Allie Boy’s Bagelry & Luncheonette Menu
135 E National Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53204
BULK BAGELS
- Half Dozen BagelsORDER IN PERSON OR BY PHONE ONLY$14.00
- Baker's DozenORDER IN PERSON OR BY PHONE ONLY$25.00
- 6pk Day OldsMixed 6 packs, available as is$7.00
Bagels
- Plain Bagel$2.50
- Pumpernickel Bagel$2.50
- Seeded Honey Wheat BagelContains Sunflower, Pumpkin, Millet & Flax Seeds$2.50
- Cinnamon Raisin Bagel$2.50
- Onion Bagel$2.50
- Everything Bagel$2.50
- Sesame Bagel$2.50
- Poppy Seed Bagel$2.50
- Bagel Of The Day!Dill Pickle!$3.00
- BialyBeefy Onions & Gouda Cheese *AVAILABLE WEEKENDS ONLY*$3.50
Schmears
- Salted Butter$1.50
- Whipped Honey Butter$2.00
- Whipped Goat Butter$2.00
- Plain Cream Cheese$1.50
- Vegan Cream CheeseOur House-Made Dairy Free Schmear, CONTAINS NUTS$3.00
- Garden Veggie Cream Cheese$2.00
- Roasted Shallot Cream Cheese$2.00
- Labneh & Herb Cream Cheese$2.00
- Smoked Salmon & Sesame$4.50
- Schmear Of The Day!$2.00
- Seasonal JamCranberry Raspberry Rosemary$2.50
- Almond Praline ButterMade In-House!$3.50
- Bacon Jam$3.00
Noshes
- Bubbe's Matzoh Ball SoupRoast Chicken, Veggies, Schmaltz, Herbs$8.50
- Iceberg CrunchThick Slabs of Crisp Iceberg Lettuce, Topped with Greek Yogurt Ranch, Seasonal Veggies, Onion, Radish, Torn Herbs & Seeded Everything Bagel Crunch$8.00
- The Big Latke WaffleGriddled Potato Pancake (Waffle Style) Served with a Choice of Applesauce and Sour Cream OR Smoked Maple Syrup$9.00
Bagel Tartines
- Tamago Egg Salad TartineTamago Egg Salad, Green Onion, Furikake. Choice of a Whole or Half Portion Served Open-Faced$6.00
- Chicken Liver Mousse TartineChicken Liver Mousse, Chicken Skin Granola, Bacon, Date Molasses. Choice of a Half or Whole Portion Served Open-Faced$7.00
- Lox TartineHouse Cured Chopped Lox, Salt Roasted Beets, Avocado Gribiche, Fines Herbs, Lemon Oil, Horseradish, Salt & Vinegar Potato Chips. Choice of a Half or Whole Portion Served Open-Faced$7.00
Bagel Sandwiches
- Egg & CheeseHerbed Omelette, Soft Scrambled Egg, American Cheese, Aged Cheddar, Salt, Pepper, Ketchup$10.00
- Bacon, Egg & CheeseApplewood Smoked Bacon, Herbed Omelette, American Cheese, Aged Cheddar, Salt, Pepper, Ketchup$11.00
- Sausage, Egg & CheeseBoar's Head Breakfast Sausage, Herbed Omelette, American Cheese, Aged Cheddar, Salt, Pepper, Ketchup$11.00
- Pork Roll, Egg & CheeseTaylor Ham Pork Roll Imported from New Jersey, Herbed Omelette, American Cheese, Aged Cheddar, Salt, Pepper, Ketchup$11.00
- The Veg HeadAvocado, Raw Crunchy Veggies, Lemon Vinaigrette, Veggie Cream Cheese Schmear$12.00
- The MahatmaTandoori Style Roasted Cauliflower, Buttery Tomato Curry, Griddled Paneer Cheese, Herbed Slaw & Tamarind Chutney Vinaigrette$13.00
- The ApolloHouse Made Beef & Lamb Doner Kabob Patty, Oven Roasted Tomato, Griddled Red Onion, Spicy French Fries, Feta Tzatziki Sauce & Mint$14.00
- The ClassicHouse Cured Lox, Tomato, Onion, Caper, Dill, Labneh & Herb Cream Cheese (cream cheese includes scallion that cannot be removed)$14.00
