All Together Now Menu

4.7

(275+ Reviews)

$Restaurant, Cafe

Big Plates
- Beet, Blood Orange + Burrata Salad
  Orange Juice Braised Beets, Crushed Pistachios, Mint
  $16.00
- Farro + Cashew Salad
  Garlic +Cashew Cream, Baby Kale, Crumbled Blue Cheese, Horseradish Honey
  $16.00
Small Plates
- Fried Goat Cheese Curds
  Blakesville Creamery Curds, Pepper + Honey Relish, Fresh Herbs
  $18.00
Sandwiches
- French Exit
  Underground Meats Salami, Pleasant Ridge Reserve Cheese, Aioli, Mustard, Demi Baguette
  $13.00
- Smash Burger
  Slagel Farms Beef Patties, Fried Onions, Malt Vinegar Mayo, Pickles, Aged Cheddar, Griddled Shokupan
  $17.00
- Smashed White Bean
  White Beans, Feta, Herb Pistou, Pickled Shallot, Focaccia. Please be aware that this sandwich cannot be made without feta.
  $15.00
- Fried Egg Sandwich
  Soppressata, Aged Cheddar, Fresno Aioli, Housemade English Muffin
  $12.00
- Roast Beef Dip
  Roast Beef, Housemade Pickles, Red Cabbage Kraut, Havarti Cheese, Caraway Rye Bread, Dipping Jus
  $15.50
- Whitney + Broccoli
  Roasted Broccoli, French Sheep's Milk Cheese, Miso + Pumpkin Seed Butter, Griddled Sourdough
  $15.50
Bites
- Crispy Fingerling Potatoes
  Scallion + Lemon Powder, Malt Vinegar Mayo, Fresno Hot Sauce
  $8.00
- Green Salad
  Revol Farms Greens, Sarvecchio Cheese, Tarragon Dressing
  $7.00
Sweets
- Chess Pie
  $11.50
- Pecan Shortbread Sandwich Cookie
  Chocolate-Studded Pecan Shortbread, Chocolate Dulce de Leche Filling
  $4.00
- Malted Chocolate Oreo
  It's a Sandwich, But Better Because It's a Cookie
  $3.00
- Oatmeal Sandwich Cookie
  Honey Marshmallow Filling
  $3.50
- Monster Cookie
  Dark Chocolate, White Chocolate, Coconut, Marshmallows, Corn Nuts, Sea Salt
  $3.50
- All of the Cookies
  One of everything! Malted Chocolate Oreo, Pecan Shortbread, Monster Cookie, Oatmeal Sandwich Cookie
  $13.00
Big Plates
- SPECIAL: Crispy Panko Salmon
  $24.00
- Grilled Hanger Steak
  Szechuan Steak Sauce, Rutabaga Puree, Grilled Spanish Onions
  $29.00
- Creamy Garlic Braised Beans
  Carrot Puree, Chermoula, Crispy Rice
  $22.50
- Seared Duck Breast
  Grilled Broccoli, Garlic Toum, Passion Fruit Glaze
  $31.00
Small Plates
- Fried Goat Cheese Curds
  Blakesville Creamery Curds, Pepper + Honey Relish, Fresh Herbs
  $18.00
- Beet, Blood Orange + Burrata Salad
  Orange Juice Braised Beets, Crushed Pistachios, Mint
  $16.00
Sandwiches
- French Exit
  Underground Meats Salami, Pleasant Ridge Reserve Cheese, Aioli, Mustard, Demi Baguette
  $13.00
- Smash Burger
  Slagel Farms Beef Patties, Fried Onions, Malt Vinegar Mayo, Pickles, Aged Cheddar, Griddled Shokupan
  $17.00
- Roast Beef Dip
  Roast Beef, Housemade Pickles, Red Cabbage Kraut, Havarti Cheese, Caraway Rye Bread, Dipping Jus
  $15.50
- Smashed White Bean
  White Beans, Feta, Herb Pistou, Pickled Shallot, Focaccia. Please be aware that this sandwich cannot be made without feta.
  $15.00
- Whitney + Broccoli
  Roasted Broccoli, French Sheep's Milk Cheese, Miso + Pumpkin Seed Butter, Griddled Sourdough
  $15.50
Bites
- Crispy Fingerling Potatoes
  Scallion + Lemon Powder, Malt Vinegar Mayo, Fresno Hot Sauce
  $8.00
- Green Salad
  Revol Farms Greens, Sarvecchio Cheese, Tarragon Dressing
  $7.00
Sweets
- Chess Pie
  $11.50
- Pecan Shortbread Sandwich Cookie
  Chocolate-Studded Pecan Shortbread, Chocolate Dulce de Leche Filling
  $4.00
- Malted Chocolate Oreo
  It's a Sandwich, But Better Because It's a Cookie
  $3.00
- Oatmeal Sandwich Cookie
  Honey Marshmallow Filling
  $3.50
- Monster Cookie
  Dark Chocolate, White Chocolate, Coconut, Marshmallows, Corn Nuts, Sea Salt
  $3.50
- All of the Cookies
  One of everything! Malted Chocolate Oreo, Pecan Shortbread, Monster Cookie, Oatmeal Sandwich Cookie
  $13.00
Brunch
- Steak + Eggs
  Grilled Hanger Steak, Sunny Side Up Eggs, Klug, Green Peppercorn Hollandaise, Mixed Greens with Tarragon Vinaigrette
  $22.00
- Bagel Sandwich
  Lox, Preserved Lemon Aioli, Pickled Red Onion, Everything Bagel
  $14.50
- Granola + Yogurt
  Chamomile Greek Yogurt, Fruit Preserves, Erin's Mom's Granola, Marigold Petals
  $7.00
- Two Eggs Any Style
  Slagel Breakfast Sausage Link, Red Corn Grits, Toasted Shokupan, Cultured Butter
  $18.50
- Creamed Eggs Over Toast
  Braised Collard Greens, Pickled Pearl Onion, Lemon, Aleppo Pepper, Aya Sourdough
  $16.00
Bagels
- Bagel Untoasted
  $4.00
- Bagels by the Half-Dozen
  Hand-Rolled Plain + Everything Bagels (3 of Each) Plus Plain + Scallion Cream Cheese
  $17.00
Small Plates
- Fried Goat Cheese Curds
  Blakesville Creamery Curds, Pepper + Honey Relish, Fresh Herbs
  $18.00
- Granola + Yogurt
  Erin's Mom's Maple Granola, Seasonal Fruit Preserves, Chamomile Greek Yogurt, Dried Marigold Petals
  $7.00
Sandwiches
- Fried Egg Sandwich
  Soppressata, Aged Cheddar, Fresno Aioli, Housemade English Muffin
  $12.00
- French Exit
  Underground Meats Salami, Pleasant Ridge Reserve Cheese, Aioli, Mustard, Demi Baguette
  $13.00
- Smashed White Bean
  White Beans, Feta, Herb Pistou, Pickled Shallot, Focaccia. Please be aware that this sandwich cannot be made without feta.
