Betty Rae's Ice Cream Menu

4.7

(2,100+ Reviews)

$Ice cream shop

Customer Favorites Ice Cream Shakes

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- Brown Butter & Toasted Pecans
  Brown Butter & Toasted Pecans ice cream. Available in pint, quart, or gallon.
  $8.99
- Cookies and Cream
  $8.99
- Chocolate Brownie
  $8.99
- Cereal and Milk
  $8.99
- Cookie Dough
  Cookie dough ice cream, available in pint, quart, or gallon sizes.
  $8.99
- Goat Cheese with Apricots and Candied Walnuts
  $8.99
- S'mores
  S'mores ice cream with graham cracker, chocolate chunks, and marshmallow swirls. Available in pint, quart, and gallon sizes.
  $8.99
- Mint & Chocolate Flakes
  $8.99
- Thou Mayest Coffee
  $8.99
- Strawberry
  $8.99
Ice Cream
- Brown Butter & Toasted Pecans
  Brown Butter & Toasted Pecans ice cream. Available in pint, quart, or gallon.
  $8.99
- Cookies and Cream
  $8.99
- Cookie Dough
  Cookie dough ice cream, available in pint, quart, or gallon sizes.
  $8.99
- Strawberry
  $8.99
- Peanut Butter
  $8.99
- Chocolate
  $8.99
- Non-Dairy Chocolate
  $8.99
- Vanilla Bean
  $8.99
- Vegan Vanilla
  $8.99
- Chocolate Brownie
  $8.99
- Thou Mayest Coffee
  $8.99
- Cereal and Milk
  $8.99
- Goat Cheese with Apricots and Candied Walnuts
  $8.99
- S'mores
  S'mores ice cream with graham cracker, chocolate chunks, and marshmallow swirls. Available in pint, quart, and gallon sizes.
  $8.99
- Razz & Blue
  $8.99
- Mint & Chocolate Flakes
  $8.99
- Cinnamon
  $8.99
Shakes
- Brown Butter & Toasted Pecans
  Brown butter & toasted pecan milkshake, with whole or oat milk options. Available in medium (16 oz) or large (20 oz).
  $7.75
- Cookies and Cream
  Cookies and cream milkshake: blended with crushed cookies. options include whole or oat milk and three sizes: small, medium, or large.
  $7.75
- Cookie Dough
  Cookie dough shake with options for whole or oat milk. available in small (12 oz), medium (16 oz), or large (20 oz).
  $7.75
- Strawberry
  Strawberry shake with options for whole or oat milk. Available in medium (16 oz) or large (20 oz).
  $7.75
- Peanut Butter
  Peanut butter shake with choice of whole or oat milk. Available in medium (16 oz) or large (20 oz).
  $7.75
- Chocolate
  Rich chocolate shake with choice of whole or oat milk. Available in medium (16 oz) or large (20 oz).
  $7.75
- Non-Dairy Chocolate
  Non-dairy chocolate milkshake. choice of whole or oat milk. Available in medium (16 oz) or large (20 oz).
  $7.75
- Vanilla Bean
  Vanilla bean milkshake with choice of whole or oat milk. Available in medium (16 oz) or large (20 oz).
  $7.75
- Vegan Vanilla
  Creamy vegan vanilla milkshake with choices of whole or oat milk. Available in medium (16 oz) or large (20 oz).
  $7.75
- Chocolate Brownie
  Rich chocolate brownie milkshake. options include whole or oat milk. Available in medium (16 oz) or large (20 oz).
  $7.75
- Thou Mayest Coffee
  Thou mayest coffee shake: choice of whole or oat milk. Available in medium (16 oz) or large (20 oz).
  $7.75
- Lavender Honey
  Lavender honey milkshake: infused with real lavender, sweetened with honey. Options for whole or oat milk. Available in medium (16 oz) or large (20 oz).
  $7.75
- Cereal and Milk
  Cereal-infused milkshake with choices of whole or oat milk. Available in medium (16 oz) or large (20 oz).
  $7.75
- Goat Cheese with Apricots and Candied Walnuts
  Goat cheese and apricots milkshake, candied walnuts topping. Choice of whole or oat milk. Available in medium (16 oz) or large (20 oz).
  $7.75
- S'mores
  S'mores milkshake with marshmallows, chocolate syrup, and graham crackers. Milk options: whole or oat. Available in medium (16 oz) or large (20 oz).
  $7.75
- Razz & Blue
  Razz & Blue Milkshake: Blend of raspberry and blueberry. Choose from whole or oat milk. Available in medium (16 oz) or large (20 oz).
  $7.75
- Mint & Chocolate Flakes
  Mint & chocolate flakes milkshake. Choice of whole or oat milk. Available in medium (16 oz) or large (20 oz).
  $7.75
- Cinnamon
  Cinnamon-infused milkshake with optional whole or oat milk. Available in medium (16 oz) or large (20 oz).
  $7.75