Heavenly Pizza- Tiffin Menu

69 W Market St, Tiffin, OH 44883

Pizza Specialty Crust Options for 10" pizzas Toppings Specialty Pizza Subs & Foldovers (sub ingredients inside pizza dough and folded over)Specialty Subs & Foldovers Salads Pasta Appetizers, Desserts, & Extras Beverages

Pizza
- 10" Cheese Pizza
  $7.95
- 12" Cheese Pizza
  $10.95
- 14" Cheese Pizza
  $12.45
- 16" Or Jr. Jumbo
  $16.00
- Jumbo
  $24.95
- 10" 1 Topping Pizza
  $9.05
- 12" 1 Topping Pizza
  $12.45
- 14" 1 Topping Pizza
  $14.20
- 16" Or Jr. Jumbo 1 Topping Pizza
  $17.00
- Jumbo 1 Topping Pizza
  $28.45
- 10" 2 Topping Pizza
  $10.15
- 12" 2 Topping Pizza
  $13.95
- 14" 2 Topping Pizza
  $15.95
- 16" Or Jr. Jumbo 2 Topping Pizza
  $19.00
- Jumbo 2 Topping Pizza
  $31.95
- 10" 3 Topping Pizza
  $11.25
- 12" 3 Topping Pizza
  $15.45
- 14" 3 Topping Pizza
  $17.70
- 16" Or Jr. Jumbo 3 Topping Pizza
  $21.00
- Jumbo 3 Topping Pizza
  $35.45
- 10" 4 Topping Pizza
  $12.35
- 12" 4 Topping Pizza
  $16.95
- 14" 4 Topping Pizza
  $19.45
- 16" Or Jr. Jumbo 4 Topping Pizza
  $23.00
- Jumbo 4 Topping Pizza
  $38.95
Specialty Crust Options for 10" pizzas
- Artisan Vegan Crust
  Gluten-free dough is made in a non-gluten-free environment; cross-contact may occur.
  $4.00
- Cauliflower Crust
  $4.00
Toppings
- Toppings
  Per Extra Item: 10": $1.10 12": $1.50 14": $1.75 16" or Jr. Jumbo: $2.00 Jumbo: $3.50 Pepperoni, Mushrooms, Ham, Sausage, Italian Sausage, Green Peppers, Onions, Green Olives, Black Olives, Mild Pepper Rings, Tomatoes, Jalapeno Peppers, Pineapple, Dill Pickle slices
- Additional Premium Toppings
  Cost for Premium Toppings, Extra Cheese, Chicken, Eggs, Steak, Meatballs, or Bacon 10": $2.00 12": $2.50 14": $3.00 16" or Jr. Jumbo: $3.50 Jumbo: $6.00 Eggs, Steak, Meatballs
Specialty Pizza
- AJ’s 6-Item Supreme
  A delightful combination of pepperoni, mushrooms, sausage, ham, onions, green peppers, and cheese 10": $12.35 12": $16.95 14": $19.45 16" or Jr. Jumbo: $22.95 Jumbo: $37.95
  $12.35
- Meat Lover’s
  A delicious combination of pepperoni, sausage, Italian sausage, ham, and bacon 10": $12.35 12": $16.95 14": $19.45 16" or Jr. Jumbo: $22.95 Jumbo: $37.95
  $12.35
- Veggie
  A healthy and delicious combination of onions, black and green olives, mushrooms, bananas, peppers, green peppers, and tomatoes. 10": $12.35 12": $16.95 14": $19.45 16" or Jr. Jumbo: $22.95 Jumbo: $37.95
  $12.35
- BBQ Chicken (Sweet Baby Ray’s)
  A delicious combination of sweet BBQ sauce, chicken, and 2 items of choice. 10": $12.35 12": $16.95 14": $19.45 16" or Jr. Jumbo: $22.95 Jumbo: $37.95
  $12.35
- Chicken Or Steak Chipotle
  Your choice of chicken or steak, chipotle sauce, onions, and green peppers. 10": $12.35 12": $16.95 14": $19.45 16" or Jr. Jumbo: $22.95 Jumbo: $37.95
  $12.35
- AJ’s Breakfast Pizza
  A tasty combination of mayo, diced hard-boiled eggs, sausage, and bacon. 10": $12.35 12": $16.95 14": $19.45 16" or Jr. Jumbo: $22.95 Jumbo: $37.95
  $12.35
- Buffalo Chicken
  A spicy combination of our hot wing sauce, chicken, cheese, plus 2 other toppings of your choice. 10": $12.35 12": $16.95 14": $19.45 16" or Jr. Jumbo: $22.95 Jumbo: $37.95
  $12.35
- Chicken Bacon Ranch
  A mouthwatering blend of chicken, bacon, creamy ranch sauce, and cheese. 10": $12.35 12": $16.95 14": $19.45 16" or Jr. Jumbo: $22.95 Jumbo: $37.95
  $12.35
- BLT
