5pc or 10pc tossed in Buffalo sauce with your choice of dipping sauce
  $11.49
Seafood
- Haddock Fish Sandwich
  Served on a fresh baked Di Paolo hoagie roll with your choice of toppings
  $12.69
- Bill's Famous Haddock Fish Fry
  Served with choice of any two sides: French Fries, Cole Slaw, Tater Tots or Macaroni Salad
  $20.69
- Mini Haddock Fish Fry
  Served with choice of any two sides: French Fries, Cole Slaw, Tater Tots or Macaroni Salad
  $18.29
Side Orders
- French Fries Regular
  Regular or Basket
  $6.49
- French Fries Well Done Regular
  Regular or Basket
  $6.49
- Onion Rings Regular
  Regular or Basket
  $6.89
- Curly Fries Regular
  Regular or Basket
  $6.49
- Mozzarella Sticks 6pc Mozzarella Sticks
  3pc, 6pc, or 9pc served with a side of marinara sauce
  $13.09
- French Fries Basket
  Regular or Basket
  $12.59
- Pizza Logs 4pc Pizza Logs
  2pc, 4pc, or 6pc served with a side of marinara sauce
  $12.19
- Onion Rings Basket
  Regular or Basket
  $13.49
- Tater Tots Regular
  Regular or Basket
  $6.49
- Tater Tots Basket
  Regular or Basket
  $12.59
- Tater Tots Well Done Regular
  Regular or Basket
  $6.49
- Curly Fries Basket
  Regular or Basket
  $12.59
- Side of Mac Salad
  $4.59
- Side of Kraft Mac & Cheese
  $4.59
- French Fries Well Done Basket
  Regular or Basket
  $12.59
- Fried Mushrooms Regular
  Regular or Basket served with choice of Bleu Cheese or Ranch
  $7.19
- Onion Rings Well Done Regular
  Regular or Basket
  $6.89
- Mozzarella Sticks 3pc Mozzarella Sticks
  3pc, 6pc, or 9pc served with a side of marinara sauce
  $6.69
- Home Fries Regular
  Regular or Basket
  $6.49
- Home Fries Well Done Regular
  Regular or Basket
  $6.49
- Pizza Logs 2pc Pizza Logs
  2pc, 4pc, or 6pc served with a side of marinara sauce
  $6.19
- Side of Coleslaw
  $4.59
- Side of Baked Beans
  $4.59
- Tater Tots Well Done Basket
  Regular or Basket
  $12.59
- Curly Fries Well Done Basket
  Regular or Basket
  $12.59
- Curly Fries Well Done Regular
  Regular or Basket
  $6.49
- Home Fries Basket
  Regular or Basket
  $12.59
- Home Fries Well Done Basket
  Regular or Basket
  $12.59
- Sweet Potato Waffle Fries Basket
  Regular or Basket
  $13.49
- Sweet Potato Waffle Fries Regular
  Regular or Basket
  $6.89
- Sweet Potato Waffle Fries Well Done Basket
  Regular or Basket
  $13.49
- Sweet Potato Waffle Fries Well Done Regular
  Regular or Basket
  $6.89
- Onion Rings Well Done Basket
  Regular or Basket
  $13.49
- Fried Mushrooms Basket
  Regular or Basket served with choice of Bleu Cheese or Ranch
  $13.99
- Mozzarella Sticks 9pc Mozzarella Sticks
  3pc, 6pc, or 9pc served with a side of marinara sauce
  $19.59
- Pizza Logs 6pc Pizza Logs
  2pc, 4pc, or 6pc served with a side of marinara sauce
  $18.19
- Fried Mushrooms Well Done Basket
  Regular or Basket served with choice of Bleu Cheese or Ranch
  $13.99
- Fried Mushrooms Well Done Regular
  Regular or Basket served with choice of Bleu Cheese or Ranch
  $7.19
Beverages
- Milkshakes Regular
  Small, Medium or Large
  $8.09
- Milkshakes Large
  Small, Medium or Large
  $10.39
- Milkshakes Small
  Small, Medium or Large
  $6.99
- Bottled Soda
  Pepsi Products
  $3.89
- Milk Chocolate
  $1.89
- Milk White
  White or chocolate
  $1.89
- Apple Juice
  $2.29
- Bottled Water
  Aquafina
  $3.29
Condiments on the Side
- Side of Meat Hot Sauce
  $0.65
- Side of Nacho Cheese
  $1.10
- Side of Gravy
  $0.65
- Side of Bleu Cheese
  $0.65
- Side of Dill Pickles
  $0.40
- Side of Ranch
  $0.65
- Side of Honey Mustard
  $0.40
- Side of Country Sweet Sauce
  $0.40
- Side of Sweet Pickles
  $0.40
- Side of Mayonnaise
  $0.40
- Side of Buffalo Sauce
  $0.40
- Side of BBQ Sauce
  $0.40
- Side of Honey BBQ Sauce
  $0.40
- Allergy Dislaimer:
  If you have a food allergy, please notify us. Allergen information for menu items is available. Ask an employee for details.
- Side of Boom Boom Sauce
  $0.40
- Side of Marinara Sauce
  $0.40