Bagel Boys New City Menu

4.3

(225+ Reviews)

Customer Favorites Hot off the Grill Breakfast Sandwiches Bagel Boys Breakfast Wraps Omelettes Side Orders & Other Goodies Homemade Bagels Bagel Sandwiches Breakfast Favorites Homemade Muffins Premium Coffee Fresh Brewed Iced Coffee and Iced Tea Refreshing Fruit Smoothies and Frappes

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- Single Egg with Bacon, Sausage, or Ham
  $8.55
- Plain Cream Cheese
  Plain cream cheese spread, options include bagel, bialy, flagel, rainbow or gluten-free bagel, or by half-pound.
  $5.27
- Regular ice coffee
  Regular iced coffee. Available in large or x-large.
  $5.57
- Corn
  A corn muffin typically includes cornmeal and may be sweetened with honey or sugar, creating a tender texture.
  $4.70
- Vegetable Cream Cheese
  Vegetable cream cheese spread, available on choice of bagel, bialy, flagel, rainbow bagel, powerbar, or gluten-free bagel. Also offered by the half pound.
  $6.55
- Hash Browns
  Crispy and golden breakfast potatoes, perfect for starting your day off right.
  $4.98
- Coffee - Regular
  Regular coffee available in small, medium, large, or x-large sizes.
  $3.57
- 1/2 Dozen
  Buy 6, get 1 free.
  $11.90
- Double Chocolate Chip
  A homemade muffin with a rich chocolate base, generously filled with chocolate chips for a double chocolate experience.
  $4.70
- Butter
  Butter spread option: Choose from classic bagel, half-pound portion, bialy, flagel, colorful rainbow bagel, powerbar, or gluten-free bagel.
  $3.84
Hot off the Grill Breakfast Sandwiches
Served on a bagel or roll. Rainbow bagel, powerbar, ciabatta roll, wrap, flagel, bialy, croissant, or gluten free bagel available for extra charge. All baking done on premises.
- Single Egg
  Single egg sandwiched between choice of breads including traditional, rainbow, and gluten-free options.
  $5.70
- Single Egg with Bacon, Sausage, or Ham
  $8.55
- Single Egg with Turkey Breast, Turkey Bacon or Salami
  Single egg paired with your choice of turkey breast, turkey bacon, or salami. Select from a variety of breads including bagel, ciabatta, or gluten-free options.
  $9.98
- Single Egg with Taylor Ham or Chicken Sausage
  Single egg paired with your choice of Taylor Ham or chicken sausage. Selection of bread includes bagel options, ciabatta, wrap, croissant, and more.
  $9.98
- Single Egg with Roast Beef or Pastrami
  Single egg paired with choice of roast beef or pastrami. Selection of bread includes bagel variants, ciabatta, wrap, croissant, and gluten-free option.
  $12.99
- Cream Cheese & Bacon
  Cream Cheese & Bacon Breakfast Sandwich: Choice of Bagel, Roll, Rainbow Bagel, Powerbar, Ciabatta, Wrap, Flagel, Bialy, Croissant, or Gluten-Free Bagel.
  $8.12
- Grilled Cheese
  Melty cheese hugged by your choice of bagel, roll, croissant, or other breads, including gluten-free options.
  $7.49
Bagel Boys Breakfast Wraps
Available on plain, whole wheat or spinach. All baking done on premises.
- Bagel Boys Burrito
  2 eggs, bacon, cheddar cheese, sour cream & salsa.
  $11.41
- Veggie Monster Wrap
  Egg whites, peppers, onions & mushrooms.
  $11.41
- Protein Wrap
  Egg whites, turkey breast & alpine lace swiss cheese.
  $14.27
- Healthy Start Wrap
  Egg whites, turkey bacon, avocado & baby spinach.
  $15.70
- Bagel Boys Famous Frickin' Chicken
  Served on a bagel or roll. Chicken sausage, egg & avocado.
  $12.84
Omelettes
Includes 2 eggs and served on a bagel or roll. Wrap, rainbow bagel, flagel, powerbar, ciabatta roll, bialy, croissant, gluten free bagel available for extra charge. All baking done on premises.
- Cheese Omelette
  Double egg & double cheese.
  $8.55
- Veggie Omelette
  Peppers, onions, tomatoes, spinach & mushrooms.
  $10.70
- Western Omelette
  Grilled ham, peppers, onions & cheddar cheese.
  $12.12
- Chicken Fajita Omelette
  Grilled chicken, pepper jack cheese, peppers, grilled onions & side of salsa.
  $12.12
- Spicy Bobo, Hobo, Sobo
  Served on a bagel or roll. 2 eggs, home fries, bacon, ham or sausage, pepper jack cheese & hot sauce.
  $12.12
Side Orders & Other Goodies
All baking done on premises.
- Home Fries
  Home fries with options of regular or large size.
  $4.98
- Bacon
  Crispy thick-cut, smoked to perfection.
  $7.12
- Hash Browns
  Crispy and golden breakfast potatoes, perfect for starting your day off right.
  $4.98
- Turkey Bacon
  Crispy Turkey Bacon Strips - Perfectly Sizzled for a Smoky Flavor
  $8.49
- Hard Boiled Egg
  A rich protein-packed treat perfect for breakfast or a quick snack.
