Andy's Frozen Custard

Great custard every time

These guys did a great job when they opened but later they have been raising prices and slightly reducing the actual amount of custard you get. I understand raising prices to keep up with the times, but I hate shrinkflation moves like this.

Icecream is on the sweeter side but still love it

The only problem I have with this place is the inconsistency of my order. I usually order a "small cup" of chocolate, as listed on the menu, and sometimes I'll get a decent amount in a small cone-shaped plastic cup, but other times I'll get a very small amount in a tiny plastic dish. Please tell your employees to be consistent with the "small cup" serving size because I really don't like being ripped off.

Good, but not much hot fudge and cookie dough in my concrete

Tried nutty waffle and triple chocolate fudge which tastes good

What a rip off. $3.50 small cup of plain vanilla and they tried to hand me about 4oz of custard. I hope you go out of business for trying to be cheap.

The Turtle Sunday is the best!