Search
Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.- Cookie Monsterall kinds of cookies & cream & fudge & yeah$6.25+
- Cookie Monster Pintall kinds of cookies & cream & fudge & yeah [prepacked]$10.00
- Double ScoopWhat's your two-scoop combo?$9.25
- MilkshakeAny flavor ice cream delivered with whipped cream & a topping. Milkshakes cannot be made vegan at this time$10.25
- Hand-Scooped Pintany flavor hand-scooped just for you$12.00
- Salty O's PintSalty Vanilla Ice Cream with Oreos [prepacked]$10.00
- Salty O'sSalty Vanilla Ice Cream with Oreos$6.25+
- Cookie Butter Pintcreamy speculoos ice cream with crushed speculoos cookies [prepacked]$10.00
- Milk & Sugar Cookiessweet cream ice cream with chunks of colorful sugar cookies$6.25+
- Triple ScoopWhy choose 2 flavors when you can have 3?!$11.25
- Milk & Cerealsweet milk ice cream blended and topped with our famous Afters Flakes; Kellog's Corn Flakes that are caramelized in butter, sugar, and salt.$6.25+
- Ube Brownie PintUbe Ice Cream With Chunks of Gooey Brownie [prepacked]$10.00
Afters Premium Handcrafted Ice Cream
- Cookie Monsterall kinds of cookies & cream & fudge & yeah$6.25+
- Saigon Coffeeice cream & coffee? say less$6.25+
- Milk & Cerealsweet milk ice cream blended and topped with our famous Afters Flakes; Kellog's Corn Flakes that are caramelized in butter, sugar, and salt.$6.25+
- Mint Monstera classic but with a twist. mint ice cream with Oreos, fudge, & chocolate chip cookies$6.25+
- Mango Sorbetrefreshing mango sorbet [vegan]$6.25+
- Triple C'sclassic vanilla ice cream with chocolate chips, chocolate fudge, and caramel$6.25+
- Madagascar Vanillavanilla beans from the island of Madagascar$6.25+
- Cookie Buttercreamy speculoos ice cream with crushed speculoos cookies$6.25+
- Dark Matter Brownie Batteryes, we know you've always wanted to eat brownie batter. so we made it$6.25+
Seasonal Flavors
- Birthday Cakesweet cream ice cream with cake batter, vanilla cake and rainbow sprinkles$6.25+
- Salty O'sSalty Vanilla Ice Cream with Oreos$6.25+
- Milk & Sugar Cookiessweet cream ice cream with chunks of colorful sugar cookies$6.25+
- Killer Chocolate BrownieRich Chocolate Ice Cream with House-Made Chocolate Brownies and Melt in Your Mouth Chocolately Flakes$6.25+
Scoops
- Triple ScoopWhy choose 2 flavors when you can have 3?!$11.25
- Single ScoopTrying a new flavor or sticking with your tried & true..one scoop is for you$6.25
- Double ScoopWhat's your two-scoop combo?$9.25
Pints
- Chocolate Chip Cookie Pint [plant-based][prepacked]$10.00
- Saigon Coffee Pint[prepacked]$10.00
- Jasmine Milk Tea Pint[prepacked]$10.00
- Dark Matter Brownie Batter Pint[prepacked]$10.00
- Cookie Monster Pintall kinds of cookies & cream & fudge & yeah [prepacked]$10.00
- Milk and Cereal Pintsweet milk ice cream blended with our famous Afters Flakes that are buttered and caramelized [prepacked]$10.00
- Strawberry Cookie Crunch Pintclassic strawberry ice cream with chocolate chip cookies.. lots of them [prepacked]$10.00
- Ube Brownie PintUbe Ice Cream With Chunks of Gooey Brownie [prepacked]$10.00
- Salty O's PintSalty Vanilla Ice Cream with Oreos [prepacked]$10.00
- On Cloud BT21 PintBT21 MEETS AFTERS vanilla rainbow sprinkle ice cream with pound cake pieces and a housemade mixed berry swirl.$10.00
- Cookie Butter Pintcreamy speculoos ice cream with crushed speculoos cookies [prepacked]$10.00
- Hand-Scooped Pintany flavor hand-scooped just for you$12.00
Quarts
- Saigon Coffee Quartice cream & coffee? say less [prepacked]$20.00
- Dark Matter Brownie Batter Quartyes, we know you've always wanted to eat brownie batter. so we made it [prepacked]$20.00
- Jasmine Milk Tea Quartyour favorite milk tea in ice cream form [prepacked]$20.00
- Chocolate Chip Cookie [vegan] QuartPlant-based Chocolate chip cookie dough with Afters plant-based chocolate chip cookies, chocolate chips, and chocolate swirl. [prepacked]$20.00
- Cookie Monster Quartall kinds of cookies & cream & fudge & yeah [prepacked]$20.00
- Milk & Cereal Quartsweet milk ice cream blended with our famous Afters Flakes that are buttered and caramelized [prepacked]$20.00
- Hand-Scooped Quartsany flavor and a lot of it!$22.00
- Cookie Butter Quartcreamy Speculoos ice cream with crushed Speculoos cookies [prepacked]$20.00
- Strawberry Cookie Crunch Quartclassic strawberry ice cream with chocolate chip cookies.. lots of them [prepacked]$20.00
Specialty Items
- Ice Cream BarsHandcrafted Afters Ice Cream dipped in creamy milk chocolate$5.25
- MilkshakeAny flavor ice cream delivered with whipped cream & a topping. Milkshakes cannot be made vegan at this time$10.25
Toppings A La Carte
- Cinnamon Toast CrunchA cereal that consists of small squares or rectangles of wheat and rice covered with cinnamon and sugar.$0.90
- Fruity PebblesA cereal is a sweetened crispy rice cereal with intense fruity flavor. this delicious cereal is gluten free and has 11 essential vitamins and minerals.$0.90
- Crushed Oreos$0.90
- Cap'n CrunchA cereal made of sweetened, yellow, square-shaped pieces$0.90
- Afters Flakescorn flakes that we butter and caramalize$0.90
- Rainbow Sprinkles$0.90
- Gummy Bears$0.90
- Mochi$0.90
- Cookie Crisp$0.90
Cones
- Cake Conewhole, not crushed$1.00
- Fresh Waffle Conewhole, not crushed - made in house$1.75
Drinks
- Orange Jarritos$3.95
- Mexican CokeThe same great taste made with only pure cane sugar and served in a bottle.$3.95
- Virgils Root Beer$3.95
- Water$2.95
Dog Ice Cream
- Hooman Food (dog treat)Peanut Butter & Banana Dog Treat$4.25