  $1.99
Homemade Bagels
Baked fresh daily on premises. Contains no fats or preservative. All baking done on premises.
- Per Piece
  Homemade bagel selections featuring a variety of flavors such as plain, sesame, everything, and more, including whole wheat options.
  $1.99
- 1/2 Dozen
  Buy 6, get 1 free.
  $11.90
- 1 Dozen
  Buy 12, get 2 free.
  $23.80
- Rainbow Bagel
  A rainbow bagel is a visually striking, hand-rolled bagel featuring a blend of colors. It typically includes spreads such as cream cheese or butter.
  $2.50
- Powerbar
  Topped with sunflower seeds, this homemade bagel features a dense, chewy texture and is packed with wholesome grains.
  $2.50
- Bialy
  A soft, round bread similar to a bagel but baked with a depression in the center, typically filled with cooked onions and poppy seeds.
  $2.50
- Mini Bagel
  A freshly baked, smaller-sized bagel, typically plain, offering a simple and classic breakfast option.
  $1.28
- Gluten Free Bagel
  A gluten-free bagel, crafted from a blend of gluten-free flours, offering a chewy texture and a slightly crisp exterior.
  $4.28
- Flagels
  Homemade flagels, available in sunflower, plain, everything, sesame, whole wheat, poppy, or whole wheat everything varieties.
  $2.50
Bagel Sandwiches
We use only Philadelphia brand cream cheese. Bialy, flagel, rainbow bagel, powerbar or gluten free bagel available for additional charge. All baking done on premises.
- Butter
  Butter spread option: Choose from classic bagel, half-pound portion, bialy, flagel, colorful rainbow bagel, powerbar, or gluten-free bagel.
  $3.84
- Plain Cream Cheese
  Plain cream cheese spread, options include bagel, bialy, flagel, rainbow or gluten-free bagel, or by half-pound.
  $5.27
- Vegetable Cream Cheese
  Vegetable cream cheese spread, available on choice of bagel, bialy, flagel, rainbow bagel, powerbar, or gluten-free bagel. Also offered by the half pound.
  $6.55
- Scallion Cream Cheese
  Scallion cream cheese, choose between bagel, bialy, flagel, rainbow bagel, powerbar, or gluten-free bagel. Also available per 1/2 lb.
  $6.55
- Olive & Pimento Cream Cheese
  Olive & pimento cream cheese spread. Available on a choice of bagels, including rainbow, powerbar, or gluten-free, as well as bialy or flagel. Option to order by the half pound.
  $6.55
- Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese
  Walnut and raisin cream cheese spread available on traditional or specialty bagels, bialys, flagels, powerbars, or gluten-free options.
  $7.12
- Strawberry
  Fresh strawberries layered on choice of bagel, bialy, flagel, rainbow bagel, powerbar, or gluten-free bagel. Option for half-pound serving available.
  $7.12
- Bacon & Scallion Cream Cheese
  Bacon & scallion cream cheese, options include choice of bagel, bialy, flagel, rainbow bagel, powerbar, or gluten-free bagel.
  $7.12
- Sundried Tomato Cream Cheese
  Sundried tomato cream cheese spread on choice of bagel, bialy, flagel, rainbow bagel, powerbar, or gluten-free bagel. Also available per 1/2 lb.
  $7.12
- Lox Cream Cheese
  Lox cream cheese available on a variety of bases: bagel, bialy, flagel, rainbow bagel, powerbar, or gluten-free bagel.
  $7.12
- Low Fat Plain Cream Cheese
  Low fat plain cream cheese, available on choice of bagel, bialy, flagel, rainbow bagel, powerbar, or gluten-free bagel.
  $5.55
- Low Fat Vegetable Cream Cheese
  Low fat vegetable cream cheese served on your choice of bagel, bialy, flagel, rainbow bagel, powerbar, or gluten-free bagel. Available by the half pound.
  $6.84
- Low Fat Scallion Cream Cheese
  Scallion cream cheese, low fat. Choose presentation: bagel, bialy, flagel, rainbow bagel, powerbar, gluten-free bagel, or by half-pound.
  $6.84
- Peanut Butter
  Peanut butter and jelly spread over choice of bagel, bialy, flagel, rainbow bagel, powerbar, or gluten-free bagel.
  $5.70
- Nova Special
  Sliced nova lox, cream cheese, tomato & sliced red onion.
  $16.41
Breakfast Favorites
All baking done on premises.
- Avocado Toast
  Creamy avocado spread on toasted bread, topped with a delightful medley of seasonings and garnishes.
  $11.41
- French Toast
  3 pieces, served with butter & syrup.
  $9.98
- Buttermilk Pancakes
  3 pieces, served with butter & syrup.
  $9.98
Homemade Muffins
Baked fresh daily on premises. Butter or jelly available for additional charge. All baking done on premises.
- Corn
  A corn muffin typically includes cornmeal and may be sweetened with honey or sugar, creating a tender texture.
  $4.70
- Blueberry
