Casey J's Tavern + American BBQ Catering Menu

4.5

(625+ Reviews)

In The Beginning The Greener Side Handhelds Mains Kids Corner Fries, Rings & Things AMBBQ Favorites Sides Desserts Specials PT & QT BBQ Meats PT & QT Sides Grilled & Other Choices Bulk BBQ Sauces Pig-Nic Packages Fajita Kit

In The Beginning
- 6 Chicken Wings
  choice of jerk-spiced, buffalo or BBQ
  $12.50
- 9 Chicken Wings
  choice of jerk-spiced, buffalo or BBQ
  $16.50
- Burnt Ends
  pork belly, cherry-bourbon sauce, sesame, brioche
  $16.50
- Chili - BOWL
  Route 66 Chili. Topped with cheese
  $12.00
- Chili - CUP
  Route 66 Chili. Topped with cheese
  $9.00
- Corn Chowder - BOWL
  $8.00
- Corn Chowder - CUP
  $6.00
- Empanadas
  smoked brisket, chiles, cheddar jack cheese, grilled scallion, salsa fresca
  $14.50
- Potato Skins
  Homemade. 3 potato Skins stuffed with cheese. Topped with bacon, scallions & sour cream. Add Caramelized Onions for $1.50
  $12.50
- Ultimate Nachos
  Fried tortilla chips smothered in a Jack cheese blend. Topped with black beans, pico de gallo, jalapeños, sour cream & guacamole.
  $12.50
The Greener Side
- Cobb Salad
  Mixed greens, chopped bacon, grilled corn, tomatoes, crumbled bleu cheese, avocado, & hard boiled eggs. Served with poppy seed dressing on the side.
  $15.50
- Garden Salad
  Mixed greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, peppers, shredded carrots and croutons.
  $14.50
- Ceasar Salad
  Romaine, croutons, shaved cheese mixed with our house Caesar dressing.
  $14.50
- Half Caesar Salad
  $6.50
Handhelds
- Pulled Pork Sandwich
  Smoked BBQ Pulled Pork sandwich, coleslaw, pickles, on a potato roll
  $17.50
- Que-Bano
  virginia ham, smoked beef brisket, swiss cheese, honey mustard, pickles, on a grilled hoagie
  $19.50
- Patty Melt
  grilled 8 oz. angus beef patty, caramelized onions, in a grilled cheese sandwich
  $19.50
- Brisket Bomb
  sliced beef brisket, peppers, onions, mushrooms, cheese in a sub roll
  $19.50
- Kielbasa Bomb
  our smoked kielbasa sausage, peppers, onions, mushrooms, american cheese, in a sub roll
  $17.50
- Smashburger
  two 4 oz. beef patties, american cheese, pickles, homemade comeback sauce
  $16.50
- Fish Tacos
  Cajun spiced Fried Haddock, cabbage, pico de gallo, cilantro, chipotle aioli. Can be requested as Grilled Haddock.
  $18.50
- American Burger
  8 oz. burger served with lettuce, tomato & a pickle.
  $15.50
- Quesadilla
  Grilled flour tortilla with melted Jack cheese, roasted mushrooms, onions & peppers. Served with sour cream & salsa.
  $16.50
- Dog Daze
  Two grilled beef franks with all the fixings
  $16.50
- Crispy Chicken Sandwich
  Deep fried boneless chicken with lettuce, onions, avocados and Habanero Ranch sauce.
  $16.50
- Grilled Chicken Sandwich
  Lettuce, tomato, onion, avocado with habanero ranch.
  $16.50
- Sliced Beef Brisket Sand
  $18.50
- Veggie Burger
  $16.50
- Fried Haddock Sandwich
  Lettuce, tomato, and tartar sauce on the side.
  $16.50
- Brisket Reuben
  lean pastrami, swiss cheese, coleslaw, thousand island dressing
  $19.00
- Pulled Chicken Sandwich
  $17.50
- Rowley Reuben
  lean pastrami, swiss cheese, coleslaw, thousand island dressing
  $18.50
Mains
- Jerk Smoked 1/2 Chicken
  rice, green beans
  $26.50
- Steak Tips
  1lb of Charbroiled Tips
  $28.50
- Fish & Chips
  fries, coleslaw, tartar sauce
  $25.50
- Honey Chipotle Salmon
  8 ozs served with two sides & lemon.
  $28.50
- Baked Haddock
  Served with tartar sauce
  $26.50
- Chicken Finger Basket
  homestyle seasoned chicken breast, fries, honey mustard
  $19.50
Kids Corner
- Kids Hamburger
  $10.00
- Kids Cheeseburger
  $11.00
- Kids Mac N Cheese
  Bowl, No side