- Pastrami Chop CheeseHouse Brined & Smoked Pastrami Brisket, Griddled Onion, Sport Pepper, Provolone Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato & Special Sauce$14.00
Deli & Sides
- Potato ChipsSalt & Vinegar Potato Chips$3.50
- Bagel ChipsOur Hand Rolled Gold Sliced & Baked$4.50
- Tamago Egg SaladGreen Onion, Furikake$4.00
- Whitefish Salad$5.00
- House-Made PicklesHouse-Made Pickle Spears and Seasonal Vegetables$1.00
- Fortified Chicken StockOur Fortified Chicken Stock (Frozen) Made In-House and Sold by the Quart!$10.00
Sweeties
- Fried Citrus Sugar Bagel$5.00
- Breakfast MuffinApricot, Saffron, Almond & Ginger$5.00
- Fresh Baked SconesBlack Currant Scone with Earl Grey Frosting$5.00
- Plum & Oat Breakfast BarToasted Oats, House Made Plum Jam, Cinnamon, Cardamom, Sesame$5.00
- Whipped Yogurt ParfaitWhipped Vanilla Bean Yogurt, Assorted Citrus, Meyer Lemon Curd, Fennel Pollen Honey, Toasted Meringue, Crispy Honey Comb, Graham-ola & Olive Oil$8.00
- The G.O.A.TFried Citrus Sugar Bagel, Sweet Chèvre Cream Cheese, Medjool Dates, Toasted Pistachios, Rose Honey & Crispy Phyllo$10.00
Specials
- Doggie Bagel TreatOat Flour, Peanut Butter, Anchovy, Bacon, Sweet Potato, Egg$1.50
- Spanish Seafood TinsImported Spanish Seafood Tins each served with House Cultured Leek Butter, Fried Matzoh & Assorted House Pickles & Ferments$16.00
- Pizza Bagel (Half Portion)Garlic Butter Brushed Bagel, Zesty House-Made Tomato Sauce, Whole Milk Mozzarella, Provolone, Pecorino, Fresh Basil. *AVAILABLE WEEKDAYS ONLY*$5.00
- Pizza Bagel (Whole Portion)Garlic Butter Brushed Bagel, Zesty House-Made Tomato Sauce, Whole Milk Mozzarella, Provolone, Pecorino, Fresh Basil. *AVAILABLE WEEKDAYS ONLY*$10.00
- Kickin' Kollards Hot Sauce (12oz Bottle)Smoked & Braised Collard Greens, Fermented Habaneros, Onion, Garlic, Red Wine Vinegar, Sugar, Salt. *Pasteurized, Keep Refrigerated*$10.00
Non-Alcoholic Beverages
- CoffeeOur Custom Blend "Bagel Brew" from Anodyne Coffee Roasting Co.$3.50
- Decaf Coffee$3.50
- Iced Coffee$4.00
- Espresso$3.25
- Latte$4.25
- Cappuccino$4.25
- Peace Out Peanut Milk Latte (ICED ONLY)House Made Toasted Peanut Milk, Anodyne Atomic Blend Espresso, Muscovado Sugar Syrup, Topped with a Fluffy Cinnamon Milk Foam (*CONTAINS PEANUTS & ALMONDS)$5.75
- TeaRishi Tea from Right Here in Milwaukee!$4.25
- House Iced Tea$3.00
- LemonadeFresh Squeezed!$3.50
- Arnold PalmerFresh Squeezed Lemonade Topped with Unsweetened Iced Tea$3.75
- Chocolate Egg CreamClassic Style Egg Cream made with Fox's U-bet Chocolate Syrup, Milk, & Topo Chico!$3.75
- Hot Chocolate$3.25
- "Bagel Brew" By The Bag 12ozOur Whole Bean Custom Brew from Anodyne Coffee Roasting Co. Originating from Central/South America$14.00
- Bottled Water$2.00
- Orange JuiceFresh Squeezed!$4.00
- Grapefruit JuiceFresh Squeezed!$4.00
- Martinelli Apple Juice$3.00
- Virgin Bloody MaryHouse-Made Bloody Mary Mix Spiked with Yemenite Zhug, Horseradish & Dill. *DOES NOT CONTAIN ALCOHOL*$6.50
- Tapuat Brewing Co. KombuchaDifferent flavors of Kombucha from Door County WI!$5.00