  A homemade muffin, freshly baked with juicy blueberries throughout, offering a classic taste.
  $4.70
- Double Chocolate Chip
  A homemade muffin with a rich chocolate base, generously filled with chocolate chips for a double chocolate experience.
  $4.70
- Cinnamon Chip
  A freshly baked muffin infused with cinnamon chips, offering a sweet and slightly spicy flavor profile.
  $4.70
- Oatbran
  An oatbran muffin typically includes a hearty blend of oat bran, often baked to achieve a tender texture.
  $4.70
- Apple Crumb
  An apple crumb muffin, featuring tender apples and a sweet, crumbly topping, typically includes cinnamon and a buttery streusel.
  $4.70
- Cranberry
  A homemade muffin incorporating cranberries, typically offering a balance of tartness from the cranberries within a soft, baked texture.
  $4.70
- Banana Nut
  A homemade banana nut muffin, incorporating ripe bananas and a blend of nuts, typically walnuts, baked into a moist base.
  $4.70
- Chocolate Chip
  A freshly baked muffin with a tender crumb, generously studded with chocolate chips.
  $4.70
- Double Chocolate Cheese
  A rich chocolate muffin filled with creamy cheese and generous chunks of chocolate.
  $4.70
- Homemade Mini-muffins 12 pic
  1 dozen pre-pack.
  $10.00
Premium Coffee
- Coffee - Regular
  Regular coffee available in small, medium, large, or x-large sizes.
  $3.57
- Coffee - Decaf
  Decaf coffee, available in sizes from small to x-large.
  $3.57
- Tea - Regular
  Regular tea, available in small, medium, large, or x-large sizes.
  $3.57
- Tea - Decaf
  Decaf tea available in sizes from small to x-large.
  $3.57
- Herbal Tea
  Herbal tea selections in various sizes: small to x-large.
  $3.57
- Hot Chocolate
  Rich hot chocolate available in small, medium, large, or x-large.
  $3.57
- Small Coffee Box
  8-10 cups. All coffee set-up prices include regular coffee, milk, sugar, sweeteners, cups & stirrers.
  $31.41
- Large Coffee Box
  14-16 cups. All coffee set-up prices include regular coffee, milk, sugar, sweeteners, cups & stirrers.
  $45.70
Fresh Brewed Iced Coffee and Iced Tea
- Regular ice coffee
  Regular iced coffee. Available in large or x-large.
  $5.57
- Decaf ice coffee
  Decaf iced coffee, available in large or x-large sizes.
  $5.57
- Fresh Homemade Lemonade
  Homemade lemonade, offered in large and x-large sizes.
  $5.79
Refreshing Fruit Smoothies and Frappes
Almond milk or oat milk available for additional charge.
- Strawberry
  Strawberry smoothie blended with choice of almond or oat milk.
  $7.85
- Banana
  Blended fresh banana with honey, milk, and a touch of vanilla ice cream for creaminess.
  $7.85
- Mango
  Mango smoothie with options of almond or oat milk.
  $7.85
- Peach
  A peach smoothie typically includes a blend of ripe peaches, a hint of yogurt, and ice, creating a smooth and refreshing drink.
  $7.85
- Watermelon
  Blended fresh watermelon typically includes a hint of lime and mint for a refreshing smoothie experience.
  $7.85
- Superfruit
  A blend of select superfruits, this smoothie typically includes a mix of antioxidant-rich berries and other fruits known for their nutritional benefits.
  $7.85
- Harvest Greens
  Harvest greens smoothie typically includes apples, bananas, kale, cucumber, kiwi, spinach, and lemongrass, blended for a refreshing drink.
  $7.85
- Vanilla Latte
  A vanilla latte frappé typically includes a blend of espresso, milk, and vanilla syrup, all frappéd to create a smooth, icy texture, often finished with a whipped cream topping.
  $7.85
- Caramel Latte
  Blended espresso and caramel with a touch of milk, typically topped with whipped cream.
  $7.85
- Espresso
  Espresso with a choice of almond or oat milk.
  $7.85
- Cookies 'N Cream
  Oreo cookies blended with vanilla ice cream and milk, typically includes a touch of chocolate syrup.
  $7.85
- Java Chip
  Blended espresso, chocolate, and chocolate chips, typically includes a base of milk or cream.
  $7.85
- Mocha
  Rich espresso blended with dark chocolate and steamed milk, topped with whipped cream.
  $7.85
- Bubblegum
  A bubblegum smoothie typically includes a blend of sweet, fruity flavors designed to mimic the classic bubblegum taste, often incorporating a mix of berries and a creamy base.
  $7.85
- Cotton Candy
  A sweet and creamy beverage blending the whimsical flavors of cotton candy with a hint of vanilla, typically served smooth.
  $7.85
- Orange Cream
  A blend of orange juice and cream, typically includes vanilla for a smooth, refreshing taste.
  $7.85