  A deluxe combination of bacon, cheese, mayo, lettuce, tomatoes…and bacon! Yes, more bacon! 10": $12.35 12": $16.95 14": $19.45 16" or Jr. Jumbo: $22.95 Jumbo: $37.95
  $12.35
- Philly Steak
  A deluxe combination of steak, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, mayonnaise and cheese. 10": $12.35 12": $16.95 14": $19.45 16" or Jr. Jumbo: $22.95 Jumbo: $37.95
  $12.35
- Pepperoni Lovers Pizza
  Triple Pepperonis and triple cheese. 10": $12.35 12": $16.95 14": $19.45 16" or Jr. Jumbo: $22.95 Jumbo: $37.95
  $12.35
- Deluxe
  A deluxe combination of pepperoni, mushrooms, ham, sausage, Italian sausage, green peppers, onions, green olives, black olives, mild pepper rings, bacon, and tomatoes. 10": $12.35 12": $16.95 14": $19.45 16" or Jr. Jumbo: $22.95 Jumbo: $37.95
  $12.35
- Pickle
  A mouthwatering blend of cheese, bacon, creamy ranch sauce, and dill pickle slices! 10": $12.35 12": $16.95 14": $19.45 16" or Jr. Jumbo: $22.95 Jumbo: $37.95
  $12.35
Subs & Foldovers (sub ingredients inside pizza dough and folded over)
- Pizza
  Pepperoni, Ham, Cheese, and Sauce. Half Sub (8"): $7.95 Whole Sub (12"): $8.95 Small (12") Foldover: $11.95 Large (16") Foldover: $15.95
  $7.95
- Italian
  Ham, Pepperoni, Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, and Mayo. Half Sub (8"): $7.95 Whole Sub (12"): $8.95 Small (12") Foldover: $11.95 Large (16") Foldover: $15.95
  $7.95
- Pepperoni
  Pepperoni, Cheese, Sauce. Half Sub (8"): $7.95 Whole Sub (12"): $8.95 Small (12") Foldover: $11.95 Large (16") Foldover: $15.95
  $7.95
- Vegetarian
  Lettuce, Tomato, Green Peppers, Mushrooms, Black and Green Olives, Onions, Banana Peppers, and Mayo Half Sub (8"): $7.95 Whole Sub (12"): $8.95 Small (12") Foldover: $11.95 Large (16") Foldover: $15.95
  $7.95
- Chicken
  Chicken, Lettuce, Tomato, Cheese, and Mayo. Half Sub (8"): $7.95 Whole Sub (12"): $8.95 Small (12") Foldover: $11.95 Large (16") Foldover: $15.95
  $7.95
- Ham & Cheese
  Ham, Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, and Mayo. Half Sub (8"): $7.95 Whole Sub (12"): $8.95 Small (12") Foldover: $11.95 Large (16") Foldover: $15.95
  $7.95
Specialty Subs & Foldovers
- Steak
  Steak, Cheese, and BBQ Sauce. Half Sub (8"): $8.95 Whole Sub (12"): $9.95 Small (12") Foldover: $12.95 Large (16") Foldover: $16.95
  $8.95
- Chicken Club
  Chicken, Ham, Bacon, Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, and Mayo. Half Sub (8"): $8.95 Whole Sub (12"): $9.95 Small (12") Foldover: $12.95 Large (16") Foldover: $16.95
  $8.95
- Chicken Bacon Ranch
  Chicken, Bacon, Ranch Sauce, and Cheese. Half Sub (8"): $8.95 Whole Sub (12"): $9.95 Small (12") Foldover: $12.95 Large (16") Foldover: $16.95
  $8.95
- Buffalo Chicken
  Chicken, Hot Wing Sauce, Cheese, and two other toppings of your choice. Half Sub (8"): $8.95 Whole Sub (12"): $9.95 Small (12") Foldover: $12.95 Large (16") Foldover: $16.95
  $8.95
- BBQ Chicken
  Chicken, BBQ Sauce, Cheese, and two toppings of your choice. Half Sub (8"): $8.95 Whole Sub (12"): $9.95 Small (12") Foldover: $12.95 Large (16") Foldover: $16.95
  $8.95
- Chipotle
  Chicken or Steak, Onions, Green Peppers, and Chipotle Sauce. Half Sub (8"): $8.95 Whole Sub (12"): $9.95 Small (12") Foldover: $12.95 Large (16") Foldover: $16.95
  $8.95
- Philly Steak
  Steak, Mushrooms, Onions, Green Peppers, Mayonnaise and Cheese. Half Sub (8"): $8.95 Whole Sub (12"): $9.95 Small (12") Foldover: $12.95 Large (16") Foldover: $16.95
