Big Gay Ice Cream Menu

Choose any 3 cookies.

Throw the confetti and celebrate with yummy rainbow sprinkled sugar cookie stuffed with more rainbow sprinkles and vanilla frosting

This rich chocolate brownie is made from pure melted chocolate with the special addition of semi sweet chocolate chips on top

A rich, buttery brown sugar and peanut butter based cookie dough is packed with an abundance of crispy-crunchy butterfinger® pieces and milk chocolate chunks

Tons of rainbow sprinkles and mini mandms!!! White chocolate chips are invited to this party too!

Semi-sweet chocolate chips, peanut butter chips, cookies and cream pieces, chopped pecans, pretzels and last but not least - potato chips!

A rich, brown sugar cookie is loaded with chocolate sandwich cookie pieces and hershey’s premier white chips®.

So lucious, you won't miss the gluten or dairy.

This sugar cookie has a lovely flavor of cinnamon and warm spices.

Zesty lemon makes this cookie both tart and refreshing while dried wild blueberries contribute a sweet note to this light, tender and chewy cookie.

Grandmas everywhere are jealous! This oatmeal raisin can satisfy any oatmeal raisin lover’s craving with our chewy yet crispy cookie overloaded with moist plump raisins.

Peanut Butter and jelly on a whole new level! Peanut butter cookie dough stuffed with grape jelly.

If you love the cake you’ll love this cookie even more! This cookie is loaded with dark chocolate chunks, hershey’s® mini kisses and white chocolate chips.

Peanut butter cookie dough is loaded with peanut butter chips and topped with chunks of reese’s® peanut butter cups.

A brown butter sugar cookie accented with flakes of pure sea salt and add generous amounts of creamy caramel and buttery heath toffee bits covered in milk chocolate.

Gooey marshmallows are blended into our chocolate cookie dough then loaded with hershey’s mini kisses, chocolate chunks and graham crackers.

A classic, made with sweet cream butter and topped with sugar crystals.

A chocolate chunk cookie, generously topped with hershey’s® mini kisses, semi sweet chocolate chunks and milk chocolate chunks.

Croissant with cookie dough

Vanilla ice cream cone injected with dulce de leche, then rolled in ground Nilla wafer cookies.

Nutella-lined waffle cone ice cream sundae filled with twisted chocolate & vanilla ice cream, dulce de leche & whipped cream, dash sea salt.

Chocolate ice cream cone rolled in our Rocky Roadhouse topping, a blend of mini marshmallows, toasted almonds & chocolate bits. 

Vanilla ice cream, hot fudge topping. Classic good times.

Vanilla ice cream cone injected with dulce de leche, lightly salted & dipped in chocolate shell.

Blueberry pie inspired: vanilla ice cream, peach preserves, pie crust crumble & whipped cream.

Key lime pie inspired: vanilla ice cream, key lime curd, pie crust crumble & whipped cream.

Peach pie inspired: vanilla ice cream, peach preserves, pie crust crumble & whipped cream.

Hot fudge sundae. A sundae of vanilla or chocolate ice cream, hot fudge (or our homemade awesome sauce, crushed peanuts or not and whipped cream.

A sundae of vanilla ice cream, our homemade strawberry sauce, crumbled Nilla wafers cookies and whipped cream.

Big gay ice cream's specialty soft serve chocolate recipe.

Dairy free and gluten free. Best vegan vanilla in manhattan.

BGIC vanilla soft serve with chocolate wafers and rainbow sprinkles.

BGIC chocolate soft serve with chocolate wafers and chocolate sprinkles.