Bender's Tavern Menu

4.7

(1,250+ Reviews)

Lunch Specials Appetizers Lunch Entrees Lunch Salads Sandwiches Lunch Soups Sides Desserts Youth Appetizers Salads Dinner Entrees Soups Sides Desserts Youth Hats Sweatshirts T-shirts Drinkware

Lunch Specials
- Lunch Special Quiche
  Quiche Du Jour Prosciutto, Domestic Swiss Cheese, Portobello Mushrooms, Eggs & Cream Bender Fries & Artisan Greens
  $15.95
- Lunch Special Pasta
  Pasta Du Jour Key west shrimp, sundried tomato, spinach, pink vodka sauce & tortellacci pasta Served with a small lettuce salad
  $18.95
- Lunch Special Sole
  Fresh Grey Sole Pan seared harissa dusted Grey sole. Served with vegetable du jour & rice pilaf
  $16.95
- Lightly Fried Haddock
  Lightly fried with Bender fries & coleslaw
  $15.95
- Fried Oysters, Half Order
  Lightly Fried Select Oysters Served with Bender fries, coleslaw
  $15.95
- LS Key West Shrimp
  Lightly Fried Key West Shrimp Served with Bender Fries and coleslaw
  $14.95
- Lunch Special Sandwich
  French Dip Toasted French baguette piled high with roasted shaved beef and caramelized onions. Topped with Swiss cheese. Served with a side of au jus
  $15.95
- Lunch Special Wrap
  Chicken Fajita Wrap Tajin dusted chicken, grilled peppers, red onion, shredded lettuce & lime crema in a flour tortilla
  $14.95
- Lunch Special Wrap 1/2
  1/2 Chicken Fajita Wrap Tajin dusted chicken, grilled peppers, red onion, shredded lettuce & lime crema in a flour tortilla ½ wrap and a cup of soup
  $14.95
- Lunch Special Salad
  Chicken Waldorf Salad Chick on a bed of Boston Bib lettuce, grapes, celery, walnuts, green apples & served with Waldorf Dressing
  $16.95
Appetizers
- Shrimp Cocktail
  4 Jumbo Domestic Gulf Shrimp served with Cocktail Sauce and Lemon.
  $19.00
- Hummus Platter
  Our house made hummus with marinated feta, cucumber-fennel relish and toasted pita
  $14.00
- Smoked Salmon Appetizer
  Foley's premium Smoked Salmon with red onions, capers & hard-boiled egg
  $17.00
- Crabmeat Cocktail
  Fresh Jonah Crabmeat served with Cocktail Sauce
  $19.00
- Roasted Beets
  Our house roasted and pickled beets served with Skorthalia (Creamy Greek Garlic Sauce)
  $13.00
- Smoked Trout
  Ducktrap Smoked Trout served with cucumber-yogurt salad.