  $8.95
- BLT
  Bacon, Lettuce, Cheese, Tomato, and Mayo. Half Sub (8"): $8.95 Whole Sub (12"): $9.95 Small (12") Foldover: $12.95 Large (16") Foldover: $16.95
  $8.95
- Meatball
  Meatballs, Cheese, Sauce. Half Sub (8"): $8.95 Whole Sub (12"): $9.95 Small (12") Foldover: $12.95 Large (16") Foldover: $16.95
  $8.95
Salads
- Antipasto Salad
  A generous portion of Lettuce, Tomato, Pepperoni, Mild Pepper Rings, Onions, Ham, and Cheese. Small: $8.45 Large: $9.95 Family: $28.95
  $8.45
- Chef Salad
  A large serving of Lettuce, Tomato, Ham, Onion, Cheese, and Egg. Small: $8.45 Large: $9.95 Family: $28.95
  $8.45
- Toss Salad
  Lettuce, Tomato, Onions, and Cheese. Small: $7.45 Large: $8.95 Family: $27.95
  $7.45
- Chicken Ceasar Salad
  Lettuce, Cheese, and Chicken. Small: $8.45 Large: $9.95 Family: $28.95
  $8.45
- Salad Dressings
  French, Fat Free French, Lite Italian, Ranch, Lite Ranch, Caesar, Thousand Island, Honey Mustard, Blue Cheese, and Heavenly Pizza Homemade Dressing. (Ask about our House Dressing to go!)
Pasta
- Cheese Lasagna
  Single Serving: $8.95 Family Size: $27.95
  $8.95
- Meat Lasagna
  Single Serving: $9.95 Family Size: $28.95
  $9.95
- Deluxe Lasagna
  Single Serving: $10.45 Family Size: $29.95
  $10.45
Appetizers, Desserts, & Extras
- Breadstix - Small
  Order of 12. + $4.00 for Gluten-free Artisan or Cauliflower. Small size only.
  $7.95
- Breadstix - Large
  Order of 24
  $11.95
- Breadstix - Family Size
  Order of 48.
  $21.95
- Cheese Breadstix - Small
  Order of 12. + $4.00 for Gluten-free Artisan or Cauliflower. Small size only.
  $7.95
- Cheese Breadstix - Large
  Order of 24.
  $11.95
- Cheese Breadstix - Family Size
  Order of 48.
  $21.95
- Parmesan Stix - Small
  Order of 6. + $4.00 for Gluten-free Artisan or Cauliflower. Small size only.
  $7.95
- Parmesan Stix - Large
  Order of 24.
  $11.95
- Parmesan Stix - Family Size
  Order of 48.
  $21.95
- Garlic Bread
  Order of 12.
  $7.95
- Chicken Chunks - Order Of 10
  Hot & Spicy, Hot BBQ, Sweet BBQ, Roasted Garlic BBQ, Chipotle Ranch, or Baked Ranch.
  $10.95
- Chicken Chunks - Order Of 30
  Hot & Spicy, Hot BBQ, Sweet BBQ, Roasted Garlic BBQ, Chipotle Ranch, or Baked Ranch.
  $28.95
- Chicken Wings
  Hot & Spicy, Hot BBQ, Sweet BBQ, Roasted Garlic BBQ, Chipotle Ranch, or Baked Ranch.
  $10.95
- Chicken Wings
  Hot & Spicy, Hot BBQ, Sweet BBQ, Roasted Garlic BBQ, Chipotle Ranch, or Baked Ranch.
  $28.95
- Add House Dressing
  Add house dressing to any sub or foldover.
- Extra Sauce
  Cup.
- Pizza By The Slice
  Each.
  $2.00
- Pepperoni Roll
  Limited Availability.
  $3.50
- Garlic Butter
  Each.
- Cookies
  Each
- Pizza Cookie
  $6.95
- Brownies
  $1.75
- Pizza Brownie
  $6.95
- Cinnamon Stix - Small
  Order of 6. + $4.00 for Gluten-free Artisan or Cauliflower. Small size only.
  $7.95
- Cinnamon Stix - Large
  Order of 24.
  $11.95
- Cinnamon Stix - Family Size
  Order of 48.
  $21.95
Beverages
- Can Of Pop/Soda
  Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Dr. Pepper, Mt. Dew, Starry, Mug Root Beer
  $1.25
- 20 Oz. Bottle
  Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Dr. Pepper, Mt. Dew, Starry, Mug Root Beer, Diet Dr. Pepper
  $2.50
- 2 Liter Bottle
  Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Dr. Pepper, Mt. Dew, Starry, Mug Root Beer, Cherry Pepsi
  $3.75
- Gatorade
  $2.50
- Bottled Water
- 20 Oz. Lemonade
  $2.50

