Anderson's Frozen Custard Menu
2634 Delaware Ave, Buffalo, NY 14216
Our Famous Signature Frozen CustardHandmade ICE CREAM & FROZEN YOGURTNon Dairy Plant Based Frozen DessertsOriginal Lemon IceSundaesArctic SwirlsHandmade Ice cream CakesHomemade Ice Cream PiesBig WheelsSundae KitsCHOCOLATE SODASJohnnie Ryan FLOATSSTRAWBERRY SENSATIONBEVERAGESMILKSHAKESNon Dairy Plant Based ShakesROAST BEEF SANDWICHESTURKEY SANDWICHESVEGAN SANDWICHCHICKEN & FISHRolls & BreadsSandwich ExtrasCheeseMore Sandwich ExtrasGRILL ITEMSFRIES & SIDESSALADSCOMBO MEALKIDS MEALSCHOCOLATE SODASSTRAWBERRY SENSATIONBEVERAGESMILKSHAKESPLANT BASED SHAKESFROZEN CUSTARDICE CREAM & FROZEN YOGURTPLANT BASED FROZEN DESSERTEXTRASORIGINAL LEMON ICECreate Your Own SundaesSignature SundaesSpecialty SundaesARCTIC SWIRLSHANDMADE ICE CREAM CAKESHANDMADE ICE CREAM PIESBIG WHEELSFRESHLY SLICED BY THE POUNDROLLSCHICKEN TENDERS BY THE POUNDCORPORATE SAMPLER PLATTERSIDES & SALADSEQUIPMENT RENTALBOXED LUNCHESBAGGED LUNCHESSUNDAE KITREADY TO SERVE SUNDAE BARREADY TO SERVE DISHESICE CREAM ALA CARTE ITEMSPREMIUM HANDMADE ICE CREAM CAKESOUR SPECIALTY HANDMADE ICE CREAM CAKE SERIESHANDMADE ICE CREAM FUDGE GANACHE CAKESHANDMADE ICE CREAM PIES
Our Famous Signature Frozen Custard
- Small$3.94
- Medium$4.74
- Large$5.39
- Pint$6.49
Handmade ICE CREAM & FROZEN YOGURT
- 1 ScoopCones & Dishes$4.59
- 2 Scoops$5.49
- 3 Scoops$6.69
- Pint$7.99
Non Dairy Plant Based Frozen Desserts
- 1 Scoop$5.54
- 2 Scoops$6.44
- 3 Scoops$7.64
- Pint$9.08
Original Lemon Ice
- Lemon Ice
Sundaes
- Create Your OwnToppings: Peanut Butter, Hot Fudge, Cold Chocolate Syrup, Butterscotch, Strawberry, Pineapple, Raspberry, Marshmallow, Caramel Extras: Nuts—Chopped, Spanish, Pecans — Add 1.26 Real Whipped Cream — Add 1.26 Candy — Add 1.26
- Signature SundaesReese’s Pieces Deluxe Peanut Butter -Hot Fudge & Reese’s® Pieces Mexican- Our Own Chocolate Sauce & Spanish Nuts Turtle- Hot Fudge, Butterscotch & Pecans Made with our own Signature Vanilla Frozen Custard
- Banana SplitVanilla & Chocolate Custard, Chocolate, Strawberry & Pineapple Toppings, Banana, Whipped Cream & Nuts$8.29
- Brownie OverboardRich Fudgy Brownie with Vanilla & Chocolate Frozen Custard, Hot Fudge, Whipped Cream & Chopped Nuts$8.29
- Choco-Peanut Butter PassionChocolate Peanut Butter Ice Cream, Hot Fudge, Peanut Butter, Peanut Butter Cookie, Whipped Cream & Reese’s® Peanut Butter Cups$8.29
- Strawberry GlacierOur Lemon Ice topped with strawberries$4.49
Arctic Swirls
- Arctic SwirlSmother it with Hot Fudge—Add .52 Double Dose Your Candy —Add 1.16
Handmade Ice cream Cakes
- RoundServes 8-10$26.49
- Small SheetServes 16-20$43.99
- Decadent SeriesServes 8-10 Cookies & Cream Dream w/real Oreo, Rainbow Fudge w/real M&M’s, Cookie Dough, plus seasonal favorites$32.99
- Fudgie TurtleServes 12-15$46.99
- Fudge GanacheServes 12-15$44.99
Homemade Ice Cream Pies
- Turtle, Cookies & Cream With Real Oreo, Peanut Butter Fudge
Big Wheels
- Original
- Large Chocolate Chip$9.99
Sundae Kits
- Classic$25.00
- Customized$29.00
CHOCOLATE SODAS
- Chocolate Sodas
Johnnie Ryan FLOATS
- Johnnie Ryan FloatsCherry, Orange, Birch Beer, Root Beer, Grape, Loganberry, Cream Soda, Cola, Diet
STRAWBERRY SENSATION
- Original Lemon Ice Blended With Lemon Up & Strawberries
BEVERAGES
- Soft Drinks
- Coffee
- Bottled Water$2.49
- Bottled Pop$2.99
MILKSHAKES
- MilkshakesChocolate, Black Raspberry, Vanilla, Pistachio, Strawberry, Cinnamon, Coffee, Loganberry, Root Beer, Mint, Peanut Butter, Hot Fudge , Caramel , Strawberries, Raspberries, Real Bananas - Add .55 each Make it a Malt add 55¢ Any item made with Hard...
