All Star Pizza - Penfield NY Menu

4.3

(250+ Reviews)

Customer Favorites Salads Pizza Specialty Pizza Calzones Wings and Boneless Wings Hot Subs Cold Subs Wraps Side Orders Dessert Drinks Garbage Plates

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- Wings
  Chicken wings, available in sizes from 5 to 50 pieces. Choose from a variety of sauces including BBQ, garlic, country sweet, mild, medium, hot, or high octane.
  $8.79+
- Ultimate Pepperoni Pizza
  Loaded with pepperoni and Cup-n-Char spicy pepperoni.
  $20.89+
- Garlic Bread with Mozzarella and Dipping Sauce
  Topped with melted mozzarella, this garlic bread is served with a side of marinara dipping sauce.
  $5.99
- Boneless Wings
  Boneless chicken wings, available in sizes from 5 to 50 pieces. Selection of sauces includes BBQ, garlic, sweet, mild, medium, hot, and high octane.
  $8.79+
- Chicken Wing Pizza
  Your choice of Buffalo style, BBQ, garlic or country sweet.
  $20.89+
- Large Hand Tossed Cheese Pizza
  Choose a crust.
  $21.44
- Medium Hand Tossed Cheese Pizza
  Choose a crust.
  $16.49
- 2 Liter Soda
  2-liter soda options: Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Fanta Orange.
  $2.99
- Small Hand Tossed Cheese Pizza
  Choose a crust.
  $9.89
- 20 oz. Soda
  20 oz. choice of Coke, Diet Coke, Cherry Coke, Ginger Ale, Dr. Pepper variants, or Root Beer.
  $2.60
Salads
Choice of dressing. Extra dressing for an additional charge.
- Tossed Salad
  Mixed greens, choice of small or large. Selection of dressings: Italian, 1000 Island, Blue Cheese, Ranch, Caesar, Honey Mustard, Vinaigrette, or Lite Italian.
  $7.69+
- Julienne Ham, Turkey and Cheese Salad
  Ham, Turkey, & Cheese
  $11.99
- Grilled Chicken Salad
  Grilled chicken on a bed of crisp greens. Choice of eight dressings, including Italian, Caesar, and honey mustard.
  $11.99
- Cajun Chicken Salad
  Cajun chicken atop crisp greens. Choice of dressing: Italian, 1000 Island, Blue Cheese, Ranch, Caesar, Honey Mustard, Vinaigrette, Lite Italian.
  $11.99
- Buffalo Chicken Salad
  Tender buffalo chicken over crisp greens. Options for Italian, 1000 Island, blue cheese, ranch, Caesar, honey mustard, vinaigrette, lite Italian dressings.
  $11.99
- Chicken Caesar Salad
  Italian, 1000 island, blue cheese, ranch, caesar, greek, honey mustard, vinaigrette & lite italian extra dressing.
  $11.99
Pizza
Add toppings for an additional charge.
- 10" Gluten Free Pizza
  A 10" pizza on a gluten-free crust, typically includes our housemade sauce and a blend of cheeses. Additional toppings available.
  $14.99
- Small Hand Tossed Cheese Pizza
  Choose a crust.
  $9.89
- Medium Hand Tossed Cheese Pizza
  Choose a crust.
  $16.49
- Large Hand Tossed Cheese Pizza
  Choose a crust.
  $21.44
- Sheet Hand Tossed Cheese Pizza
  Choose a crust.
  $31.89
Specialty Pizza
Choice of crust.
- Chicken Wing Pizza
  Your choice of Buffalo style, BBQ, garlic or country sweet.
  $20.89+
- All Star White Pizza
  Garlic, oil, ricotta, mozzarella and spices.
  $18.69+
- Meat Lovers Pizza
  Meatball, pepperoni, sausage and ham.
  $20.89+
- Veggie Pizza
  Onion, green peppers, mushrooms, tomatoes and black olives.
  $20.89+
- Deluxe Pizza
  Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onion and green peppers.