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

Heavenly Pizza- Tiffin Menu

Pizza

10" Cheese Pizza

12" Cheese Pizza

14" Cheese Pizza

16" Or Jr. Jumbo

Jumbo

10" 1 Topping Pizza

12" 1 Topping Pizza

14" 1 Topping Pizza

16" Or Jr. Jumbo 1 Topping Pizza

Jumbo 1 Topping Pizza

10" 2 Topping Pizza

12" 2 Topping Pizza

14" 2 Topping Pizza

16" Or Jr. Jumbo 2 Topping Pizza

Jumbo 2 Topping Pizza

10" 3 Topping Pizza

12" 3 Topping Pizza

14" 3 Topping Pizza

16" Or Jr. Jumbo 3 Topping Pizza

Jumbo 3 Topping Pizza

10" 4 Topping Pizza

12" 4 Topping Pizza

14" 4 Topping Pizza

16" Or Jr. Jumbo 4 Topping Pizza

Jumbo 4 Topping Pizza

Specialty Crust Options for 10" pizzas

Artisan Vegan Crust

Cauliflower Crust

Toppings

Toppings

Additional Premium Toppings

Specialty Pizza

AJ’s 6-Item Supreme

Meat Lover’s

Veggie

BBQ Chicken (Sweet Baby Ray’s)

Chicken Or Steak Chipotle

AJ’s Breakfast Pizza

Buffalo Chicken

Chicken Bacon Ranch

BLT

Philly Steak

Pepperoni Lovers Pizza

Deluxe

Pickle

Subs & Foldovers (sub ingredients inside pizza dough and folded over)

Pizza

Italian

Pepperoni

Vegetarian

Chicken

Ham & Cheese

Specialty Subs & Foldovers

Steak

Chicken Club

Chicken Bacon Ranch

Buffalo Chicken

BBQ Chicken

Chipotle

Philly Steak

BLT

Meatball

Salads

Antipasto Salad

Chef Salad

Toss Salad

Chicken Ceasar Salad

Salad Dressings

Pasta

Cheese Lasagna

Meat Lasagna

Deluxe Lasagna

Appetizers, Desserts, & Extras

Breadstix - Small

Breadstix - Large

Breadstix - Family Size

Cheese Breadstix - Small

Cheese Breadstix - Large