Non Dairy Plant Based Shakes
- Regular$5.74
- Large$7.14
ROAST BEEF SANDWICHES
- ORIGINAL3 oz.$7.99
- CARL'S CHOICE5 oz.$8.99
- BARBECUE BEEF$6.99
TURKEY SANDWICHES
- ORIGINAL TURKEY SANDWICHES3 oz. (Served hot or cold)$7.99
- CARL'S CHOICE TURKEY SANDWICHES5 oz. served hot or cold$8.99
VEGAN SANDWICH
- VEGGIE WRAPLettuce, Cucumber, Tomato, Red Onion & Balsamic dressing$5.99
- VEGGIE BURGER$7.59
CHICKEN & FISH
- BUFFALO STYLE CHICKEN TENDER SANDWICHwith Lettuce, Wing Sauce, Blue Cheese$7.99
- CHICKEN TENDER BASKETwith Fries. Plain or Buffalo Style
- GRILLED CHICKEN$7.79
- CAESAR CHICKEN WRAPWith almonds$10.51
- WILD CAUGHT FISH SANDWICH$7.99
Rolls & Breads
- KimmelweckRolls
- KaiserRolls
- Ancient GrainRolls
- Gluten FreeRolls$2.00
- Organic Sprouted WhiteBreads
- WrapBreads
Sandwich Extras
- Thick Beef Gravy$1.26
- Melted Cheddar Sauce$1.26
- CondimentsHorseradish, Honey Dijon Sauce, Ketchup, Mayonnaise, Mustard, Banana Peppers, Onion, Lettuce, Tomato, Pickles, Relish, Hot Relish, Bold BBQ Sauce
Cheese
- American-Cheddar$1.26
- Provolone$1.26
- Feta$1.26
More Sandwich Extras
- Nitrate Free Bacon$2.39
- Avocado$2.39
GRILL ITEMS
- HAMBURGERAll Natural Beef
- CHEESEBURGERAll Natural Beef
- HOT DOGSahlen’s$3.89
FRIES & SIDES
- CURLY QUE FRIES
- SWEET POTATO FRIES
- CAJUN FRIES WITH CHEESE
- ONION RINGS
- BAKED POTATOESAdd Ons: 1.26 each Sour Cream, Thick Gravy, Broccoli, Melted Cheddar Sauce Add On Protein: Bacon 2.39 BBQ Beef 5.29$3.19
- MAC 'N CHEESE
- POTATO SALAD$2.99
SALADS
- CREATE YOUR OWN GARDEN SALADCreate Your Own Garden Salad Start with a base of Mixed Greens, then select your toppings: Includes your choice of: Croutons, Banana Peppers, Cucumber, Tomato, Chow Mein Noodles, Red Onion Salad Extras—add $1.26 each Broccoli, Pecans, Almonds, Man...$5.79
- GRILLED CHICKEN MANDARIN SALADMixed Greens, Grilled Chicken, Almonds, Chinese Noodles. Mandarin Oranges & Orange Sesame Dressing$14.10
- SPRING SALADMixed Greens, Feta Cheese, Red Onion, Pecans with Raspberry Vinaigrette Dressing.$9.57
- SIDE SALADwith tomato & cucumber$3.99
COMBO MEAL
- CREATE YOUR OWN COMBO MEALChoose any Sandwich, plus any Side Item or Salad, plus any Drink and Save .75! ~ excludes junior size ~
KIDS MEALS
- CHOOSE ONE MAIN ITEMAll Natural Roast Beef, BBQ Beef, All Natural Turkey, Hot Dog, Chicken Tender, Grilled Chicken Strips, Mac ’n Cheese, PB & J or *Angus Hamburger add 1.09$9.49
- CHOOSE ONE SIDE DISHCurly Fries, Mac ‘n Cheese, Steamed Broccoli, Applesauce, Banana, Pretzels, Chips or *Cajun Fries - add .49
- CHOOSE ONE BEVERAGEChocolate Milk, Apple Juice Box, Pop, Milk, or * Mini-Shake—add 1.14
CHOCOLATE SODAS
- CHOCOLATE SODAS
- Johnnie Ryan FLOATSCherry, Orange, Birch Beer, Root Beer, Loganberry, Cream Soda, Cola, Diet
STRAWBERRY SENSATION
- STRAWBERRY SENSATIONNo Fat & Non-Dairy Original Lemon Ice blended with Lemon Up & Strawberries
BEVERAGES
- Soft Drinks
- Coffee
- Bottled Water$2.49
- Bottled Pop$2.99
MILKSHAKES
- MILKSHAKESMade with Signature Frozen Custard. Chocolate, Black Raspberry, Vanilla, Pistachio, Strawberry, Cinnamon, Coffee, Loganberry, Root Beer, Mint Peanut Butter, Hot Fudge , Caramel , Strawberries, Raspberries, Real Bananas - Add .55 each Make it a Mal...