  $15.00
- Smash Burger
  Slagel Farms Beef Patties, Fried Onions, Malt Vinegar Mayo, Pickles, Aged Cheddar, Griddled Shokupan
  $17.00
- Roast Beef Dip
  Roast Beef, Housemade Pickles, Red Cabbage Kraut, Havarti Cheese, Caraway Rye Bread, Dipping Jus
  $15.50
- Whitney + Broccoli
  Roasted Broccoli, French Sheep's Milk Cheese, Miso + Pumpkin Seed Butter, Griddled Sourdough
  $15.50
Bites
- Crispy Fingerling Potatoes
  Scallion + Lemon Powder, Malt Vinegar Mayo, Fresno Hot Sauce
  $8.00
- Green Salad
  Revol Farms Greens, Sarvecchio Cheese, Tarragon Dressing
  $7.00
- Slagel Farms Sausage Links (2pc)
  $5.50
- Homemade English Muffin with Jam + Butter
  Fluffy Goodness with Cultured Butter + Seasonal Jam
  $5.00
Sweets
- Chess Pie
  $11.50
- Pecan Shortbread Sandwich Cookie
  Chocolate-Studded Pecan Shortbread, Chocolate Dulce de Leche Filling
  $4.00
- Malted Chocolate Oreo
  It's a Sandwich, But Better Because It's a Cookie
  $3.00
- Oatmeal Sandwich Cookie
  Honey Marshmallow Filling
  $3.50
- Monster Cookie
  Dark Chocolate, White Chocolate, Coconut, Marshmallows, Corn Nuts, Sea Salt
  $3.50
- All of the Cookies
  One of everything! Malted Chocolate Oreo, Pecan Shortbread, Monster Cookie, Oatmeal Sandwich Cookie
  $13.00
- Dulce De Leche Buttermilk Doughnut
  $4.50
Cheese + Meat Boards
- Portable Cheese Board
  A cheese board to go wherever you do. Three of our current favorite cheeses, accompanied by crostini, jam, honey, mustard, and pickles. Serves 2-3 people. Default packaging is a cardboard to-go box, but we can snazz it up by plating on a sturdy reusable wood board if you'd like.
  $20.00
- A Board for Small Gatherings
  Our tastiest cheeses and meats and all the accompaniments, sized for a 4-6 person gathering. Boards are served with crostini, preserves, cornichons + raw honey and are presented on a sturdy, table-ready, reusable wood board. Cheese and meat board includes three cheeses and two meats, and a cheese-only will have four cheeses. Looking for something larger? Check out the catering menu on our website.
  $45.00
Soft Cheese
Some of our standbys are available here for your snacking pleasure. This is a mere whisper of all of the cheese we have in our case, so please call us if you don't see what you're looking for here.
- Blakesville Fresh Chevre
  Floofy, tangy, salty, fresh goat cheese from Blakesville Creamery in Wisconsin.
  $8.00
- Feta Voras
  Balanced and luscious. A pasteurized sheep and goat's milk cheese from northern Greece. Perfect for cooking!
  $8.50
- Meredith Dairy Marinated Sheep & Goat Milk
  It’s easy to eat an immodest amount of these fluffy, creamy Aussie cheese cubes. Consider yourself warned. Meredith Dairy’s Marinated Sheep & Goat Milk Cheese can slide onto your plate at all hours of the day. Spread on hearty toast for a great morning. Add to your midday sandwich. Toss a few pieces and their herby, garlicky marinating oil with hot pasta for an insta-sauce situation. When you inevitably empty the jar of cheese cubes, turn the remaining oil into dressing by whirling it in a blender with sherry vinegar.
  $14.00
- Julianna
  We all know someone like Julianna: buttery and smooth, nutty and firm, covered in flower petals and herbs. Or we wish we did, at least. This goat milk round from Capriole Farms is just as pretty as it is tasty. Pasteurized goat milk from Indiana.
  $10.50
- Omorro
  A soft-ish torta-style cheese from the Azores. Buttery and pleasantly tangy. Pasteurized cow milk from Portugal.
  $7.50
- Kunik Button
  If you've never had a cheese make you swoon, be prepared for that to change. This blend of farmstead goat milk and Jersey cow cream is at once delicate and sumptuous, bright and buttery, and just really dang good. 9 ounce piece. Pasteurized cow and goat milk from Nettle Meadow Farms in New York.
  $12.50
- Sofia
  A lightly-aged brick with veins of vegetable ash from Capriole Farms. Soft, silky, and lemon meringue-like. Goat milk from Capriole Farms in Indiana.
  $9.75
- Leonora
  This bright, lemony, brick-shaped babe is lush and balanced. Its soft-ripened, pasteurized goat milk is sourced from two separate farms in the region (always Murciana goats). We love.
  $6.50
- Robiola Bosina
  Silky, custardy, earthy Piedmontese goodness. Cow and sheep milk from Italy. 9 ounce piece.
  $7.50
- La Tur
  Gooey, charming blend of cow, goat, and sheep milk. It's luscious, full, and sweet and would make just as good a dessert as it would cheese board centerpiece. 8oz piece. Pasteurized milk.
  $15.00
- Camembert Dell' 3 Latti
  $7.00
- Willoughby
  A succulent, gooey washed-rind cheese with savory aromas and milky, herbal, lightly floral flavors within. Cow's milk from Cellars at Jasper Hill in Vermont. 8 ounce wheel.
  $8.50
- Pipers Pyramid
  Piper’s Pyramid is a literal smoke show: there’s a layer of smoked paprika that runs throughout the cheese and around the exterior. Lovely on its own, but also makes a primo partner for cured meat. Goat milk cheese from Indiana. 10oz pyramid.