  $10.00
- Kids Chicken Tenders
  3 Chicken Tenders
  $10.00
- Kids Hot Dog
  $9.00
- Kids Ribs
  Two Ribs
  $10.00
- Kids Pulled Pork Sandwich
  $11.00
- Kids Pulled Chicken Sandwich
  $10.00
- Kids Cheese Quesadilla
  $9.00
- Kids Grilled Cheese
  $9.00
Fries, Rings & Things
- Fried Pickles
  With chipotle aioli sauce.
  $10.50
- French Fries
  $7.00
- Sweet Potato Fries
  $8.00
- Bowl Jerk Spiced Potato Chips
  Jerked Spiced Homemade Potato Chips
  $6.00
- Onion Rings Basket
  $9.00
- Truffle Fries
  Our french fries tossed in truffle oil & topped with parmesan
  $9.00
- Chili Cheese Fries
  $10.00
- Waffle Fries
  $9.00
- Kitchen Sink
  $12.00
AMBBQ Favorites
- 1/3 Rack Ribs
  Served with a choice of two sides & cornbread.
  $18.50
- 1/2 Rack Ribs
  Served with a choice of two sides & cornbread.
  $24.50
- Full Rack Ribs
  Served with a choice of two sides & cornbread.
  $34.50
- Pulled Pork
  Served with a choice of two sides & cornbread.
  $19.50
- Pulled Chicken
  Served with a choice of two sides & cornbread.
  $19.50
- Smoked Kielbasa
  Served with a choice of two sides & cornbread.
  $19.50
- Sliced Beef Brisket Pt
  Served with a choice of two sides & cornbread.
  $28.50
- 2 Meat Combo
  Served with a choice of two sides & cornbread.
  $30.00
- 3 Meat Combo
  Served with a choice of two sides & cornbread.
  $34.00
Sides
- Spanish Rice Side
  $4.50
- Brussel Sprouts Side
  $4.50
- Coleslaw Side
  $4.50
- Green Beans Side
  $4.50
- Baked Beans Side
  $4.50
- Mac N Cheese Side
  $4.50
- Mashed Potatoes Side
  $4.50
- Southern Greens Side
  $4.50
- Cuke, Onion, Carrot Salad Side
  $4.50
- Potato Chips Side
  $4.50
- Cornbread Side
  $2.50
- Pickles Side
  $4.00
- Apple sauce
  $1.00
- No Side
- Spinach Side
  $4.50
- sm side onion rings
  $4.50
- Side Tortilla Chip
  $2.00
- Flour Tortillas (3)
  $2.50
Desserts
- Key Lime Pie
  Homemade
  $11.00
- Apple Crisp
  $12.00
- Skillet Cookie w Ice Cream
  Skillet Chocolate Chip Cookie w Ice Cream
  $8.00
- Chocolate Cake
  Decadent Chocolate Cake
  $10.00
- Steve's Pecan Pie
  Homemade
  $10.00
- Vanilla Ice Cream Cup
  $5.00
Specials
- Boiled Dinner
  $24.00
PT & QT BBQ Meats
Larger Quantities Available, Call Restaurant to Order
- Pulled Pork
  $10.00
- Pulled Chicken
  $9.00
- Smoked Kielbasa
  $9.00
- Sliced Beef Brisket
  $12.00
- St. Louis Pork Ribs
  $18.00
- Dry Spiced Chicken Wings
  $55.00
- Mild BBQ Chicken Wings
  $55.00
- Buffalo Chicken Wings
  $55.00
- Chipotle Molasses Chicken Wings
  $55.00
PT & QT Sides
Larger Quantities Available, Call Restaurant to Order
- Baked Beans
  $9.00
- Macaroni N' Cheese
  $10.00
- Red Bliss Mashed Potato
  $9.00
- Spanish Rice
  $9.00
- String Beans
  $9.00
- Roasted Mushroom, Onions, Peppers
  $10.00
- Southern Greens
  $9.00
- Coleslaw
  $9.00
- Cucumber, Onion, Carrot Salad
  $9.00
- Cornbread
  $2.50
- Dozen Sandwich Rolls
  $7.00
- Gluten Free Sandwich Rolls
  $2.00
Grilled & Other Choices
- Steak Tips - LBS
  $32.00
- Grilled Salmon
  $28.00
- Chicken Tenders - 4LBS
  $56.00
- Dozen Cheeseburgers & Buns
  $50.00
- Dozen Hot Dogs & Buns
  $33.00
Bulk BBQ Sauces
- Mild BBQ
  $4.00
- Hot BBQ
  $4.00
- Chipotle Molasses BBQ
  $4.00
- Yellow BBQ
  $4.00
Pig-Nic Packages
Please allow minimum of 30 minutes when placing order. MAX 2 PER ORDER. No substitutions.
- Package 1 (Serves 5-6)
  1 Racks Pork Ribs 12 Chicken Wings 1 PT Sandwich Meat 3 Pint Sides 8 Pieces CB 1/2 PT BBQ Sauce
  $160.00
- Package 2 (Serves 14-15)
  3 Racks Pork Ribs 24 Chicken Wings 2 QT Sandwich Meat 3 QT Sides 14 Pieces of CB 2 - 1/2 Pt BBQ Sauce
  $355.00
Fajita Kit
- Fajita Kit (Serves 4-5)
  $70.00
- Fajita Kit (Serves 8-9)
  $130.00