Baltimore in a Box Ice Cream Menu

4.5

(25+ Reviews)

Ice cream shop

Customer Favorites Baltimore Ice Cream Flavors Traditional Ice Cream Flavors Sorbets Gift Boxes!

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- Summer in Charm City Ice Cream
  A Baltimore Classic Egg Custard Snowball but in Ice Cream form! (Our most popular flavor)!
  $10.00
- Bawlmer Cookie & Cream Ice Cream
  Cookies & Cream Ice Cream except we took out the Oreo Cookies and mixed in chunks of Baltimore's iconic Berger Cookies into it instead!
  $10.00
- Salty Balty Ice Cream
  A salted Goetze's Caramel Creams base with chunks of chopped Berger Cookies mixed in!
  $10.00
- Otterly Divine Ice Cream
  Birthday Cake Ice Cream with Otterbein's Sugar Cookies and Rainbow Sprinkles!
  $10.00
- Mr. Trash Wheel's Junk Food Ice Cream
  Cookies & Cream with Cookie Dough, Pretzel Sticks, & Marshmallows! A portion of the proceeds for this Ice Cream Flavor Helps Support our Beloved Mr. Trash Wheel!
  $10.00
- Cookies & Cream Ice Cream
  $10.00
- LaMarshmallow Chip Ice Cream
  A Dark Chocolate Ice Cream with Otterbein's Chocolate Chip Cookies and Marshmallows mixed in!
  $10.00
- Apple Pie Ice Cream
  $10.00
- Ode to Joe Ice Cream
  Ode to Joe Flacco? Or a cup of Joe? We'll let you decide. This flavor features Baltimore's favorite coffee: Zeke's Coffee Charm City Blend with Oreo Ice Cream!
  $10.00
- 2 Pints & 2 Baltimore Snacks Box!
  Pick any 2 Pints of Ice Cream and 2 Baltimore Snacks to be packaged in a Baltimore in a Box Ice Cream Care Package!
  $40.00
Baltimore Ice Cream Flavors
Our Signature Flavors Inspired by Baltimore!
- Bawlmer Cookie & Cream Ice Cream
  Cookies & Cream Ice Cream except we took out the Oreo Cookies and mixed in chunks of Baltimore's iconic Berger Cookies into it instead!
  $10.00
- Summer in Charm City Ice Cream
  A Baltimore Classic Egg Custard Snowball but in Ice Cream form! (Our most popular flavor)!
  $10.00
- Salty Balty Ice Cream
  A salted Goetze's Caramel Creams base with chunks of chopped Berger Cookies mixed in!
  $10.00
- Downey Ocean Ice Cream
  A trip Downey Ocean never tasted so good! This flavor turns Caramel Fisher's Popcorn into Ice Cream form!
  $10.00
- Ode to Joe Ice Cream
  Ode to Joe Flacco? Or a cup of Joe? We'll let you decide. This flavor features Baltimore's favorite coffee: Zeke's Coffee Charm City Blend with Oreo Ice Cream!
  $10.00
- LaMarshmallow Chip Ice Cream
  A Dark Chocolate Ice Cream with Otterbein's Chocolate Chip Cookies and Marshmallows mixed in!
  $10.00
- East Bmore Eclair Ice Cream
  Made with local and family owned Geresbeck's Food Market's Scratch Made Chocolate Eclair Ingredients!
  $10.00
- I'm So Crabby Ice Cream
  A Vanilla Ice Cream with some added spice via Baltimore's favorite UTZ Crab Chips!
  $10.00
- Cal's Streak Ice Cream
  An Orange Creamsicle Ice Cream with Chocolate Chips mixed in! Let's Go O's!
  $10.00
- Otterly Divine Ice Cream
  Birthday Cake Ice Cream with Otterbein's Sugar Cookies and Rainbow Sprinkles!
  $10.00
- Poe-Conut Ice Cream
  Coconut Ice Cream with Otterbein's Lemon Sugar Cookies!
  $10.00
- Mr. Trash Wheel's Junk Food Ice Cream
  Cookies & Cream with Cookie Dough, Pretzel Sticks, & Marshmallows! A portion of the proceeds for this Ice Cream Flavor Helps Support our Beloved Mr. Trash Wheel!
  $10.00
- The Block is Hot Ice Cream
  Vanilla Ice Cream with Chocolate Chips & OLD BAY Hot Sauce!
  $10.00
Traditional Ice Cream Flavors
- Vanilla Ice Cream
  $10.00
- Chocolate Ice Cream
  $10.00
- Strawberry Ice Cream
  $10.00
- Mint Chocolate Chip Ice Cream
  $10.00
- Cookies & Cream Ice Cream
  $10.00
- C is For Cookie Ice Cream
  Cookies & Cream with extra Oreo Cookies and added Cookie Dough
  $10.00
- Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Ice Cream
  Creamy vanilla ice cream mixed with chunks of chocolate chip cookie dough.
  $10.00
- Snallygaster Ice Cream
  Peanut Butter Ice Cream with Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups, Pretzels and Caramel Swirl
  $10.00
- Butter Pecan Ice Cream
  $10.00
- Apple Pie Ice Cream
  $10.00
- Chocolate Covered Strawberry
  Rich chocolate ice cream blended with sweet strawberry pieces, capturing the classic chocolate-covered strawberry flavor in every bite.
  $10.00
Sorbets
Dairy Free
- Mango Sorbet
  $10.00
- Watermelon Sorbet
  $10.00
Gift Boxes!
A Combo Box of Ice Cream and Baltimore Snacks!
- 2 Pints & 2 Baltimore Snacks Box!
  Pick any 2 Pints of Ice Cream and 2 Baltimore Snacks to be packaged in a Baltimore in a Box Ice Cream Care Package!
  $40.00
- 4 Pints in an Ice Cream Gift Box!
  Choose any 4 delicious pints of Baltimore in a Box Ice Cream to arrive in our custom branded Baltimore in a Box Ice Cream Gift Box!
  $45.00