  $10.00
Firm + Firm-ish Cheese
Some of our standbys are available here for your snacking pleasure. This is a mere whisper of all of the cheese we have in our case, so please call us if you don't see what you're looking for here.
- Romao
  Herbaceous and nearly pine-y from the rosemary that covers this sheep’s milk cheese while it ages for 8 months. Pasteurized sheep’s milk cheese from Spain.
  $6.50
- Pata Cabra
  Pata Cabra is a washed-rind log with a nice balance of fruitiness and tangy acidity. Think lemon and creme fraiche, with a delightfully crumbly texture. Pasteurized goat's milk from Spain.
  $8.25
- Rispens Sheep Gouda
  All hail Jacob Rispens, and while you're at it give his kids a nod for asking their dad to switch from cow's milk to sheep's milk- ultimately switching up the Dutch tradition and giving cheese lovers this knockout. Complex, custardy, sharp, dreamy. Delicious alongside wine, beer, cider, or your own happy tears once you take your first bite.
  $8.50
- Malvarosa
  Malvarosa is a relative newcomer to the scene. Its production began as a way to save a nearly-extinct breed of sheep, but now its raison d'etre is simply deliciousness. It's firm, buttery, rich, and sweet, with a nearly butterscotch-like finish. The unique shape comes from aging in a knotted cheesecloth. Pasteurized sheep's milk from Spain.
  $5.50
- Challerhocker
  Sure, you could top your French onion soup with Challerhocker. But this Swiss cow's milk morsel basically IS French onion soup in cheese form - savory, brothy, deep, complex, and warming. Raw cow's milk from Switzerland.
  $10.00
- Reading Raclette
  Reading Raclette is a semi-firm wheel of cows' milk cheese that is washed with saltwater brine as it matures. Texture is soft and supple, with heady flavors that leant toward fruity and milky notes. This baby is a great melter and an ideal cheese for fondue, raclette, mac and cheese, other melty cheese dishes, and snacking, of course. Raw cow's milk from Vermont.
  $5.75
- Cabot Clothbound Cheddar
  A friendly but complex aged cheddar with crumbly texture, savory caramel flavors, and a bright sweetness at the finish. Cow's milk from Cellars at Jasper Hill in Vermont.
  $8.25
- Mastorazio
  A fine example of Italian pecorino from the folks at Casa Madaio in Salerno, Italy. It ages for a minimum of 12 months in caves the family has been using to age cheese in for four generations. Firm and crumbly with notes of woody herbs and hazelnuts. Raw sheep milk from Italy.
  $7.50
- Saint Germain
  Tomme-style with tender texture and a delicate, herbaceous natural rind. Lightly aged goat milk from Blakesville Creamery in Wisconsin.
  $8.75
- Manchego 1605
  This is not your average Manchego. This is a Manchego named for the year Miguel Cervantes wrote Don Quixote, which was the first written reference to the cheese. A Manchego made from the milk of animals born to the gentle sounds of mariachi music. The tunes allegedly keep the lambs happy and calm, which leads to tastier milk. Like most Manchegos, 1605 will be earthy and savory, with toothsome texture. But there will also be heavenly notes of nutmeg and caramel, candied almonds and a hint of hay with a long, lingering finish. Do we owe it to the mariachi? We’re going to say yes. Raw milk from Spain.
  $10.25
- Garrotxa
  Grassy, herbaceous, nutty, and semi-firm. Kind of like taking a nap in the grass with a goat. Pasteurized goat milk from Spain.
  $8.00
- Tarentaise
  A best-in-show awarded cheese produced by Spring Brook Farm.
  $7.75
- Pantaleo
  Slightly sweet with a touch of lemony brightness, this mellow Sardinian goat’s milk cheese is great on its own and is a total mic drop with a bit of our honey. Pasteurized goat milk from Italy.
  $6.50
- La Dama Sagrada
  A "sacred dame" named for Fátima, head cheesemaker at the Spanish dairy cooperative that makes this beaut. La Dama is full-bodied and sweet, with pleasant grassiness and complex texture. Raw goat's milk from Spain.
  $7.25
- Wilde Weide Gouda
  A younger gouda made on a verdant island in the Netherlands that houses only cows, the cheesemakers and the cheese. Floral, ripe, with bourbon notes and unmatched creaminess. Raw cow milk from Holland.
  $7.75
- Montgomery's Cheddar
  Montgomery’s is a benchmark English farmstead cheddar, an ultra-traditional version of a style of cheese that’s ubiquitous enough that it can seem un-special. But there’s a reason cheddar hit the big time, and going back to the source code with Montgomery’s (Monty’s if you’re a true cheese nerd) can help you understand. Third-generation cheesemaker Jamie Montgomery uses the same starter cultures as his mother before him and his grandfather before her. The cultures are difficult to handle and can be unpredictable in their results, but they’re credited with producing an incredible symphony of flavors: rich, meaty and robust with sweet, nearly caramelized fruit notes. Nothing worth doing is easy, right? Raw cow's milk from the UK.
  $9.75
- Dalmatinac
  You haven't tried Dalmatinac yet? Let's change that. Fun to say (dahl-mah-TEE-nahts), even more fun to eat. This Croatian blend is 90% cow's milk, 10% sheep's milk. Toasty, herbal, buttery, nicely salted --a true hero on the cheese board.
  $5.50
Funk + Blues
Some of our standbys are available here for your snacking pleasure. This is a mere whisper of all of the cheese we have in our case, so please call us if you don't see what you're looking for here.
- Roquefort
  Creamy, salty, spicy blue cheese that you should most definitely slather with That Honey We Put On Our Cheese Boards. Pasteurized sheep milk from France.
  $6.25
Cured Meats + Other Treats
- Black Garlic Salami
  Earthy, Savory Salami Made with Mushroom + Black garlic. 2oz Piece.
  $7.50
- Calabrian Salami
  The Calabrian Salami is Meat with Gentle Heat. It's Made with WI-Grown Calabrian Peppers + Red Wine. 2oz Piece.
  $7.50
- Chicken Liver Mousse
  A Jar of Decadence + Deliciousness. 4oz Portion.
  $8.00
- Finocchiona
  Pork Salami with Bright Fennel Flavors, Black Pepper + White Wine. 2oz Piece.
  $7.50
- Gin Rummy
  German-Style Salami with Rum + Coriander. 6oz Piece.
