Almost Heaven Ice Cream Menu

$Ice cream shop, Dessert shop, Restaurant

624 Prospect Ave S, Hartville, OH 44632

Order Online

Seasonal Items Door Dash

Seasonal Items
- Brown Butter Graham
  Brown Butter ice cream swirled with a delightful graham cracker. This combination has become a best seller!
  $4.25
- White Chocolate Peppermint
  White chocolate ice cream with a peppermint buttercream swirl.
  $4.25
- Campfire Special
  A rich chocolate base, featuring delightful swirls of marshmallow and graham cracker.
  $4.25
- Dark Chocolate Peppermint (Dairy Free)
  Dark chocolate dairy free ice cream with peppermint candy pieces.
  $4.25
- Pumpkin Roll
  Creamy cream cheese ice cream is sandwiched between two soft and spiced pumpkin cookies, creating a delightful pumpkin roll ice cream sandwich.
  $8.10
- Cinnamon Roll
  Cinnamon Roll flavored ice cream with a sweet frosting swirl.
  $4.25
- Dark Chocolate PBC Ice Cream Sandwich
  $8.00
- Fun-Fetti Ice Cream Sandwich
  $8.00
- Triple Chocolate Ice Cream Sandwich
  $8.00
- Cheesecake Cups
  Each seasonal flavor features different indulgent layers. But one, our strawberry cheesecake cup for example includes layers of creamy vanilla ice cream, a buttery graham cracker crust, rich cheesecake pieces, with a strawberry topping creating a delightful combination of textures and flavors.
  $10.00
Door Dash
- Peanut Butter Ice Cream Pie
  Indulge in the ultimate dessert experience with our homemade ice cream pie. Made with premium ingredients, this delectable treat is the perfect balance of creamy vanilla ice cream, peanut butter cups, homemade peanut butter and chocolate drizzle and a graham cracker crust. Order your ice cream pie today and savor every bite!
  $19.50
- Kids Dish
  Choose 1 of our permanent flavors. Served with a lid and spoon. Our seasonal offerings are available exclusively in-store.
  $4.25
- Ice Cream Sandwich
  Choose your favorite cookie and ice cream flavor to create a personalized treat that's as unique as you are. Order now and satisfy your sweet tooth with a delicious custom ice cream sandwich!
  $8.10
- Oreo Ice Cream Pie
  Indulge in the ultimate dessert experience with our homemade ice cream pie. Made with premium ingredients, this delectable treat is the perfect balance of creamy ice cream , oreos, chocolate drizzle and a graham cracker crust. Order your ice cream pie today and savor every bite!
  $19.50
- Small Dish
  Choose up to 2 of our permanent flavors. Served with a lid and spoon. Our seasonal offerings are available exclusively in-store.
  $6.25
- Medium Dish
  Choose up to 3 of our permanent flavors. Served with a lid and spoon. Our seasonal offerings are available exclusively in-store.
  $8.50
- Cone To Go
  Waffle cones are made fresh daily, upgrade your waffle cone by dipping it in chocolate, or stick to the classic cake cone. When ordered online cones will be packaged separately to go.
- Large Dish
  Choose up to 4 of our permanent flavors. Served with a lid and spoon. Our seasonal offerings are available exclusively in-store.
  $10.75
- Quart
  Choose from a variety of our permanent handcrafted flavors and enjoy the creamy goodness of our super-premium ice cream in the comfort of your home. Simply browse our selection, select your desired flavor, and place your order for pick up.
  $16.20
- Doggy Dish
  A dollop of soft serve vanilla with a dog treat on top!
  $2.00