  $15.00
- Calamari
  Lightly fried Calamari served with a sweet Thai chili glaze
  $16.00
Lunch Entrees
- Protein Plate
  Bender’s gourmet burger or Bell & Evans chicken breast with hummus or cottage cheese, hard-boiled egg
  $15.00
- Strip Steak
  12 oz. Certified Angus Beef®
  $54.00
- Filet
  Certified Angus Beef® 8 oz. Center Cut
  $58.00
- Sirloin
  8 oz Certified Angus Beef® Texas Sirloin
  $29.00
- Flat Iron Steak
  Sliced w/mushroom-cabernet sauce with Bender fries, vegetable du jour
  $14.00
- Pork Chop
  12 oz. Ohio Proud Premium Bone-In Pork Chop with mashed potatoes & demi-glace
  $35.00
- Chicken Piccata Lunch
  Chicken breast dredged in flour, sautéed in lemon juice, butter & capers. Served with mashed potatoes, broccoli
  $16.00
- Linguini Alfredo Lunch
  Add Chicken 9 or Key West Shrimp 11
  $12.00
- Halibut
  Our #1 most popular item. We suggest Ala Foley Style (rolled in crushed ritz cracker and baked in the oven) served with lemon and butter (Ala Foley Shown in Picture)
  $45.00
- Camp Kagel Walleye
  Fresh Lake Erie Walleye served "Camp Kagle Style" (Lightly dusted with flour, salt, pepper, paprika and pan fried and baked in the oven) Served with tarter sauce and lemon
  $33.00
- Boston Scrod Dinner
  Fresh from Boston! Served broiled or Ala Foley (shown Ala Foley)
  $29.00
- Boston Scrod, Half Order
  Ala Foley or broiled with Bender fries & coleslaw
  $18.00
- Fried Oysters Dinner
  Select Oysters lightly fried and served with cocktail sauce or tarter sauce
  $32.00
- Fried Oysters, Half Order
  Lightly Fried Select Oysters Served with Bender fries, coleslaw
  $15.95
- Fried Haddock Dinner
  Our Famous Fried haddock served with Tarter Sauce and Lemon
  $25.00
- Lightly Fried Haddock
  Lightly fried with Bender fries & coleslaw
  $15.95
- Salmon Dinner
  Foley's Atlantic Salmon
  $31.00
- Salmon, Half Order
  Maple-balsamic glaze with Bender fries & coleslaw
  $22.00
- Crab Cake Dinner
  Our Special blend of Claw Crab meat served with Creole aioli, tomato scallion relish and basmati rice
  $32.00
- Crab Cake, Half Order
  Basmati rice, tomato-scallion relish, creole aioli
  $17.00
Lunch Salads
- Boston Bibb Salad Lunch
  Boston bibb lettuce with strawberries, marcona almonds, warm brie & white balsamic vinaigrette
  $14.00
- Benders Wedge
  Dry blue cheese, bacon, egg, tomato, red onion & choice of dressing
  $14.00
- Caesar Salad Lunch
  Hearts of romaine lettuce, croutons, parmesan cheese & Caesar dressing
  $11.00
- Jacob Salad Small
  Julienne lettuce, turkey, ham, hard boiled egg, relish, tomatoes & special creamy dressing
  $10.95
- Jacob Salad Large
  Julienne lettuce, turkey, ham, hard boiled egg, relish, tomatoes & special creamy dressing
  $14.95
- Small Benders Tomato
  Bender's tomatoes with dry blue cheese, basil, parsley, red onion & Italian dressing
  $9.00
- Large Benders Tomato
  Bender's tomatoes with dry blue cheese, basil, parsley, red onion & homemade Italian dressing
  $15.00
- Steak & Onion Salad
  Flat iron steak, tomato, blue cheese, onion rings & balsamic vinaigrette
  $17.00
- Cobb Salad
  Chicken, tomato, avocado, blue cheese, bacon, egg, red onion & choice of dressing
  $16.00
- Mixed Greens Salad
  $3.00
Sandwiches
- Benders Burger
  House special blend of Brisket, Chuck & Short Rib served with choice of cheese, lettuce, tomato and onion on a brioche bun w/chips
  $15.95
- Big Sis Burger
  Bender’s special 8oz burger blend w/American cheese, shredded lettuce & “Big Sis” sauce (mayo, dijon, dill pickles, onion) on a brioche bun
  $16.95
- Mushroom Thyme Burger
  Bender’s special 8oz burger blend w/Swiss cheese, sauteed mushrooms & thyme mayo on a brioche bun
  $16.95
- Classic Reuben
  Corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss & thousand island on grilled rye w/ chips
  $14.95
- Fried Haddock Sandwich
  Famous breaded & fried haddock on a brioche bun w/ chips
  $13.00
- SoCal Chicken Sandwich
  Bacon, Swiss, avocado, lettuce, tomato & mayo on a brioche bun w/chips
  $15.95
Lunch Soups
- Soup Cup
  $6.00
- Soup Bowl
  $9.00
- Turtle Soup Cup
  $9.00
- Turtle Soup Bowl
  $13.00
Sides
- Applesauce
  $1.50
- Bender Fries
  $3.50
- Coleslaw
  $1.50
- Cottage Cheese
  $1.25
- Daily Side Lunch
  $2.00
- French Fries
  $4.00
- Jerry Fries
  $4.50
- Veggie Side
  $3.00
- Onion Rings
  $5.00
Desserts
- Bread Pudding
  $8.95
- Cheesecake
  Our Monster Cheesecake is wonderful-Served with or without strawberries-Picture is shown with Strawberries
  $9.95
- Large Chocolate Peanut Butter Sundae
  $7.25
- Mini Chocolate Peanut Butter Sundae
  $4.25
- Chocolate Decadence
  Our Chocolate Decadence is a Flourless chocolate cake made with some of the finest chocolate available!