PLANT BASED SHAKES
- PLANT BASED SHAKES
FROZEN CUSTARD
- FROZEN CUSTARDVanilla, Chocolate, Twist & Daily Special
ICE CREAM & FROZEN YOGURT
- ICE CREAM & FROZEN YOGURT
PLANT BASED FROZEN DESSERT
- PLANT BASED FROZEN DESSERT
EXTRAS
- Waffle Cone / Bowl$1.19
- Dipped Waffle Cone / Bowl$2.39
- Gluten Free Cone$0.35
- Sprinkles$0.49
ORIGINAL LEMON ICE
- ORIGINAL LEMON ICE& Flavor of the Day Non Dairy & No Fat
Create Your Own Sundaes
- Create Your Own SundaesToppings: Peanut Butter, Hot Fudge, Cold Chocolate Syrup, Butterscotch, Strawberry, Pineapple, Raspberry, Marshmallow, Caramel. Extras: $1.26 each Nuts—Chopped, Spanish Peanuts, Pecans Real Whipped Cream Candy
Signature Sundaes
- Reese’s Pieces DeluxePeanut Butter, Hot Fudge & Reese’s® Pieces
- MexicanChocolate Sauce & Spanish Nuts
- TurtleHot Fudge, Caramel & Pecans
Specialty Sundaes
- Banana SplitVanilla & Chocolate Custard, Chocolate, Strawberry & Pineapple Toppings, Banana, Whipped Cream & Nuts$8.29
- Brownie OverboardRich Fudgy Brownie with Vanilla & Chocolate Frozen Custard, Hot Fudge, Whipped Cream & Chopped Nuts$8.29
- Choco-Peanut Butter PassionChocolate Peanut Butter Ice Cream, Hot Fudge, Peanut Butter, Whipped Cream, Peanut Butter Cookie & Reese’s® Peanut Butter Cups$8.29
- Strawberry GlacierOur Lemon Ice topped with strawberries.$4.49
ARCTIC SWIRLS
- ARCTIC SWIRLSM&M’s®, Reese’s® Pieces, Cookie Dough, Birthday Cake, Oreo, Heath, Brownie Pieces, Reese’s® Peanut Butter Cup. Smother it with Hot Fudge—Add .55 Candy Double Dosed —Add 1.26
HANDMADE ICE CREAM CAKES
- RoundServes 8-10$26.49
- Small SheetServes 16-20$40.99
- Decadent SeriesServes 8-10. Cookies & Cream Dream w/real Oreo, Rainbow Fudge w/real M&M’s, Cookie Dough Plus Seasonal Favorites$31.99
- Fudgie TurtleServes 12-15$44.99
- Fudge GanacheServes 12-15. Peanut Butter or Mint$40.99
HANDMADE ICE CREAM PIES
- HANDMADE ICE CREAM PIESTurtle or Peanut Butter Fudge
BIG WHEELS
- Original
- Large Chocolate Chip$8.99
FRESHLY SLICED BY THE POUND
- All Natural Roast Beef$15.79
- All Natural TurkeyServed in a Tin with au jus on side for dipping. For presentation on a platter: add 4.00 per platter.$14.99
- BBQ BeefOur All Natural Beef sauteed in our own BBQ Sauce.$12.59
- CondimentsHorseradish, Ketchup, Mayonnaise, Banana Peppers.
ROLLS
- Kimmelweck, Kaiser
- Ancient Grain
- Gluten Free
CHICKEN TENDERS BY THE POUND
- Chicken Tenders By The Pound8-9 tenders per pound.
CORPORATE SAMPLER PLATTER
- 10 Mini Assorted Sandwiches$47.50
- 20 Mini Assorted Sandwiches$95.00
SIDES & SALADS
- GARDEN SALADWith mixed greens. Approximately 7-10 servings per lb.
- CAESAR SALADWith mixed greens. Approximately 7-10 servings per lb.
- POTATO SALADTraditional egg and mustard. Approximately 3-4 servings per lb.
- HOMESTYLE MAC N CHEESE
- BROCCOLI BACON & ALMOND SALAD
- CONFETTI VEGGIE PASTAIncludes mixed peppers, onion, cucumber, tomatoes, black olives, carrots and pasta with balsamic vinaigrette.
- GREEK PASTA SALADIncludes feta cheese, tomatoes, black olives, banana peppers, tri colored pasta and Greek Dressing. Requires 48 hours notice
- BACON CHEESY MASHED POTATOESReal mashed potatoes w nitrate free bacon & cheddar.
- MASHED POTATOES WITH GRAVY
EQUIPMENT RENTAL
- Silver Bullet Coolers (Each)$20.00
- Hot Fudge Warmer & Pump (Each)$10.00
- Crock Pot (Each)$10.00
BOXED LUNCHES
- ClassicSandwich, Condiments, Side Item, Cookie & Drink
- CustomizedCustomized Sandwich, Condiments, Side Item, Cookie & Drink
BAGGED LUNCHES
- ClassicSandwich, Condiments, Side Item & Cookie
- CustomizedCustomized Sandwich, Condiments, Side Item & Cookie
SUNDAE KIT
- Make At Home Sundae KitIncludes ~ • 3 pints Signature Frozen Custard (1 each of Vanilla, Twist, Chocolate) • Hot Fudge • M&M’s • Oreo Cookie Pieces • Rainbow Sprinkles Must Be Pre-Ordered Online Serves 6-8$26.99
READY TO SERVE SUNDAE BAR
- Ready To Serve Sundae BarIncludes: • Dishes of your favorite Handmade Ice Creams • Your Choice of 2 Sundae Toppings: Strawberry, Caramel, Hot Fudge, Peanut Butter or Cold Chocolate Syrup • Choice of 2: M & M’s, Reese’s Pieces, Spanish Peanuts or Chopped Nuts • Rainbow Spr...$7.50
READY TO SERVE DISHES
- Handmade Ice Cream Small Dish$4.59
- Non-Dairy Plant Based Small Dish$5.54
- Signature Frozen Custard Small Dish$3.94
ICE CREAM ALA CARTE ITEMS
- Our Famous Signature Frozen CustardBy the pint.$6.49
- Handmade Ice Cream & Frozen YogurtBy the pint.$7.99
- Non Dairy Plant Based Frozen DessertBy the pint.$9.08
- Hot Fudgeper pint (15 servings)$4.50
- Caramelper pint (15 servings)$4.50
- Peanut Butterper pint (15 servings)$4.50
- Strawberriesper pint (10 servings)$4.50
- Chocolate Syrupper pint (30 servings)$4.50
- Sprinklesper pint (30 servings)$2.59
- Candiesper pint (15 servings)$6.00
- Nutsper pint (15 servings)$7.00
- Whipped Creamper can (40 servings)$7.00
PREMIUM HANDMADE ICE CREAM CAKES
- Round(Serves 8-10)$26.49
- Small Sheet(Serves 16-20). Personalized Message For Free$40.99
OUR SPECIALTY HANDMADE ICE CREAM CAKE SERIES
- Cookies & Cream Dream With Real Oreo$31.99
- Rainbow Fudge With Real M&Ms$31.99
- Cookie Dough$31.99
- Seasonal Favorites$31.99
HANDMADE ICE CREAM FUDGE GANACHE CAKES
- Peanut ButterRich Chocolate Ganache with our Handmade Ice Cream.$40.99
- Mint FudgeRich Chocolate Ganache with our Handmade Ice Cream.$40.99
HANDMADE ICE CREAM PIES
- Turtle, Peanut Butter Fudge & Seasonal Specialties!To make any visit a special one!!$19.99
Menu Gallery
Menu Gallery
Menus may not be up to date.