  $20.89+
- 4 Cheese Pizza
  Garlic, oil, mozzarella, provolone, cheddar and Parmesan cheese.
  $20.89+
- Philly Steak Pizza
  Onion, peppers, steak and cheese.
  $20.89+
- California White Veggie Pizza
  Garlic, oil, broccoli, tomatoes, artichokes and spinach.
  $20.89+
- Ultimate Pepperoni Pizza
  Loaded with pepperoni and Cup-n-Char spicy pepperoni.
  $20.89+
Calzones
Calzones
- Calzone Regular
  Generous portions of mozzarella and ricotta stuffed in a garlic-seasoned golden-brown crust with side of sauce. Extra sauce for an additional charge. Add toppings for an additional charge.
  $10.99
- Calzone Large
  Generous portions of mozzarella and ricotta stuffed in a garlic-seasoned golden-brown crust with side of sauce. extra sauce for an additional charge. add toppings for an additional charge.
  $15.94
Wings and Boneless Wings
Includes bleu cheese. Choice of sauce. Add extra for an additional charge.
- Wings
  Chicken wings, available in sizes from 5 to 50 pieces. Choose from a variety of sauces including BBQ, garlic, country sweet, mild, medium, hot, or high octane.
  $8.79+
- Boneless Wings
  Boneless chicken wings, available in sizes from 5 to 50 pieces. Selection of sauces includes BBQ, garlic, sweet, mild, medium, hot, and high octane.
  $8.79+
Hot Subs
Choice a cheese. Add toppings upon request. Add extra for an additional charge.
- Grilled Chicken Hot Sub
  Grilled chicken, choice of cheese including provolone, mozzarella, Swiss, or American, in a submarine sandwich. Available in regular 7" or large 12".
  $10.99+
- Cheeseeburger Hot Sub
  Cheeseburger hot sub with choice of provolone, mozzarella, swiss, or american cheese. Available in regular 7" or large 12".
  $13.19+
- Roast Beef Hot Sub
  Roast beef, choice of cheese: provolone, mozzarella, Swiss, American. Available in 7" or 12".
  $13.19+
- BBQ Beef Hot Sub
  BBQ beef hot sub with choice of provolone, mozzarella, swiss, or american cheese. Available in 7" or 12".
  $13.19+
- Chicken Finger Hot Sub
  Chicken finger pieces, choice of cheese, in a submarine sandwich. Sizes: regular 7", large 12". Cheese options: provolone, mozzarella, swiss, American.
  $13.19+
- Meatball Hot Sub
  Sizes available in 7" or 12". Choice of provolone, mozzarella, Swiss, or American cheese.
  $13.19+
- Chicken Parmesan Hot Sub
  Chicken Parmesan with breaded chicken, marinara sauce, choice of cheese: provolone, mozzarella, Swiss, American. Available in 7" or 12".
  $13.19+
- Eggplant Parmesan Hot Sub
  Eggplant Parmesan Sub: Crispy breaded eggplant, marinara sauce, choice of cheese: provolone, mozzarella, Swiss, or American. Available in 7" or 12".
  $13.19+
- BLT Hot Sub
  BLT hot sub with layers of bacon, lettuce, tomato. Sizes: regular 7", large 12". Cheese options: provolone, mozzarella, swiss, American.
  $13.19+
Cold Subs
Choice a cheese. Add toppings upon request. Add extra for an additional charge.
- Italian Assorted Cold Sub
  Italian meats, with choice of provolone, mozzarella, Swiss, or American cheese in a 7" or 12" submarine sandwich.
  $10.99+
- Ham Cold Sub
  Ham submarine sandwich with options for regular 7" or large 12". Choice of provolone, mozzarella, swiss, or american cheese.
  $10.99+
- Salami Cold Sub
  Salami submarine sandwich with choice of provolone, mozzarella, Swiss, or American cheese. Available in regular 7" or large 12".
  $10.99+
- Roast Beef Cold Sub
  Roast beef cold sub with options for regular 7" or large 12". Selection of provolone, mozzarella, Swiss, or American cheese.