  $11.95
Youth
- JR Pasta Butter
  $8.00
- JR Pasta Marinara
  $10.00
- JR Fried Haddock
  $15.00
- JR Burger
  $8.00
- JR Haddock Sandwich
  $11.50
- JR Chicken Fingers
  $11.95
Appetizers
- Roasted Beets
  Our house roasted and pickled beets served with Skorthalia (Creamy Greek Garlic Sauce)
  $13.00
- Calamari
  Lightly fried Calamari served with a sweet Thai chili glaze
  $16.00
- Crab Cake Appetizer
  $16.00
- Crabmeat Cocktail
  Fresh Jonah Crabmeat served with Cocktail Sauce
  $19.00
- Hummus Platter
  Our house made hummus with marinated feta, cucumber-fennel relish and toasted pita
  $14.00
- Shrimp Cocktail
  4 Jumbo Domestic Gulf Shrimp served with Cocktail Sauce and Lemon.
  $19.00
- Smoked Trout
  Ducktrap Smoked Trout served with cucumber-yogurt salad.
  $15.00
- Smoked Salmon Appetizer
  Foley's premium Smoked Salmon with red onions, capers & hard-boiled egg
  $17.00
- Smoked Duck Appetizer
  Hickory & Applewood Smoked Duck - Honey-basil pesto, sun-dried tomatoes, roasted garlic, Parmesan
  $13.00
Salads
- Large Benders Tomato
  Bender's tomatoes with dry blue cheese, basil, parsley, red onion & homemade Italian dressing
  $15.00
- Small Benders Tomato
  Bender's tomatoes with dry blue cheese, basil, parsley, red onion & Italian dressing
  $9.00
- Benders Wedge
  Dry blue cheese, bacon, egg, tomato, red onion & choice of dressing
  $14.00
- Caesar Salad Side
  Hearts of romaine lettuce, croutons, Parmesan cheese & Caesar dressing
  $11.00
- Chopped Salad
  pears, apple, bacon, craisins, feta, poppyseed dressing.
  $12.00
- Mixed Greens Salad
  $3.00
Dinner Entrees
- Filet
  Certified Angus Beef® 8 oz. Center Cut
  $58.00
- Strip Steak
  12 oz. Certified Angus Beef®
  $54.00
- Sirloin
  8 oz Certified Angus Beef® Texas Sirloin
  $29.00
- Chicken Piccata
  Chicken breast dredged in flour, sautéed in lemon juice, butter & capers with mashed potatoes & sweet peas
  $25.00
- Pork Chop
  12 oz. Ohio Proud Premium Bone-In Pork Chop with mashed potatoes & demi-glace
  $35.00
- Linguini Alfredo
  Homemade Alfredo Sauce with Linguini- Add Chicken or Shrimp
  $18.00
- Crab Cake Dinner
  Our Special blend of Claw Crab meat served with Creole aioli, tomato scallion relish and basmati rice
  $32.00
- Fried Haddock Dinner
  Our Famous Fried haddock served with Tarter Sauce and Lemon
  $25.00
- Fried Oysters Dinner
  Select Oysters lightly fried and served with cocktail sauce or tarter sauce
  $32.00
- Grey Sole
  The best of the flounder family. Grey Sole is pan sauteed and served with lemon and butter.
