Anderson's Frozen Custard Menu

2369 Niagara Fls Blvd, Amherst, NY 14228
  • Our Famous Signature Frozen Custard

    • Small

      $3.94
    • Medium

      $4.74
    • Large

      $5.39
    • Pint

      $6.49
  • Handmade ICE CREAM & FROZEN YOGURT

    • 1 Scoop

      Cones & Dishes
      $4.59
    • 2 Scoops

      $5.49
    • 3 Scoops

      $6.69
    • Pint

      $7.99
  • Non Dairy Plant Based Frozen Desserts

    • 1 Scoop

      $5.54
    • 2 Scoops

      $6.44
    • 3 Scoops

      $7.64
    • Pint

      $9.08
  • Original Lemon Ice

    • Lemon Ice

  • Sundaes

    • Create Your Own

      Toppings: Peanut Butter, Hot Fudge, Cold Chocolate Syrup, Butterscotch, Strawberry, Pineapple, Raspberry, Marshmallow, Caramel Extras: Nuts—Chopped, Spanish, Pecans — Add 1.26 Real Whipped Cream — Add 1.26 Candy — Add 1.26
    • Signature Sundaes

      Reese’s Pieces Deluxe Peanut Butter -Hot Fudge & Reese’s® Pieces Mexican- Our Own Chocolate Sauce & Spanish Nuts Turtle- Hot Fudge, Butterscotch & Pecans Made with our own Signature Vanilla Frozen Custard
    • Banana Split

      Vanilla & Chocolate Custard, Chocolate, Strawberry & Pineapple Toppings, Banana, Whipped Cream & Nuts
      $8.29
    • Brownie Overboard

      Rich Fudgy Brownie with Vanilla & Chocolate Frozen Custard, Hot Fudge, Whipped Cream & Chopped Nuts
      $8.29
    • Choco-Peanut Butter Passion

      Chocolate Peanut Butter Ice Cream, Hot Fudge, Peanut Butter, Peanut Butter Cookie, Whipped Cream & Reese’s® Peanut Butter Cups
      $8.29
    • Strawberry Glacier

      Our Lemon Ice topped with strawberries
      $4.49
  • Arctic Swirls

    • Arctic Swirl

      Smother it with Hot Fudge—Add .52 Double Dose Your Candy —Add 1.16
  • Handmade Ice cream Cakes

    • Round

      Serves 8-10
      $26.49
    • Small Sheet

      Serves 16-20
      $43.99
    • Decadent Series

      Serves 8-10 Cookies & Cream Dream w/real Oreo, Rainbow Fudge w/real M&M’s, Cookie Dough, plus seasonal favorites
      $32.99
    • Fudgie Turtle

      Serves 12-15
      $46.99
    • Fudge Ganache

      Serves 12-15
      $44.99
  • Homemade Ice Cream Pies

    • Turtle, Cookies & Cream With Real Oreo, Peanut Butter Fudge

  • Big Wheels

    • Original

    • Large Chocolate Chip

      $9.99
  • Sundae Kits

    • Classic

      $25.00
    • Customized

      $29.00
  • CHOCOLATE SODAS

    • Chocolate Sodas

  • Johnnie Ryan FLOATS

    • Johnnie Ryan Floats

      Cherry, Orange, Birch Beer, Root Beer, Grape, Loganberry, Cream Soda, Cola, Diet
  • STRAWBERRY SENSATION

    • Original Lemon Ice Blended With Lemon Up & Strawberries

  • BEVERAGES

    • Soft Drinks

    • Coffee

    • Bottled Water

      $2.49
    • Bottled Pop

      $2.99
  • MILKSHAKES

    • Milkshakes

      Chocolate, Black Raspberry, Vanilla, Pistachio, Strawberry, Cinnamon, Coffee, Loganberry, Root Beer, Mint, Peanut Butter, Hot Fudge , Caramel , Strawberries, Raspberries, Real Bananas - Add .55 each Make it a Malt add 55¢ Any item made with Hard...
  • Non Dairy Plant Based Shakes

    • Regular

      $5.74
    • Large

      $7.14
  • ROAST BEEF SANDWICHES

    • ORIGINAL

      3 oz.
      $8.49
    • CARL'S CHOICE

      5 oz.
      $9.99
    • BARBECUE BEEF

      $7.49
  • TURKEY SANDWICHES

    • ORIGINAL TURKEY SANDWICHES

      3 oz. (Served hot or cold)
      $8.49
    • CARL'S CHOICE TURKEY SANDWICHES

      5 oz. (Served hot or cold)
      $9.99
  • VEGAN SANDWICH

    • VEGGIE WRAP

      Avocado, Lettuce, Cucumber, Tomato, Red Onion & Balsamic
      $5.99
    • VEGGIE BURGER