  $10.99+
- Turkey Cold Sub
  Turkey Cold Sub - Submarine sandwich with turkey. Options include regular 7" or large 12", and cheese choices: provolone, mozzarella, swiss, or American.
  $10.99+
- Tuna Cold Sub
  Options for regular 7" or large 12". Choose from provolone, mozzarella, swiss, or American cheese. Submarine sandwich style.
  $10.99+
- Veggie Cold Sub
  Submarine sandwich filled with garden-fresh veggies. Options for size and cheese selection, including provolone, mozzarella, swiss, or American.
  $10.99+
- Capicola Cold Sub
  Capicola slices with selected cheese in a submarine sandwich. Options for 7" or 12", and cheese choices: provolone, mozzarella, swiss, or American.
  $10.99+
- Assorted Cheese Cold Sub
  Mix of provolone, mozzarella, Swiss, and American cheeses in a submarine sandwich. Options for regular 7" or large 12" size.
  $10.99+
Wraps
Choice a wrap. Cold or hot.
- Chicken Caesar Wrap
  Romaine, grilled chicken, Parmesan and Caesar dressing.
  $9.99
- Turkey Club Wrap
  Premium turkey breast, lettuce, tomato, bacon with avocado aoli.
  $9.99
- Roasted Veggie Wrap
  Garlic roasted, portobello mushrooms, broccoli, artichoke hearts and roasted red peppers with avocado aoli.
  $9.99
- Buffalo Chicken Wrap
  Chicken fingers dipped in Buffalo wing sauce with lettuce, tomato and blue cheese.
  $9.99
Side Orders
Side Orders
- Garlic Bread with Mozzarella and Dipping Sauce
  Topped with melted mozzarella, this garlic bread is served with a side of marinara dipping sauce.
  $5.99
- Pizza Logs
  Pizza logs typically consist of crispy eggroll wrappers filled with mozzarella cheese and pepperoni, served with a side of pizza sauce for dipping.
  $7.99
- Mozzarella Sticks
  6 pieces.
  $7.99
- Fried Mushrooms
  Crispy Golden-Battered Mushrooms
  $7.99
- Chicken Fingers
  Add fries for an additional charge.
  $11.99
- Jalapeno Poppers
  Spicy, Cream Cheese-Stuffed Jalapeños, Breaded and Deep-Fried to Golden Perfection
  $7.49
- French Fries
  Crispy, golden-brown potato fries with a light, crunchy exterior and tender interior.
  $4.59
- Cheesy Fries
  Served with mozzarella, cheddar, bacon and 1 side of any sauce. Extra sauce for an additional charge.
  $11.99
- Onion Rings
  Crispy golden-fried onion rings, perfectly seasoned for a savory crunch.
  $5.59
Dessert
Dessert
- Fried Dough
  Fresh dough expertly fried and traditionally served with a generous dusting of powdered sugar, often accompanied by a drizzle of vanilla icing.
  $5.99
Drinks
Drinks
- 2 Liter Soda
  2-liter soda options: Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Fanta Orange.
  $2.99
- 20 oz. Soda
  20 oz. choice of Coke, Diet Coke, Cherry Coke, Ginger Ale, Dr. Pepper variants, or Root Beer.
  $2.60
- Powerade
  A combination of electrolytes and carbohydrates that provide effective hydration and energy.
  $2.55
- Gold Peak
  Gold Peak Tea, options include unsweetened or sweet with lemon.
  $2.55
Garbage Plates
Garbage Plates
- Cheeseburger.
  Includes American cheese
  $15.95
- Red Hots
  Includes American cheese
  $15.95
- 1 Cheeseburger 1 Red Hot
  Includes American cheese
  $15.95
- Chicken Finger
  Choose a sauce for your fingers to be tossed in, or select "no sauce" to have them plain. Includes American cheese
  $15.95
- Steak
  Add peppers and/or mushrooms for no charge. Includes cheddar cheese
  $15.94