  $32.00
- Halibut
  Our #1 most popular item. We suggest Ala Foley Style (rolled in crushed ritz cracker and baked in the oven) served with lemon and butter (Ala Foley Shown in Picture)
  $45.00
- Lobster Tail Dinner - 2
  Two 4 oz. South African Lobster (known for their sweetness) tails broiled and served lemon and butter
  $62.00
- Lobster Whole
  Whole Maine 1 1/4 lb Lobster served Steamed or Broiled (cut in half) served with lemon and butter
  $36.95
- Salmon Dinner
  Foley's Atlantic Salmon
  $31.00
- Boston Scrod Dinner
  Fresh from Boston! Served broiled or Ala Foley (shown Ala Foley)
  $29.00
- Chilean Sea Bass
  Sauteed or Lightly Cajun
  $52.00
- Shrimp Scampi Entree
  $39.00
- Crab Stuffed Flounder
  Our homemade crab stuffing wrapped with grey sole and baked. Served over spinach and Dijon mustard sauce
  $32.00
- Crab Stuffed Portabella Entree
  Roasted Portobello Mushroom stuffed with our homemade crab stuffing
  $29.00
- Camp Kagel Walleye
  Fresh Lake Erie Walleye served "Camp Kagle Style" (Lightly dusted with flour, salt, pepper, paprika and pan fried and baked in the oven) Served with tarter sauce and lemon
  $33.00
- Mozzarella Sachettes
  $24.00
- Fried Haddock Sandwich
  Famous breaded & fried haddock on a brioche bun w/ chips
  $13.00
Soups
- Soup Cup
  $6.00
- Soup Bowl
  $9.00
- Turtle Soup Cup
  $9.00
- Turtle Soup Bowl
  $13.00
Sides
- Applesauce
  $1.50
- Baked Potato
  $2.50
- Bender Fries
  $3.50
- Coleslaw
  $1.50
- Cottage Cheese
  $1.25
- French Fries
  $4.00
- Jerry Fries
  $4.50
- Sauteed Mushrooms
  $5.25
- Sauteed Onions
  $4.50
- Sauteed Spinach
  $8.00
- Veggie Side
  $3.00
- Add-On Sauces
Desserts
- Bread Pudding
  $8.95
- Cheesecake
  Our Monster Cheesecake is wonderful-Served with or without strawberries-Picture is shown with Strawberries
  $9.95
- Large Chocolate Peanut Butter Sundae
  $7.25
- Mini Chocolate Peanut Butter Sundae
  $4.25
- Chocolate Decadence
  Our Chocolate Decadence is a Flourless chocolate cake made with some of the finest chocolate available!
  $11.95
Youth
- JR Pasta Butter
  $8.00
- JR Pasta Marinara
  $10.00
- JR Scrod
  $16.00
- JR Fried Haddock
  $15.00
- JR Burger
  $8.00
- JR Haddock Sandwich
  $11.50
- JR Chicken Sandwich
  $10.00
- JR Chicken Fingers
  $11.95
Hats
- Trucker Hat
  $20.00
- Dad Hat
  $20.00
Sweatshirts
- Grey Sweatshirt
  $30.00
- Green Sweatshirt
  $30.00
T-shirts
- Red T-Shirt
  $20.00
- Sandstone T-Shirt
  $20.00
- Cape T-Shirt
  $20.00
Drinkware
- 20oz Yeti
  $39.95
- 30oz Yeti
  $45.95
- Anniversary Glass
  $10.00
- Lobster Glass
  $3.99
- Krombacher Glass
  $6.00