      With Lettuce, Tomato & Red Onion, served on Ancient Grain
      $7.89
  • CHICKEN & FISH

    • BUFFALO STYLE CHICKEN TENDER SANDWICH

      with Lettuce, Wing Sauce & Blue Cheese on Kaiser
      $8.49
    • CHICKEN TENDER BASKET

      with Fries. Plain or Buffalo Style
    • Grilled All-Natural CHICKEN

      with Lettuce & Tomato on Kaiser
      $8.49
    • CAESAR CHICKEN WRAP

      Almonds, Cucumbers, Parmesan , Lettuce & Caesar Dressing
      $10.99
    • Wild Caught FISH SANDWICH

      With Lettuce, Tomato, Tartar on Kaiser
      $8.99
  • ROLLS & BREADS

    • Kimmelweck

      Rolls
    • Kaiser

      Rolls
    • Ancient Grain

      Rolls
    • Gluten Free

      Rolls
      $2.49
    • Organic Sprouted White

      Breads
    • Wrap

      Breads
  • CONDIMENTS

    • Condiments

      Horseradish, Ketchup, Mustard, Honey Mustard, Mayonnaise, Onion, Lettuce, Tomato, Pickles, Relish, BBQ Sauce
  • SANDWICH EXTRAS

    • Thick Beef Gravy

    • Melted Cheddar Sauce

    • American

    • Provolone

    • Feta Cheese

  • MORE SANDWICH EXTRAS

    • Nitrate Free Bacon

    • Avocado

  • GRILL ITEMS

    • HAMBURGER

      All Natural Beef
    • CHEESEBURGER

      All Natural Beef
    • HOT DOG

      Sahlen's
      $3.99
  • FRIES & SIDES

    • Curly Que Fries

    • Sweet Potato Fries

    • Cajun Fries

    • Onion Rings

    • Baked Potato

      Large
      $3.29
    • Mac ‘N Cheese

    • Potato Salad

      $3.09
  • COMBO MEAL

    • CREATE YOUR OWN COMBO MEAL

      Choose any Sandwich, plus any Side Item or Salad, plus any Drink and Save 1.00! ~ excludes junior size ~
  • SALADS

    • Create Your Own Salad

      Start with Mixed Greens, then select your toppings: Includes your choice of: Croutons, Banana Peppers, Cucumber, Tomato, Chow Mein Noodles, Red Onion. Salad Extras: add 1.29 each Broccoli, Pecans, Almonds, Mandarin Oranges, Feta Cheese. Add Protei...
      $5.96
    • GRILLED CHICKEN MANDARIN SALAD

      Mixed Greens, Almonds, Chinese Noodles, Mandarin Oranges & Balsamic Vinaigrette.
      $14.53
    • Spring Salad

      Mixed Greens, Feta Cheese, Red Onion, Pecans, Mandarin Oranges & Raspberry Vinaigrette.
      $9.83
    • Side Salad

      with tomato & cucumber
      $4.19
  • KIDS MEALS

    • CHOOSE ONE MAIN ITEM

      All-Natural Roast Beef, BBQ Beef, All-Natural Turkey, Hot Dog, Grilled All-Natural Chicken Strips, Mac 'n Cheese
    • CHOOSE ONE SIDE DISH

      Curly Fries, Steamed Broccoli, Applesauce, Banana, Chips
    • CHOOSE ONE BEVERAGE

      Chocolate Milk, Apple Juice Box, Pop, Milk
  • CHOCOLATE SODAS

    • CHOCOLATE SODAS

    • Johnnie Ryan ROOT BEER FLOAT

      Cherry, Orange, Birch Beer, Root Beer, Loganberry, Cream Soda, Cola, Diet
  • STRAWBERRY SENSATION

    • STRAWBERRY SENSATION

      No Fat & Non-Dairy. Original Lemon Ice blended with Lemon Up & Strawberries
  • BEVERAGES