  $9.50
- Goat Salami
  $8.00
- Nduja
  Calabrian-Style Spreadable Salami with Ancho Chili + Ghost Pepper. 3oz Piece.
  $7.00
- Piri Piri Salami
  $9.50
- Saucisson Sec
  Classic French-style Salami with Garlic + Black Pepper. 2oz Piece.
  $7.50
- Spanish-Style Chorizo
  Mildly Spicy Spanish-Style Chorizo with Smoky Paprika + Cayenne Pepper. 2oz Piece.
  $7.50
- Tuscan Salami
  Classic Italian-Style Salami with Black Pepper, Fennel + Red Wine. 6oz Piece.
  $9.50
- Sliced Black Garlic Salami
  3.2 oz portion.
  $8.00
- Sliced Bresaola - Brooklyn Cured
  Cured dried beef by Brooklyn Cured. 3.2 oz portion.
  $9.00
- Sliced Coppa - Il Porcelino
  Dry-cured Berkshire pork shoulder based on a classic Italian recipe. Produced by Il Porcelino in Colorado. 3.2 oz portion.
  $9.50
- Sliced Lomo Serrano
  Spanish cured pork loin rubbed with garlic and pimentón. 3.2 ounce portion. Produced in Castilla y León.
  $8.00
- Sliced Soppressata
  $7.00
- Sliced Speck Alto Adige
  Traditional lightly smoked and cured ham style from the mountains of northern Italy. Rubbed with a blend of spices including bay and juniper, it’s then cold-smoked in the mountain air, retaining flavors of pine and tobacco. 3.2 oz portion, pork from Italy.
  $5.00
Sparkling
- Nestarec 'Danger' (2023)
  $44.00
- Pierre Paillard 'Les Terre Roses XIX' Bouzy Grand Cru 750ml NV
  $98.00
White
- Vallee Moray Cailloutis (2020)
  $57.00
- Julien Cruchandeau Hautes Cotes de Nuits Blanc (2022)
  $50.00
- Poderi Sanguineto 'Bianco Toscano' (2021)
  $22.00
- Cantine Barbera 'Tivitti' Menfi Inzolia (2022)
  $22.00
Skin Contact + Orange
- Vino del Poggio 'Vino Bianco' Sauvignon (2022)
  $46.00
Pink
- Guiberteau Saumur Rose (2023)
  $33.00
- Cantina Cenci 'Prima Quercia' Rosato (2022)
  $35.00
Red
- Baptiste Cousin 'Dynamitage' (2023)
  $50.00
- Pedro Parra y Familia 'Hub' (2021)
  $45.00
The REALLY Good Sh*t (AKA Our Cellar)
A selection from our “REALLY Good Sh*t” book. If you're looking for unicorns, you’ll find them here.
- Clos Rougeard 'Les Poyeaux' (2015)
  Cabernet Franc -- Loire, FR
  $240.00
- Clos Rougeard 'Les Poyeaux' (2016)
  Cabernet Franc -- Loire, FR
  $240.00
- Clos Rougeard 'Les Poyeaux' (2017)
  Cabernet Franc -- Loire FR
  $230.00
- Clos Rougeard Saumur-Champigny Rouge (2015)
  Cabernet Franc -- Loire FR
  $170.00
- Clos Rougeard Saumur-Champigny Rouge (2017)
  Cabernet Franc -- Loire FR
  $185.00
- Hiyu Wine Farm 'Moon Dog Perennial' (2015)
  Pinot Noir, Pinot Gris -- Columbia River Gorge, OR
  $305.00
- Champagne Vincent Laval Cumieres Rose (2020)
  Pinot Noir, Pinot Meunier -- Champagne, FR
  $289.00
- Domaine de La Cote 'Memorius' Pinot Noir (2021)
  Pinot Noir -- Santa Rita Hills, CA
  $111.00
- Domaine Hubert Lignier, ‘La Rioffe’ Morey St. Denis 1er Cru Bourgone AOC
  Pinot Noir -- Burgundy, FR
  $266.00
- Chateau Rayas Châteauneuf-du-Pape Reserve (2008)
  Grenache -- Rhone, FR
  $800.00
- Vignobles Levet, ‘La Chavaroche’ Côte-Rôtíe AOC (2020)
  Syrah -- Rhone, FR
  $111.00
- Montevertine, ‘Le Pergole Torte’ (2019)
  Sangiovese -- Tuscany, IT
  $248.00
- Keller Rieslaner Auslese 375ml (2021)
  Riesling -- Rheinhessen, DE
  $49.00
- Joh. Jos. Prüm ‘Graacher Himmelreich’ Auslese (2021)
  Riesling -- Mosel, DE
  $82.00
- Clos Saron Camptonville Folly Pinot Noir (2018)
  Pinot Noir -- Sierra Foothills, CA
  $73.00
- Domaine Chantereves ‘Les Monts de Fussey’ Hautes Côtes de Beaune AOC (2021)
  Chardonnay -- Burgundy, FR
  $68.00
- Jean-Yves Peron 'Le Pas de l'Ours' Rouge (2019)
  Mondeuse -- Savoie, FR
  $82.00
- Brandini Barolo Annuziata (2017)
  Nebbiolo -- Piedmont, IT
  $158.00
- 'Colete' White Blend (2020)
  50% Sauvignon Blanc and 50% Semillon -- Napa Valley, CA
  $54.00
- Caves de Jean Bourdy Galant des Abesses (NV)
  Chardonnay, Brandy -- Jura, FR
  $91.00
- Sylvain Pataille Chardonnay Rose (2021)
  Chardonnay Rose -- Burgundy, FR
  $114.00
- Cruse Wine Co Brut Tradition (NV)
  Chardonnay, Pinot Noir -- Petaluma, CA
  $58.00
- Keller 'Dalsheim Hubacker GG' Riesling (2020)
  Riesling -- Rheinhessen, DE
  $365.00
- Guiberteau 'Clos des Guichaux' (2021)
  Chenin Blanc -- Loire, FR
  $65.00
- Paradigm Estate Cabernet Sauvignon (2019)
  Cabernet -- Napa Valley, CA
  $116.00
- Emidio Pepe Montepulciano d'Abruzzo (2015)
  Montepulciano -- Abruzzo, IT
  $179.00
- Paolo Bea 'Arboreus' (2015)
  Trebbiano Spoletino -- Umbria, IT
  $95.00
- Dard & Ribo 'St Joseph' Rouge (2022) - Signed Bottle!
  Syrah -- Rhone, FR
  $94.00
- Herve Souhaut 'St Epine' (2022)
  Syrah -- Rhone, FR
  $90.00
- Château de Béru 'Athenais' Amphore Bourgogne Côtes d’Auxerre (2020)
  Pinot Noir -- Burgundy, FR
  $109.00
- Baraldo Toscana Rosso Cru Caccialupi (2020)
  Sangiovese -- Tuscany, IT
  $95.00
- Closerie Saint Roc ‘Les Noyers’ VDF (2020)
  Merlot, Cabernet Franc, Cabernet Sauvignon -- Bordeaux, FR
  $130.00
- Desparada 'Columba' (2021)
  Sangiovese, Teroldego -- Santa Barbara County, CA
  $73.00
- Desparada 'Axis' Petit Verdot (2021)
  Petit Verdot -- Central Coast, CA
  $85.00
- Bereche 'Les Montees' Coteaux Champenois Rouge (2022)
  Pinot Noir--Champagne, FR
  $139.00
- Marie Courtin 'Le Blanc de Tremble' (2019)
  Pinot Noir -- Champagne, FR
  $91.00
- Champagne Lelarge-Pugeot 'Cote des Glaises' (2020)
  Chardonnay -- Champagne, FR
  $101.00
- Martin Woods Pearlstad Vineyard (2022)
  Chardonnay -- Willamette Valley, OR
  $70.00
- Herve Souhaut Clos des Cessieux (2022)
  Syrah -- Rhone FR
  $82.00
- Arnot-Roberts 'Que Syrah Vineyard' Syrah (2022)
  Syrah -- Healdsburg CA
  $95.00
BIG!!! Bottles
- Raventos 'De Nit' Riserva Rosado 1.5L (2020)
  $70.00
- Willi Schaefer Graa Himm Riesling Kabinett MAG 1.5L (2022)
  $204.00
- Eva Fricke 'Mellifluous' 1.5L (2018)
  $180.00
- Bruno Duchene 'l'Anodine' MAG 1.5L (2022)
  $196.00
- Maxine Magnon 'Rozeta' 1.5L (2018)
  $101.00
- Envinate 'Albahra' MAG 1.5L (2023)
  $78.00
- Gut Oggau 'Atanasius' MAG 1.5L (2022)
  $104.00
Little!!! Cans + Bottles
- Djuce Fizzy (2022) 187ml
  $7.00
Snacks 'n Spreads
- Agrumato Blood Orange Olive Oil
  Agrumato Blood Orange Olive Oil captures the true essence of Sicilian blood oranges through its unique process of crushing whole blood oranges together with olives, sealing in the essential oils of the zest. The resulting extra virgin olive oil is bursting with fresh, authentic blood orange flavor. Drizzle it over cheeses like Shabby Shoe or use it to top a scoop of vanilla gelato finished with a sprinkle of flaky salt.
  $29.00
- Creamed Trout
  Lake trout spread with lemon and dill
  $14.00
- Crunch Party
  Candied almonds, cashews, pecans, rosemary, Aleppo pepper, crispy favas, and big corn nuts are having a party and you're invited. 7 ounce bag.
  $9.00
- Housemade Cultured Butter
  Better butter made by us with local cream
  $8.00
- Marcona Almonds
  Toasted, salted, and tossed with olive oil. 4 ounce tub.
  $8.00
- Pimento Cheese
  Spread it on your crackers, bread, and sandwiches. Dunk your veggies in it. There are a lot of ways to win with this one.
  $8.50
- Regalis Black Truffle Microwave Popcorn
  Few things are more ridiculous and fun than popping yourself a bag of popcorn covered in BLACK TRUFFLE. It's the ultimate high-low eating experience. Each box contains three bags.
  $14.00
- Torres Truffle Potato Chips
  $5.00
- Woodblock Chocolate Bars
- Zapp's Potato Chips: Regular
  Crunchy. Classic.
  $3.00
- Zapp's Potato Chips: Voodoo
  Like a really good salt + vinegar chip, but with a Creole twist
  $3.00
- Chocolate Sardines | Cluizel
  These milk chocolates heard that sardines are trending and showed up as school of six fish-shaped delights. Made by family-owned French chocolatiers Cluizel.
  $19.00
Fish in Tins
- Boquerones | Bahia de la Concha
  Plump lil Spanish white anchovies in white wine vinegar. Drape over bread and butter and get yourself to snack heaven.
  $17.00
- Grilled Salmon | Fangst
  $16.00
- Mussels in Escabeche | La Brujula
  $17.00
- Piquillo Peppers + Sweet Combo | Porto-Muinos
  $14.00
- Razor Clams + Sea Spaghetti | Porto-Muinos
  $20.00
- Sardines | La Brujula
  $12.00
- Smoked Sardines | Jose Gourmet
  $12.00
- Smoked Small Mackerel | Jose Gourmet
  $12.00
- Smoked Trout Fillets | Minnow
  $14.00
- Smoked Whitefish | Great Lakes Tinned Fish
  $18.00
- White Tuna Loin | La Brujula
  $15.00
- Sardines with Lemon | Regalis
  $15.00
- Smoked Spiny Oysters | Regalis
  $28.00
Olives & Pickles
- Basque Olive Mix
  A medley of green and black olives with Provencal herbs and bits of red pepper
  $8.50
- Castelvetrano Olives Retail
  Bright green, buttery, rich, and delectable
  $6.50
- Cucumber Pickles with Coriander + Dill | All Together Now
  A classic spear everyone can get behind. Made right here.
  $5.00
- Pickled Carrots with Star Anise + Bay Leaf | All Together Now
  Crunchy, snacky, star anise and bay leaf-spiked carrot sticks. Made right here.
  $6.00
- Pickled Golden Beets with Chile de Arbol | All Together Now
  Pure pickled gold(en beets) with a kick. Made right here.
  $7.00
- Cornichons
  Tiny lil pickles
  $5.00
- Piparra Peppers | Matiz
  $8.00
Grocery
- Agrumato Blood Orange Olive Oil
  Agrumato Blood Orange Olive Oil captures the true essence of Sicilian blood oranges through its unique process of crushing whole blood oranges together with olives, sealing in the essential oils of the zest. The resulting extra virgin olive oil is bursting with fresh, authentic blood orange flavor. Drizzle it over cheeses like Shabby Shoe or use it to top a scoop of vanilla gelato finished with a sprinkle of flaky salt.
  $29.00
- Armato Olive Oil "Sci-appa"
  This cold-pressed Ligurian olive oil is delicate and fruity, with buttery, smooth texture. 500ml bottle.
  $31.00
- Armato Semi-Dried Tomatoes in Olive Oil
  Ripe, sweet cherry tomatoes harvested at the height of Ligurian summer, gently dried and packed in Armato's stellar olive oil. Delicious with literally everything, but especially with cheese and cured meat.
  $24.00
- Banyuls Vinegar | La Cave de l'Abbe Rous
  $22.00
- Blackberry Thyme Jam - Large | All Together Now
  Blackberries and thyme in spreadable deliciousness form. A pleasing yin and yang of fruit and herbs. Made right here. 6oz jar.
  $9.00
- Blackberry Thyme Jam - Small | All Together Now
  Blackberries and thyme in spreadable deliciousness form. A pleasing yin and yang of fruit and herbs. Made right here - 4oz jar. Perfectly portable for snacks on the go!
  $7.50
- Blueberry Lemongrass Jam - Large | All Together Now
  Blueberries, lemongrass, and delight in a jar. Made right here. 6oz jar.
  $9.00
- Blueberry Lemongrass Jam - Small | All Together Now
  Blueberries, lemongrass, and delight in a jar. Made right here - 4oz jar. Perfect for picnicking.
  $7.50
- Caplansky's Horseradish Mustard
  A mustard with a jolt of kicky horseradish for when you want to be EXTRA. Awesome with cured meats and all other places you need some pizzaz.
  $10.50
- Caplansky's Old Fashioned Mustard
  A stone-ground, lively, classic mustard that's perfect on sandwiches and charcuterie boards. It comes from Caplansky's Deli in Toronto, folks who know a thing or two about condiments. 8 ounce jar.
  $10.50
- Castello Conti Red Wine Vinegar
  Bright, balanced, fruit-forward red wine vinegar from venerable Piedmont winemaker Castello Conti. It's made from old estate grape vines and aged slowly over two years. Unfiltered, intense and delightful. 250ml bottle.
  $27.00
- Concord Grape Jam - Large | All Together Now
  Concord grapes (aka the grape-iest of the grapes) from Mick Klug cooked down with a touch of Vietnamese cinnamon. Floral, bright, and classic. Made right here. 6oz jar.
  $10.00
- Concord Grape Jam - Small | All Together Now
  Concord grapes (aka the grape-iest of the grapes) from Mick Klug cooked down with a touch of Vietnamese cinnamon. Floral, bright, and classic. Made right here - 4oz jar. Perfect for picnics!
  $8.00
- Cucumber Pickles with Coriander + Dill | All Together Now
  A classic spear everyone can get behind. Made right here.
  $5.00
- Divina Calabrian Peppers in Oil
  $9.50
- Fleur de Sel | M. Gilles Hervy
  $16.00
- Mostarda Mediterranea | Dario Cecchini
  Sweet, delicately spicy red pepper jelly from famed Tuscan butcher Dario Cecchini. Eat this on soft cheese (Robiola Bosina, perhaps?), stirred into vinaigrette, slathered on roasted meats, layer it into sandwiches. There's no bad way to do it. 220g jar.
  $24.00
- Pear Mostarda | Casa Forcello
  $14.00
- Persimmon Star Anise Jam - Large | All Together Now
  $10.00
- Persimmon Star Anise Jam - Small | All Together Now
  $8.00
- Pickled Carrots with Star Anise + Bay Leaf | All Together Now
  Crunchy, snacky, star anise and bay leaf-spiked carrot sticks. Made right here.
  $6.00
- Pickled Golden Beets with Chile de Arbol | All Together Now
  Pure pickled gold(en beets) with a kick. Made right here.
  $7.00
- Pink Salt Kitchens Nam Prik Pao
  Thai roasted chili jam from local maker Pink Salt Kitchens that checks all the boxes: umami, smoky, tangy, sweet, and spicy. It's amazing with soft cheese, and in dressings, stir fries, and soups. 6 ounce jar. * Contains shellfish *
  $17.00
- Regalis Black Truffle Microwave Popcorn
  Few things are more ridiculous and fun than popping yourself a bag of popcorn covered in BLACK TRUFFLE. It's the ultimate high-low eating experience. Each box contains three bags.
  $14.00
- Strawberry Lemon Peel Jam - Large | All Together Now
  Local strawberries and a whisper of citrus. Makes friends easily, especially with goat cheese and/or a nice biscuit. Made right here. 6oz jar.
  $9.00
- Strawberry Lemon Peel Jam - Small | All Together Now
  Local strawberries and a whisper of citrus. Makes friends easily, especially with goat cheese and/or a nice biscuit. Made right here. 4oz jar - Perfect for packing on a picnic to the park.
  $7.50
- That Honey You Had on Your Cheese Board - Large
  Raw honey that spreads like frosting and improves LITERALLY EVERYTHING IT TOUCHES from Trillium Woods Apiary in Sheboygan Falls, WI. 6oz jar.
  $13.00
- Zab's Hot Honey
  $18.00
- Zab's Original Hot Sauce
  $8.00
- Crab Apple Mostarda | Casa Forcello
  $14.00
- Quicos
  Big crunchy corn nuts. 4 ounce bag.
  $4.00
- Crispy Favas
  Crispy, snacky fried fava beans. 4 ounce bag.
  $4.00
- Erin's Mom's Granola
  The best granola around, made by ATN owner Erin's mom. It's a seedy, crunchy blend made with maple syrup, olive oil, sea salt.
  $12.00
- Ruby Coffee Roasters "Breakfast of Champions"
  A bag o' beans roasted by our pals at Ruby Coffee Roasters in Nelsonville, WI just for us. The "Breakfast of Champions" blend is rich, vibrant, and chocolatey.
  $18.00
- Chocolate Sardines | Cluizel
  These milk chocolates heard that sardines are trending and showed up as school of six fish-shaped delights. Made by family-owned French chocolatiers Cluizel.
  $19.00
- Sour Blackberry Fish | BonBon NYC
  $8.00
- Sour Elderflower Fish | BonBon NYC
  $8.00
- Sour Peach Fish | Bonbon NYC
  $8.00
- Sweet Wild Strawberry Fish | Bonbon NYC
  $8.00
- Pear Rosemary Compote | Casa Forcello
  $14.00
GIFTING
- All Together Now At Home
  This gift kit is a lighthearted, delicious collection of homemade and signature goods that brings the best of ATN to your recipient. Or to you. No judgement here. SMALL KIT includes two artisan cheeses, a piece of Saucisson Sec from Underground Meats, a jar of That Honey We Put on Our Cheese Boards, ATN's seasonal preserves, Homemade Seedy Oat Crackers, Crunch Party, and two Malted Chocolate Oreo cookies. LARGE KIT includes three artisan cheeses, Saucisson Sec and Wisco Old Fashioned salamis from Underground Meats, a jar of That Honey We Put on Our Cheese Boards, ATN's seasonal preserves, Homemade Seedy Oat Crackers, Mitica Olive Oil Taralli Crackers, Crunch Party, and three Malted Chocolate Oreo cookies, and a trio of Mast chocolate bars.
  $75.00
- Cocktail Napkins | The Weaving Mill
  Locally-loomed checked napkins from The Weaving Mill. Excellent for picnics or giving your cheese and bread a rest during cocktail hour. This set of two is 100% cotton, machine-washable, and measures 7.5” x 7.5” each. About The Weaving Mill: The Weaving Mill is an artist-run industrial weaving studio in Chicago. They make projects of their own, textile and otherwise, that respond to the practice of running a small industrial mill, and also collaborate with other artists and designers. Working with people of diverse textile experience, TWM aims to fill the space between hand and industrially made and bring the mechanics of textile production into wider view.
  $27.00
Bread + Crackers
- Aya Baguette
  A real French guy told us these baguettes from Aya Bakery are the best in the city so it must be true
  $3.50
- Olive Oil & Oregano Rusks | Yia Yia & Friends
  We call them little toasted pieces of bread, the Europeans call them rusks. What a wild world. These ones get a Greek olive oil and oregano treatment and would be delightful underneath an Alpine cheese.
  $8.50
- Carrot Breadsticks | Yiayia & Friends
  Crunchy, mildly carrot-y, and incredibly snackable. These olive oil and carrot breadsticks are fit for hungry bunnies and humans alike. Dunk into dips and soft cheeses or nibble on 'em just plain. We're not here to tell you how to live.
  $8.50
- Miller's Damsel Buttermilk Crackers
  $9.50
- Fine Cheese Co. Gluten-Free Olive Oil Crackers
  $9.00
- Ines Rosales Sweet Olive Oil Tortas
  Hot tip: these are SO good with cheese. Thin, crispy, JUST this side of sweet... A dream. Truly.
  $9.00
- Mitica Pane di Musica
  A cracker so thin you have to see it to believe it! 'Pane di Musica' is a classic Sardinian semolina and olive oil flatbread named for the sheets of parchment on which music was once transcribed. Delicate, yes, but also rich and flavorful. It's a great sort of dissonance that begs for soft cheese.
  $9.00
- Mitica Toketti Olive Oil & Semolina Flatbread
  $8.00
- Fine Cheese Co. Olive Oil Crackers
  $7.00
- Rustic Bakery Rosemary Flatbread Crackers
  $9.00
- All Together Now Seedy Oat Crackers
  Homemade honey-whole wheat rounds studded with sesame, fennel, chia + caraway seeds, urfa pepper, and sea salt.
  $8.00
- Mitica Classic Taralli
  Crunchy lil wreath-shaped olive oil crackers. Dangerously snackable.
  $5.00
- Mitica Fennel Taralli
  Fennel-flecked olive oil crackers that hail from Southern Italy and want to be friends with your cheese
  $5.00
Spirits
- Agua Magica Mezcal
  $80.00
- Buelan 'Las Canciones No. 1' Manzanilla 375ml
  $23.00
- C Cassis Blackcurrant Liqueur
  $27.00
- Casa Mandel Boullosa 'Carcavelos' (1998)
  $55.00
- Forthave 'Blue' Gin
  An aromatic, eminently sippable gin from the Forthave folks. Juicy, herbaceous, and round on the palate. This gin is the reason we broke our own rule of only offering "wine-adjacent" spirits. Drink over ice or mix for a superlative cocktail.
  $43.00
- Forthave 'Four' 375ml
  $39.00
- Forthave 'Marseille' Amaro 750ml
  $65.00
- Forthave 'Mithradates' 750ml
  $65.00
- Forthave 'Red' Apertivo 375ml SMALL
  $26.00
- Forthave 'Red' Apertivo 750ml
  $43.00
- Forthave 'Three' Amer 375ml
  $34.00
- Forthave 'Yellow' Genepi
  $43.00
- Forthave Black 'Nocino' 375ml
  $36.00
- Forthave Brown 'Coffee' 750ml
  $60.00
- Forthave ‘Marseille’ Amaro 375ml
  $34.00
- Green Chartreuse
  $105.00
- Hoste 'Perfect Manhattan'
  $85.00
- Hoste 'The Martini'
  $70.00
- La Venenosa 'Sierra del Tigre de Jalisco'
  $145.00
- Maxico Mistico 'Llevame Lejos' Ginger Licor
  $33.00
- Neversink Spirits Apple Aperitif
  $58.00
- Rittenhouse Rye 100
  $33.00
- Sweet Gwendoline Gin
  $53.00
- Yellow Chartreuse
  $105.00
- The Han 'Won Mae' Plum Liqueur 375ml
  $20.00
- Yangchon Yangchon Chungju 500ml
  $37.00
- Green Key Herbal Elixir
  $57.00
Beer Singles
- 18th Street 'Candi Crushable' Pale Ale | 16oz Can
  $8.00
- 3 Fonteinen 'Druif Muscaris' 750ml
  $49.00
- 3 Fonteinen 'Oude Geuze' 2019 VINTAGE 375ml
  $24.00
- Art History 'Bauhaus' German Pilsner | 16oz Can
  $8.00
- Art History 'Good Morning Munich' Bavarian Helles Lager | 16oz Can
  $8.00
- Dutchbag 'Knitwit' Witbier | 16oz Can
  $8.00
- Dutchbag 'Pack of Goofs' Patersbier | 16oz Can
  $8.00
- Hopewell 'Pils' Pilsner | 16oz Can
  $7.00
- Hopewell 'Ride or Die' APA | 16oz Can
  $7.00
- Middlebrow 'Neighborhood' | 12oz Can
  $7.00
- Moody Tongue 'Aperitif Pilner' | 12oz Bottle
  $5.00
- Perennial Artisan Ales 'Saison de Lis' | 16oz Can
  $8.00
- Middlebrow 'Yard Work' Kolsch | 12oz Can
  $6.00
- Is/Was 'Le Bizon' | 500ml Bottle
  $17.00
- Is/Was 'Spandrel' (2025) | 500ml Bottle
  $17.00
Cider
- Cyril Zangs 'Ciderman' NV (330ml)
  $13.00
- Aval Cidre Blanc | 12oz Can
  $6.00
- Shacksbury 'Sweater Weather' Spiced Cider | 12oz Can
  $4.00
Seltzer, Cocktails + Otherwise
- Marz Malort Spritz
  $7.00
- Hopewell 'Choom Lite' Seltzer with 3mg Hemp-Derived THC | 8oz Can
  $10.00
- Flyer's 'Ol' Fashioned' Sparkling Beverage with 5mg Hemp-Derived THC | 355ml Can
  $10.00
- HOSTE | Mezcal Negroni
  HOSTE is a team of world-class bartenders making cocktails just like the ones they'd pour for you at their bars, but bottled for your enjoyment at home. The Mezcal Negroni, an homage to the bold flavors and rich cultural traditions of Oaxaca, is the latest addition to their lineup. It showcases Paquera’s Artisanal Ensamble Mezcal alongside bitters inspired by Los Pacos Oaxaca’s world-renowned mole, a custom sweet vermouth blend by Little City Vermouth and our own tamarind liqueur. Includes an orange citrus zest atomizer for garnish. Serves 10 drinks.
  $82.00
- Hana Makgeolli 'Silkysonic' 236ml Can
  $8.00
Beer 4-Packs
- 18th Street 'Candi Crushable' Pale Ale | 4-pack
  $16.00
- 2nd Shift Brewing 'Brewligans' NEIPA | 4-pack
  $17.00
- 2nd Shift Brewing 'Katy' | 4-pack
  $16.00
- 2nd Shift Brewing 'Technical Ecstasy' | 4-pack
  $12.00
- Art History 'Bauhaus' German Pilsner | 4-pack
  $16.00
- Art History 'Dithering Bitter' ESB | 4-pack
  $16.00
- Art History 'Lincoln Highway' APA | 4-pack
  $16.00
- Art History ‘Good Morning Munich’ Bavarian Helles Lager | 4-pack
  $16.00
- Dutchbag 'Knitwit' Witbier | Four Pack
  $16.00
- Dutchbag 'Pack of Goofs' Patersbier | 4-pack
  $16.00
- Dutchbag Gleep Glop | 4 Pack
  $16.00
- Duvel '666' | 4-pack
  $20.00
- Hopewell 'Pils' Pilsner | 4-pack
  $14.00
- Hopewell 'Ride or Die' APA | 4-pack
  $14.00
- Marz 'Singing to Plants' NE IPA | 4-pack
  $19.00
- Middlebrow 'Neighborhood' Farmhouse | 4-pack
  $14.00
- Middlebrow 'Yard Work' Kolsch | 4-pack
  $12.00
- Moody Tongue 'Aperitif Pilsner' | 4-pack
  $10.00
- Perennial Artisan Ales 'Saison de Lis' Saison | 4-pack
  $16.00
- Reissdorf Kolsch | 4-pack
  Kolsch / 4.8% ABV / 16oz / Germany
  $18.00
- Art History ‘Gravitace’ Czech Pale Lager | 4-pack
  $16.00
- Marz x Babes 'BFF Beer' Hibiscus IPA | 4-pack
  $16.00
Not Booze
- A'Siciliana Aranciata
  $3.00
- A'Siciliana Limonata
  $3.00
- Agua di Piedra | 12oz bottle
  $3.00
- Agua di Piedra | 22oz bottle
  $6.00
- Cold Coffee
  Cold coffee brewed from Ruby Coffee Roasters beans
  $4.00
- Freeman House 'Chai Baby'
  Vegan + delicious
  $8.00
- Ghia 'Le Spritz' Original
  Bold, bitter, and herbaceous, just like your favorite aperitivo. Think Sprite with extra ginger. No booze here, though!
  $6.50
- Hot Teas from Spirit
  Choice of Turmeric Tonic (Herbal Tea, Caffeine-Free), Breakfast Blend (Black Tea, Caffeinated), or Emerald Spring (Green Tea, Caffeinated)
  $3.50
- Martinelli's Apple Juice
  $4.00
- Marz Yerba Mate
  $4.00
- Metric Classic Cold Brew
  $5.50
- RMBR 'Rose Petal Berry' Kombucha
  $5.00
- Sprecher Root Beer
  For the kid in you. Or your actual kid.
  $3.00
- St Agrestis Falso Amaro
  $6.50
- St Agrestis Phony Mezcal Negroni
  $6.50
- Visitor Non Alcoholic Beer
  $6.00
- Odd Bird 'GSM' Non-Alcoholic Wine
  $29.00
- Aplos 'Chili Margarita'
  $7.00
- Aplos 'Ume Spritz'
  $7.00
- Aplos 'Kola Fashioned'
  $7.00
- Marz CBD Elixir: Citrus Party
  Citrus Party is a blend of orange, lemon, grapefruit and lime with a light dry hopping of Citra hops. No alcohol, yes CBD.
  $5.00
- Aplos 'Calme' Functional Non-Alcoholic Spirit
  $49.00
- Copenhagen Sparkling Tea 'Bla' (Jasmine)
  $33.00
- Copenhagen Sparkling Tea 'Lysergron' (Green Tea)
  $33.00
Merch
- ATN Hat
  It goes on your head! It's also very comfy and a smart shade of blue. Back of cap has a small All Together Now stitched near the closure.
  $28.00
- Wine Key
  This thing is for removing barriers between you and your wine, often called "corks."
  $10.00
- ATN Mug
  Have you ever tried drinking coffee straight from your hands? This mug works a lot better than that. ATN Logo on one side, illustration on the other.
  $12.00
- ATN Chip Clip
  Keep it together!
  $4.00