- Topo Chico Sparkling Water$3.00
- Mexican Coke$3.50
- Diet Coke$2.50
- Mexican Sprite$3.50
- Dr. Brown's Soda$2.75
Beer
- Miller High Life, 12ozID CHECKED UPON PICK UP$3.00
- Gummylicious Hazy IPA, Noon Whistle Brewing Co, 12oz, Lombard, ILBrewed with Citra, Citra Cryo, Mosaic, and Ekuanot hops giving it a deeply complex flavor profile that is bursting with juicy flavor and notes of tropical citrus ID CHECKED UPON PICK UP$4.50
- Sociable Cider, Skinny Tire, 12oz, Minneapolis, MNLight & Crisp on Flavor and Calories :P ID CHECKED UPON PICK UP$5.00
- Wasting Away Mexican Lager, BlackStack Brewing, 16oz, St. Paul, MNPale Pour, Smooth Malty Flavors, Maize with a Hint of Spice ID CHECKED UPON PICK UP$5.50
- Melancholia Saison, The Veil Brewing Co, 16oz, Norfolk, VAID CHECKED UPON PICK UP$5.50
- Chocolate Milk Stout, 4 Hands Brewing Co, 16oz, St. Louis, MORich, Chocolatey, Smooth Creaminess Provided by Cacao Nibs & Milk Sugar ID CHECKED UPON PICK UP$5.50
- White Grape Sour, Untitled Art, 16oz, Waunakee, WISour Ale Brewed with White Grapes ID CHECKED UPON PICK UP$6.00
- Nect-O-Cooler, Phase Three Brewing, 16oz, Lake Zurich, ILFruited Sour Ale packed with Orange and Tangerine with a green tint to it to remind us of our favorite childhood fruit juice drink. ID CHECKED UPON PICK UP$6.50
Cocktails
- Bloody Mary KitHouse-Made Bloody Mary Mix Spiked with Yemenite Zhug, Horseradish & Dill. Served with a Mini Bottle of Rehorst Vodka & Garnished with Usinger Garlic Beef Summer Sausage, Clock Shadow Creamery's Sadie Goat's Milk Cheddar Cheese, Pickled Quail Egg & Lemon ID CHECKED UPON PICK UP$12.00
- Blackberry Agave Hard Seltzer, 12oz, Untitled Art, Waunakee, WIID CHECKED UPON PICK UP$5.50
Wine
- Ramona Blood Orange Wine SpritzSicilian Zibibbo Grapes mixed with Organic Blood Orange Juice Certified WBENC ID CHECKED UPON PICK UP$5.50
- Chardonnay/Gruner Blend, Illahe Vineyards "Capitol Fizz" Sparkling Rosé, Oregon 187mlLively Acid, Aromas of Apple and Pear, with Strawberry Notes on the Palate. Single Serving Size Bottle! ID CHECKED UPON PICK UP$6.00
- Glera/Chardonnay, Adami NV Brut "Bosco Di Gica" Prosecco, Italy, 375mlYellow Apple and Peach on the Nose with a Crisp, Fresh Spiciness on the Palate. ID CHECKED UPON PICK UP$12.00
- Mimosa Kit375ml Bottle of Adami NV Brut "Bosco di Gica" Prosecco with 12oz of fresh squeezed orange juice ID CHECKED UPON PICK UP$16.00
T-Shirts
- I <3 AB's T$20.00
- Cream City Bagels (Cream)$25.00
- Cream City Bagels (Maroon)$25.00
- Fear The Schmear$30.00
- Makings Of A Veg Head$30.00
Hoodies
- Posh Nosh Zip-Up$42.00
- Your Place Hoodie*Sightly darker than pictured$65.00
Stickers
- Pink Bagel Bite Sticker$0.50
Pins
- Mustard Bagel Bite Pin$5.00
- Maroon Bagel Bite Pin$5.00
- Blush Bagel Bite Pin$5.00
Bandanas
- Cream Bandana$6.00
- Black Bandana$6.00
- Maroon Bandana$6.00
- Yellow Bandana$6.00
Greeting Cards
- Greeting CardsGreeting Cards Created by Our Talented Barista Calynn Klohn! Original Poetry Inside!$5.00
- Valentine’s Day Card BundlePack of 6 Cards, 2 of Each Design (Blank Inside)$10.00