    • Coffee Or Tea

      $1.99
    • Bottled Pop

      $3.19
    • Bottled Water

      $2.49
    • Soft Drinks

  • MILKSHAKES

    • MILKSHAKES

      Made with Signature Frozen Custard. Chocolate, Black Raspberry, Vanilla, Pistachio, Strawberry, Cinnamon, Coffee, Loganberry, Root Beer, Mint. Peanut Butter, Hot Fudge, Caramel, Strawberries, real Bananas Add 0.59 each. Make it a Malt - Add 0.59
  • PLANT BASED SHAKES

    • PLANT BASED SHAKES

  • FROZEN CUSTARD

    • FROZEN CUSTARD

      Cones & Dishes: Vanilla, Chocolate, Twist & Daily Special
  • ICE CREAM & FROZEN YOGURT

    • ICE CREAM & FROZEN YOGURT

      Cones & Dishes
  • PLANT BASED FROZEN DESSERT

    • PLANT BASED FROZEN DESSERT

      Cones & Dishes
  • EXTRAS

    • Waffle Cone / Bowl

      $1.24
    • Dipped Waffle Cone / Bowl

      $2.46
    • Gluten Free Cone

    • Sprinkles

  • ORIGINAL LEMON ICE

    • ORIGINAL LEMON ICE

      ORIGINAL LEMON ICE & Flavor of the Day
  • CREATE A SUNDAE

    • Create A Sundae

      Toppings: Peanut Butter, Hot Fudge, Butterscotch, Cold Chocolate Syrup, Strawberry, Pineapple, Marshmallow, Hot Caramel. Extras: Whipped Cream 0.99, Candies 1.29, Nuts 1.29 (Chopped, Spanish Peanuts, Pecans)
  • SIGNATURE SUNDAES

    • Reese’s Pieces Deluxe

      Peanut Butter, Hot Fudge & Reese’s® Pieces
    • Mexican

      Chocolate Sauce & Spanish Nuts
    • Turtle

      Hot Fudge, Hot Caramel & Pecans
  • SPECIALTY SUNDAES

    • Banana Split

      Vanilla & Chocolate Custard, Chocolate, Strawberry & Pineapple Toppings, Banana, Whipped Cream & Nuts
      $8.79
    • Brownie Overboard

      Rich Fudgy Brownie with Vanilla & Chocolate Frozen Custard, Hot Fudge, Whipped Cream & Chopped Nuts
      $8.79
    • Choco-Peanut Butter Passion

      Chocolate Peanut Butter Ice Cream, Hot Fudge, Peanut Butter, Whipped Cream, Peanut Butter Cookie & Reese’s® Peanut Butter Cups
      $8.79
    • Strawberry Glacier

      Our Lemon Ice topped with strawberries.
      $4.49
  • ARCTIC SWIRLS

    • ARCTIC SWIRLS

      M&M’s®, Reese’s® Pieces, Oreo, Cookie Dough, Reese’s PB Cup® Heath, Brownie, Birthday Cake. Smother it with Hot Fudge—Add .59
  • HANDMADE ICE CREAM CAKES

    • Classic Round

      Serves 8-10
      $26.49
    • Small Sheet

      Serves 16-20
      $40.99
    • Decadent Series

      Serves 8-10. Cookies & Cream Dream w/real Oreo, Rainbow Fudge w/real M&M’s, Cookie Dough Plus Seasonal Favorites
      $30.99
    • Fudgie Turtle

      Serves 12-15
      $43.99
    • Fudge Ganache

      Serves 12-15. Peanut Butter or Mint
      $39.99
  • HANDMADE ICE CREAM PIES

    • Handmade ICE CREAM PIES

      Turtle or Peanut Butter Fudge
  • BIG WHEELS

    • Original

    • Large Chocolate Chip

      $8.99
  • FRESHLY SLICED BY THE POUND

    • ALL-NATURAL ROAST BEEF

      $17.99
    • ALL-NATURAL TURKEY

      $15.99
  • OTHER ENTREES

    • BBQ BEEF

      Our All-Natural Beef simmered in our own BBQ Sauce. dinner sized rolls– yield is 6-8 sandwiches per pound. regular rolls– yield is 3-4 sandwiches per pound
    • CHICKEN TENDERS

      6-7 tenders per pound. includes dipping sauce
  • ROLLS

    • Kimmelweck

    • Kaiser

    • Ancient Grain

    • Gluten Free

  • CORPORATE SAMPLER SANDWICH PLATTERS

    • Classic Roast Beef & Turkey Platter

      All-natural Roast Beef & All-Natural Turkey Sandwiches
    • Mixed Platter

      All-Natural Roast Beef & All-Natural Turkey Sandwiches, Veggie Wraps, & Caesar All-Natural Chicken Wraps
  • SIDES & SALADS