Menu Photos

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

Bagel Boys New City Menu

Customer Favorites

Single Egg with Bacon, Sausage, or Ham

Plain Cream Cheese

Regular ice coffee

Corn

Vegetable Cream Cheese

Hash Browns

Coffee - Regular

1/2 Dozen

Double Chocolate Chip

Butter

Hot off the Grill Breakfast Sandwiches

Single Egg

Single Egg with Bacon, Sausage, or Ham

Single Egg with Turkey Breast, Turkey Bacon or Salami

Single Egg with Taylor Ham or Chicken Sausage

Single Egg with Roast Beef or Pastrami

Cream Cheese & Bacon

Grilled Cheese

Bagel Boys Breakfast Wraps

Bagel Boys Burrito

Veggie Monster Wrap

Protein Wrap

Healthy Start Wrap

Bagel Boys Famous Frickin' Chicken

Omelettes

Cheese Omelette

Veggie Omelette

Western Omelette

Chicken Fajita Omelette

Spicy Bobo, Hobo, Sobo

Side Orders & Other Goodies

Home Fries

Bacon

Hash Browns

Turkey Bacon

Hard Boiled Egg

Homemade Bagels

Per Piece

1/2 Dozen

1 Dozen

Rainbow Bagel

Powerbar

Bialy

Mini Bagel

Gluten Free Bagel

Flagels

Bagel Sandwiches

Butter

Plain Cream Cheese

Vegetable Cream Cheese

Scallion Cream Cheese

Olive & Pimento Cream Cheese

Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese

Strawberry

Bacon & Scallion Cream Cheese

Sundried Tomato Cream Cheese

Lox Cream Cheese

Low Fat Plain Cream Cheese

Low Fat Vegetable Cream Cheese

Low Fat Scallion Cream Cheese

Peanut Butter

Nova Special

Breakfast Favorites

Avocado Toast

French Toast

Buttermilk Pancakes

Homemade Muffins

Corn

Blueberry

Double Chocolate Chip

Cinnamon Chip

Oatbran

Apple Crumb

Cranberry

Banana Nut

Chocolate Chip

Double Chocolate Cheese

Homemade Mini-muffins 12 pic