    • GARDEN SALAD

      Mixed Greens, cucumbers, tomatoes, croutons, Choice of Ranch or Balsamic Dressing. (7-10 svgs per pound.)
    • POTATO SALAD

      Traditional Mustard & Egg. (3-4 svgs per pound.)
    • HOMESTYLE MAC 'N CHEESE

    • BROCCOLI BACON ALMOND & ONION SALAD

      with dressing
    • GREEK PASTA SALAD

      with banana peppers,, feta cheese, tomatoes, black olives, cucumbers, pasta in Greek Dressing.
    • BACON CHEESY MASHED POTATOES

      Real mashed potatoes w nitrate free bacon, butter, cheddar cheese & sour cream.
    • MASHED POTATOES WITH GRAVY

    • CURLY QUE FRIES

  • BAGGED LUNCHES

    • Classic

      Includes a Sandwich, (condiments on side) a Side Item, & Cookie
    • Customized

      Customized Sandwich, (condiments on side) Side Item, Cookie
  • Handmade Ice Cream Cakes

    • Classic Round

      Vanilla & Chocolate Ice Creams with a center of Chocolate Crunchies. Personalized Message For Free
    • SPECIALTY SERIES

      Cookies & Cream Dream w Real Oreo, Rainbow Fudge & M&M's, Cookie Dough (Plus Seasonal Favorites)
      $30.99
    • FUDGE GANACHE

      Rich Chocolate Ganache with our Handmade Ice Cream. Peanut Butter or Mint Fudge
      $39.99
    • ICE CREAM PIES

      Turtle, Peanut Butter Fudge & Seasonal Specialties!
      $19.99
  • READY TO SERVE SUNDAE BAR

    • READY TO SERVE SUNDAE BAR

      Includes: • Dishes of Handmade Ice Creams • Your Choice of 2 Sundae Toppings: Strawberry, Caramel, Hot Fudge, Cold Chocolate Syrup • Your Choice of 2: M&M’s, Reese’s Pieces, Oreos, Nuts • Rainbow Sprinkles & Whipped Cream • Spoons & Napkins
  • READY TO SERVE DISHES

    • Handmade Ice Cream

      $3.99
    • Non Dairy Plant Based

      $4.79
    • Signature Frozen Custard

      $3.59
    • Original Lemon Ice

      $2.49
  • EQUIPMENT RENTAL

    • SILVER BULLET COOLER Rental

      A cooler on wheels that will keep desserts frozen for up to 2 hours* ( when not opened) Must be returned within 48 hours to avoid further charges.
      $35.00
  • ICE CREAM ALA CARTE ITEMS

    • Signature Frozen Custard

      Frozen Dessert By the Pint
      $6.49
    • Handmade Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt

      Frozen Dessert By the Pint
      $8.59
    • Non Dairy Plant Based Frozen Dessert

      Frozen Dessert By the Pint
      $9.89
    • Hot Fudge Or Caramel

      Toppings Per Pint. Servings Per Pint: 15-18
      $7.00
    • Peanut Butter

      Toppings Per Pint. Servings Per Pint: 15-18
      $7.00
    • Strawberries

      Toppings Per Pint. Servings Per Pint: 10-12
      $7.00
    • Chocolate Syrup

      Toppings Per Pint. Servings Per Pint: 25-30
      $7.00
    • Sprinkles

      Toppings Per Pint. Servings Per Pint: 25-30
      $5.00
    • Candies & Nuts

      Toppings Per Pint. Servings Per Pint: 25-30
      $9.00
    • Whipped Cream Can

      Toppings Per Pint. Servings Per Pint: 30-40
      $7.00
  • Make at Home Sundae Kits

    • Classic Sundae Kit

      Serves 6-8. Includes ~ • 3 pints Signature Frozen Custard: (Vanilla, Chocolate & Twist) • Hot Fudge • M&M’s • Oreo Cookie Pieces • Rainbow Sprinkles
      $28.99
    • Custom Sundae Kit

      Serves 6-8. Includes ~ • 3 pints of Your Choice! ♦ Handmade Ice Cream, ♦ Signature Frozen Custard, ♦ Plant Based Non-Dairy, ♦ Original Lemon Ice • Your Choice of Sundae Sauce • Your Choice of Candies or Nuts • Rainbow or Chocolate Sprinkles
      $32.99

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms