A Slice of New York Menu

4.7

(1,800+ Reviews)

Customer Favorites Large 18” - Specialty Pies Small 14” - Specialty Pies Personal 10” - Specialty Pies Build Your Own Pie Other Eats Desserts Drinks Merch!Sauces/Extras "TIP" the Crew Catering

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- ASONY Margarita - Personal 10"
  Vegetarian. ASONY Garlic Oil base, peeled plum tomato (pureed), fresh basil, fresh garlic, fresh parmesan, EVOO. This is our version of a Margherita and is highly popular! Both delicate and complex, it pops with color and flavor. If you want to try a signature dish you can't find anywhere else, try this!
  $15.00
- Garlic Knots
  Vegetarian. More like an homage to the knot. Our dough tossed in Asony garlic oil, topped with extra ASONY Garlic Oil, and then sprinkled with fresh parmesan. Served with our marinara sauce.
  $6.00
- Large 18”
  Our large is 18" and will feed 3-5 people. It is cut into eight slices. Keep in mind, the number of slices has nothing to with the size of the pie or the amount of food it is. It is just a label. Some would call our large their X-large or don't even offer that size. Whole pies only, no half/half.
  $29.00
- Small 14”
  Keep in mind, our small is not small; in fact it is pretty big at 14". Don't let the name fool you. It will feed 2-3 people. The number of slices has nothing to with the size of the pie or the amount of food it is. It is just a label. Many places call their large 14" (the size of this small). It is cut into eight slices. Whole pies only, no half/half.
  $22.00
- ASONY Margarita - Large 18"
  Vegetarian. ASONY Garlic Oil base, peeled plum tomato (pureed), fresh basil, fresh garlic, fresh parmesan, EVOO. This is our version of a Margherita and is highly popular! Both delicate and complex, it pops with color and flavor. If you want to try a signature dish you can't find anywhere else, try this!
  $36.00
- Mini-Cannoli (set of 3) - From NY!
  Traditional cream with chocolate chips, topped with powdered sugar. When you order a cannoli, this is what you expect. We get the filling and shells from Long Island, and we make them to order. The ratio of cream to shell is lower, so this may seem a bit less sweet than a large one. Perfect for sharing!
  $7.00
- Tiramisu - From NY!
  If you are a tiramisu fan, you will not be disappointed. They handcraft the Tiramisu the old-fashioned way, using the finest authentic ingredients. Imported Savoiardi ladyfingers are hand dipped in a custom espresso mixture, layered with ethereal mascarpone imported from Italy, then finished with a generous dusting of premium cocoa powder. They say, "You will not find a better Tiramisu anywhere," and we agree!
  $7.00
- The City (Combo) - Large 18"
  Pepperoni, Italian sausage, fresh mushrooms, sliced red onions, bell peppers, black olives, fresh chopped garlic. If you want a great combination pie, this is it. The flavors are fresh and bold, yet not overpowering each other. Pure goodness!
  $46.50
- Ranch Cup - 1.5oz
  Ken's is a high-quality brand and their ranch is great on slices or garlic knots. More ranch please! Each cup is $0.50. 1.5oz cup
  $0.50
- Personal 10”
  Our personal is equivalent to about two house slices you would get from us from the display if you came in for slices. Whole pies only, no half/half.
  $13.00
Large 18” - Specialty Pies
Please identify any allergies/restrictions. Sorry, whole pies only; no half/half. A quick tip for crisping or heating a fresh pie: 1. Heat up a skillet/frying pan (high heat, no oil). 2. When hot, place a slice or two in the pan (optional: cover the pan to melt the cheese a bit more). 3. In a minute or two, the bottom will be dry and crisp as if it came out of our pizza ovens! You can also heat up a pizza stone, but that's overkill. Save the energy!
- The City (Combo) - Large 18"
  Pepperoni, Italian sausage, fresh mushrooms, sliced red onions, bell peppers, black olives, fresh chopped garlic. If you want a great combination pie, this is it. The flavors are fresh and bold, yet not overpowering each other. Pure goodness!
  $46.50
- Buffalo Chicken - Large 18"
  ASONY Garlic Oil base, seasoned chicken breast, sliced red onions, Franks red hot, fresh basil, fresh parmesan. A little spicy and what you want in a Buffalo flavor. We use a special version of Franks, their Buffalo version - extra spicy. It does have a kick, but not crazy at all. If you like our Buffalo slice, enjoy!
  $43.00
- Rockefeller Center (All Meat) - Large 18"
  Pepperoni, Italian sausage, salami, meatballs, fresh chopped garlic. This is a great option for the meat lovers. It is a little salty in all the right places. If someone is asking for the "one with meat," this is it.
  $43.00
- Bensonhurst (Chicken) - Large 18"
  Seasoned chicken breast, pesto (no nuts), fresh mushrooms, fresh chopped garlic. If you like pesto and chicken, this is a great option. This has been on our menu since we opened, and for good reason.
  $46.50
- Times Square (All Veggie) - Large 18"
  Vegetarian. Bell peppers, fresh mushrooms, sliced red onions, black olives, fresh chopped garlic. If you like veggies, this is it. Everything is prepped fresh daily. It is very similar to our combo pie (The City) except no meat!
  $43.00
- ASONY Margarita - Large 18"
  Vegetarian. ASONY Garlic Oil base, peeled plum tomato (pureed), fresh basil, fresh garlic, fresh parmesan, EVOO. This is our version of a Margherita and is highly popular! Both delicate and complex, it pops with color and flavor. If you want to try a signature dish you can't find anywhere else, try this!
  $36.00
- Munchie Lunchie - Large 18"
  Pepperoni, chorizo, jalapeño. Created by a member of our team. This is a spicy and delicious option for you if heat is a preference. Not super hot, but a bit of kick for sure.
  $39.50
- Coney Island (Hawaiian) - Large 18"
  Does pineapple belong on pizza? This is our standard Hawaiian pie with a New York name. #teampineapple
  $36.00
- White - Large 18"
  Vegetarian. ASONY Garlic Oil base, mozzarella, ricotta, fresh parmesan, EVOO. This is an "Off-Menu" item that has become very popular over the years. The ricotta makes this pie a creamy delight. You might have seen this pie with fresh basil and Balsamic reduction...we call that the "Fancy White." Just order this and add fresh basil and Balsamic reduction and you'll get it!
  $36.00
- Panini - Large 18"
  ASONY Garlic Oil base, smoked ham, salami, fresh basil, Balsamic reduction, fresh parmesan. This is an "off-menu" item. We created this as an homage to the panini sandwiches we used to make. They were delicious and so is this. If you like things a little salty, you'll like this too. We added this because many of our long-time customers asked for it!
  $43.00
- Wall Street - Large 18"
  ASONY Garlic Oil base, mozzarella, ricotta, pepperoni, bacon, Mike's Hot Honey. This is a new "Off-Menu" item that has really taken off. It was created internally by our team and really looks and smells great. And of course, it tastes awesome! If you like the White Pie, this is a meat evolution of it. And if you see orange oil drip off a slice, it's probably not from the pepperoni; it is the Mike's Hot Honey. Don't blot it off or let it drip off. It's good!
  $46.50
Small 14” - Specialty Pies
Please identify any allergies/restrictions. Sorry, whole pies only; no half/half. A quick tip for crisping or heating a fresh pie: 1. Heat up a skillet/frying pan (high heat, no oil). 2. When hot, place a slice or two in the pan (optional: cover the pan to melt the cheese a bit more). 3. In a minute or two, the bottom will be dry and crisp as if it came out of our pizza ovens! You can also heat up a pizza stone, but that's overkill. Save the energy!
- The City (Combo) - Small 14"
  Pepperoni, Italian sausage, fresh mushrooms, sliced red onions, bell peppers, black olives, fresh chopped garlic. If you want a great combination pie, this is it. The flavors are fresh and bold, yet not overpowering each other. Pure goodness!
  $39.50
- Buffalo Chicken - Small 14"
  ASONY Garlic Oil base, seasoned chicken breast, sliced red onions, Franks red hot, fresh basil, fresh parmesan. A little spicy and what you want in a Buffalo flavor. We use a special version of Franks, their Buffalo version - extra spicy. It does have a kick, but not crazy at all. If you like our Buffalo slice, enjoy!
  $36.00
- Rockefeller Center (All Meat) - Small 14"
  Pepperoni, Italian sausage, salami, meatballs, fresh chopped garlic. This is a great option for the meat lovers. It is a little salty in all the right places. If someone is asking for the "one with meat," this is it.
  $36.00
- Bensonhurst (Chicken) - Small 14"
  Seasoned chicken breast, pesto (no nuts), fresh mushrooms, fresh chopped garlic. If you like pesto and chicken, this is a great option. This has been on our menu since we opened, and for good reason.
  $39.50
- Times Square (All Veggie) - Small 14"
  Vegetarian. Bell peppers, fresh mushrooms, sliced red onions, black olives, fresh chopped garlic. If you like veggies, this is it. Everything is prepped fresh daily. It is very similar to our combo pie (The City) except no meat!
  $36.00
- ASONY Margarita - Small 14"
  Vegetarian. ASONY Garlic Oil base, peeled plum tomato (pureed), fresh basil, fresh garlic, fresh parmesan, EVOO. This is our version of a Margherita and is highly popular! Both delicate and complex, it pops with color and flavor. If you want to try a signature dish you can't find anywhere else, try this!
  $29.00
- Munchie Lunchie - Small 14"
  Pepperoni, chorizo, jalapeño. Created by a member of our team. This is a spicy and delicious option for you if heat is a preference. Not super hot, but a bit of kick for sure.
  $32.50
- Coney Island (Hawaiian) - Small 14"
  Does pineapple belong on pizza? This is our standard Hawaiian pie with a New York name. #teampineapple
  $29.00
- White - Small 14"
  Vegetarian. ASONY Garlic Oil base, mozzarella, ricotta, fresh parmesan, EVOO. This is an "Off-Menu" item that has become very popular over the years. The ricotta makes this pie a creamy delight. You might have seen this pie with fresh basil and Balsamic reduction...we call that the "Fancy White." Just order this and add fresh basil and Balsamic reduction and you'll get it!
  $29.00
- Panini - Small 14"
  ASONY Garlic Oil base, smoked ham, salami, fresh basil, Balsamic reduction, fresh parmesan. This is an "off-menu" item. We created this as an homage to the panini sandwiches we used to make. They were delicious and so is this. If you like things a little salty, you'll like this too. We added this because many of our long-time customers asked for it!
  $36.00
- Wall Street - Small 14"
  ASONY Garlic Oil base, mozzarella, ricotta, pepperoni, bacon, Mike's Hot Honey. This is a new "Off-Menu" item that has really taken off. It was created internally by our team and really looks and smells great. And of course, it tastes awesome! If you like the White Pie, this is a meat evolution of it. And if you see orange oil drip off a slice, it's probably not from the pepperoni; it is the Mike's Hot Honey. Don't blot it off or let it drip off. It's good!
  $39.50
Personal 10” - Specialty Pies
Please identify any allergies/restrictions. A quick tip for crisping or heating a fresh pie: 1. Heat up a skillet/frying pan (high heat, no oil). 2. When hot, place a slice or two in the pan (optional: cover the pan to melt the cheese a bit more). 3. In a minute or two, the bottom will be dry and crisp as if it came out of our pizza ovens! You can also heat up a pizza stone, but that's overkill. Save the energy!
- The City (Combo) - Personal 10"
  Pepperoni, Italian sausage, fresh mushrooms, sliced red onions, bell peppers, black olives, fresh chopped garlic. If you want a great combination pie, this is it. The flavors are fresh and bold, yet not overpowering each other. Pure goodness!
  $18.00
- Buffalo Chicken - Personal 10"
  ASONY Garlic Oil base, seasoned chicken breast, sliced red onions, Franks Red Hot, fresh basil, fresh parmesan. A little spicy and what you want in a Buffalo flavor. We use a special version of Franks, their Buffalo version - Extra Spicy. It does have a kick, but not crazy at all. If you like our Buffalo slice, enjoy!
  $17.00
- Rockefeller Center (All Meat) - Personal 10"
  Pepperoni, Italian sausage, salami, meatballs, fresh chopped garlic. This is a great option for the meat lovers. It is a little salty in all the right places. If someone is asking for the "one with meat," this is it.
  $17.00
- Bensonhurst (Chicken) - Personal 10"
  Seasoned chicken breast, pesto (no nuts), fresh mushrooms, fresh chopped garlic. If you like pesto and chicken, this is a great option. This has been on our menu since we opened, and for good reason.
  $18.00
- Times Square (All Veggie) - Personal 10"
  Vegetarian. Bell peppers, fresh mushrooms, sliced red onions, black olives, fresh chopped garlic. If you like veggies, this is it. Everything is prepped fresh daily. It is very similar to our combo pie (The City) except no meat!
  $17.00
- ASONY Margarita - Personal 10"
  Vegetarian. ASONY Garlic Oil base, peeled plum tomato (pureed), fresh basil, fresh garlic, fresh parmesan, EVOO. This is our version of a Margherita and is highly popular! Both delicate and complex, it pops with color and flavor. If you want to try a signature dish you can't find anywhere else, try this!
  $15.00
- Munchie Lunchie - Personal 10"
  Pepperoni, chorizo, jalapeño. Created by a member of our team. This is a spicy and delicious option for you if heat is a preference. Not super hot, but a bit of kick for sure.
  $16.00
- Coney Island (Hawaiian) - Personal 10"
  Does pineapple belong on pizza? This is our standard Hawaiian pie with a New York name. #teampineapple
  $15.00
- White - Personal 10"
  Vegetarian. ASONY Garlic Oil base, mozzarella, ricotta, fresh parmesan, EVOO. This is an "Off-Menu" item that has become very popular over the years. The ricotta makes this pie a creamy delight. You might have seen this pie with fresh basil and Balsamic reduction...we call that the "Fancy White." Just order this and add fresh basil and Balsamic reduction and you'll get it!
  $15.00
- Panini - Personal 10"
  ASONY Garlic Oil base, smoked ham, salami, fresh basil, Balsamic reduction, fresh parmesan. This is an "off-menu" item. We created this as an homage to the panini sandwiches we used to make. They were delicious and so is this. If you like things a little salty, you'll like this too. We added this because many of our long-time customers asked for it!
  $17.00
- Wall Street - Personal 10"
  ASONY Garlic Oil base, mozzarella, ricotta, pepperoni, bacon, Mike's Hot Honey. This is a new "Off-Menu" item that has really taken off. It was created internally by our team and really looks and smells great. And of course, it tastes awesome! If you like the White Pie, this is a meat evolution of it. And if you see orange oil drip off a slice, it's probably not from the pepperoni; it is the Mike's Hot Honey. Don't blot it off or let it drip off. It's good!
  $18.00
Build Your Own Pie
All pies come with our house made NY sauce and Grande mozzarella cheese. We make our dough and sauce daily, and shred cheese daily. We make all pies by hand and on deck ovens. Add the toppings you like. Please identify any allergies/restrictions. Sorry, whole pies only; no half/half. A quick tip for crisping or heating a fresh pie: 1. Heat up a skillet/frying pan (high heat, no oil). 2. When hot, place a slice or two in the pan (optional: cover the pan to melt the cheese a bit more). 3. In a minute or two, the bottom will be dry and crisp as if it came out of our pizza ovens! You can also heat up a pizza stone, but that's overkill. Save the energy!
- Large 18”
  Our large is 18" and will feed 3-5 people. It is cut into eight slices. Keep in mind, the number of slices has nothing to with the size of the pie or the amount of food it is. It is just a label. Some would call our large their X-large or don't even offer that size. Whole pies only, no half/half.
  $29.00
- Small 14”
  Keep in mind, our small is not small; in fact it is pretty big at 14". Don't let the name fool you. It will feed 2-3 people. The number of slices has nothing to with the size of the pie or the amount of food it is. It is just a label. Many places call their large 14" (the size of this small). It is cut into eight slices. Whole pies only, no half/half.
  $22.00
- Personal 10”
  Our personal is equivalent to about two house slices you would get from us from the display if you came in for slices. Whole pies only, no half/half.
  $13.00
Other Eats
Please identify any allergies/restrictions.
- Garlic Knots
  Vegetarian. More like an homage to the knot. Our dough tossed in Asony garlic oil, topped with extra ASONY Garlic Oil, and then sprinkled with fresh parmesan. Served with our marinara sauce.
  $6.00
- House Stromboli
  Large enough to share and filled with smoked ham, salami, bell peppers, red onions, mozzarella, and our NYC sauce, brushed with EVOO, topped with parmesan cheese with a side of our house marinara sauce. This is a nicely balanced meat/veggie meal.
  $15.00
- Veggie Stromboli
  Vegetarian. Large enough to share and filled with bell peppers, red onions, mushrooms, black olives, garlic, mozzarella, and our NYC sauce, brushed with EVOO, topped with parmesan cheese with a side of our house marinara sauce. Just like our House version, but no meat!
  $15.00
- House Calzone
  A large half-moon, adding smoked ham and stuffed with the finest mozzarella and ricotta cheeses, brushed with EVOO, topped with parmesan cheese, with a side of our house marinara sauce. If you like cheese, this is the one for you.
  $17.00
- Meatball Parm Sub Sandwich
  Our homemade hero stuffed with meatballs, mozzarella, our marinara, and topped with fresh parmesan.
  $15.00
- Chicken Parm Sub Sandwich
  Our homemade hero stuffed with the lightly breaded chicken breast fillets, covered with mozzarella cheese, and topped with our marinara and fresh parmesan.
  $15.00
- House Salad
  Vegetarian. Iceberg and spring mix, sliced roma tomatoes, sliced black olives, sliced fresh mushrooms, sliced red onions.
  $6.00
Desserts
- Cannoli (large) - From NY!
  Traditional cream with chocolate chips, topped with powdered sugar. When you order a cannoli, this is what you expect. We get the filling and shells from Long Island, and we make them to order.
  $5.00
- Mini-Cannoli (set of 3) - From NY!
  Traditional cream with chocolate chips, topped with powdered sugar. When you order a cannoli, this is what you expect. We get the filling and shells from Long Island, and we make them to order. The ratio of cream to shell is lower, so this may seem a bit less sweet than a large one. Perfect for sharing!
  $7.00
- Tiramisu - From NY!
  If you are a tiramisu fan, you will not be disappointed. They handcraft the Tiramisu the old-fashioned way, using the finest authentic ingredients. Imported Savoiardi ladyfingers are hand dipped in a custom espresso mixture, layered with ethereal mascarpone imported from Italy, then finished with a generous dusting of premium cocoa powder. They say, "You will not find a better Tiramisu anywhere," and we agree!
  $7.00
- NY Cheesecake - From NY!
  Brought in from Long Island, our all-natural, New York cheesecake is baked slowly (the old-fashioned way) with real cream cheese, sour cream, and an authentic graham cracker crust. Incredibly smooth and creamy, our cheesecake has been a consistent winner for decades. We love it!
  $6.00
- Drakes Cakes - From NY!
  We grew up with Drakes, and we are the only ones who sell them around here. We get them shipped in every 3-4 weeks (depending on sales). If you are craving that Devil Dog cake or peeling the chocolate off the Yodels as you unwind them, we're your place. Keep in mind, inventory is very volatile, so please list a backup in case we are out of your preference.
  $2.00
- Mini-Cannoli (one) - From NY!
  Traditional cream with chocolate chips, topped with powdered sugar. when you order a cannoli, this is what you expect. we get the filling and shells from long island, and we make them to order.
  $3.00
Drinks
- Manhattan Special Soda
  These premium, pure cane sugar sodas have been made in Brooklyn, NY since 1895. They started with their Pure Espresso Coffee, and later added Black Cherry, Sarsaparilla, Orange, Vanilla Cream. Like me, if you thought Dr. Brown's Black Cherry was the best growing up, you will find that Manhattan Special's Black Cherry is the best today. I haven't found one better.
  $4.00
- Can Soda
  7up sodas and Coke (just Coke)
  $2.50
- Bottled Water
  $3.00
Merch!
- Long Sleeve Shirt
  Like our t-shirts, these are 100% cotton from Comfort Colors, so you know they are the best. Very limited quantities and in Grape (purple) only. They are super comfy and have our fun melty alt-logo on the front showing we were established in 2006. The back has "A Slice of New York" subtly in black.
  $35.00
- Bottle Opener / Carabiner
  $5.00
- Stickers
  Who doesn't love stickers? Ours embrace local team colors (Warriors, SF Giants, Sharks, 49ers, our classic B&W, and our color logo). We also have our fun melty alt-logo.
  $1.00
Sauces/Extras
Sides of ranch and spices
- "TIP" the Crew (service charge)
  PLEASE NOTE: This is NOT a tip in the legal sense; it is a gift you are giving the business. We are asking you to trust the business to make sure this generosity is getting to the team (we are a worker cooperative that is owned by the workers). If you select $1.00, about $0.80 will get to the team due to overhead (Unemployment Insurance, Workers Compensation, and payroll taxes).
- Ranch Cup - 1.5oz
  Ken's is a high-quality brand and their ranch is great on slices or garlic knots. More ranch please! Each cup is $0.50. 1.5oz cup
  $0.50
- Side of Marinara Sauce - ~4oz
  Our marinara is a delicious dipping sauce. We sauté some onions, red pepper, pepper, and oil, then blend it together with our NYC pizza sauce. Our knots, stromboli, and calzone come with a cup.
  $1.00
- Frank's Red Hot - Buffalo Spicy (2 Containers)
  This is the same sauce we put on our Buffalo Chicken and other special items. It's got a nice spicy kick.
  $0.50
- Fresh Parmesan (3 Containers) + Red Pepper (3 Packs)
  This is the same freshly grated parm we use on our pies and other items. It's a top quality cheese from Grande Cheese Company (we are a 100% Grande Cheese operator). A few years ago we said "no more generic packaged cheese!" And to make it easy, we include red pepper flakes (3 packs).
  $0.50
- Red Pepper Packets (2 Packs)
  These are the same as the red pepper flakes you have at home. The quality is great, whether ours or yours.
- Mike's Hot Honey Cup - 1oz
  Mike’s Hot Honey is a sweet-heat combo of honey infused with chili peppers that adds the perfect kick to all of your favorite foods. Packed in 1oz cups.
  $2.00
- Light Sauce
  If you prefer less sauce or a drier pie, select this option.
- Extra Sauce
  If you want more sauce than we would normally use, select this. Keep in mind it may make the crust a bit soggy. A quick tip for crisping or heating a fresh pie: 1. Heat up a skillet/frying pan (high heat, no oil). 2. When hot, place a slice or two in the pan (optional: cover the pan to melt the cheese a bit more). 3. In a minute or two, the bottom will be dry and crisp as if it came out of our pizza ovens! You could also heat up a pizza stone, but that's overkill. Save the energy!
"TIP" the Crew
Unfortunately, there is no way to directly tip the crew on deliveries via this portal, so we have created this menu to allow you to provide additional support. It is not technically a tip as you are giving this to the business, so you need to trust A Slice of New York, a worker cooperative, to distribute the money equitably. For now, ALL of this goes to the team. The business is currently absorbing 15-20% overhead on what is donated to cover the Workers Compensation, Unemployment Insurance, and payroll taxes. We thank you for your generosity.
- $1 Team Thank You
  Approximately $0.80 will go to the crew, the rest goes to the government and insurance (not to the business).
  $1.00
- $5 Team Thank You
  Approximately $4 will go to the crew, the rest goes to the government and insurance (not to the business).
  $5.00
- $10 Team Thank You
  Approximately $8 will go to the crew, the rest goes to the government and insurance (not to the business).
  $10.00
- $20 Team Thank You
  Approximately $16 will go to the crew, the rest goes to the government and insurance (not to the business).
  $20.00
Catering
- 15 Person Lunch - 4 pies/3 options
  Serves 15. Meat pizza (2): 1 Pepperoni and 1 Buffalo Chicken. Vegetarian pizza (2): 2 ASONY Margarita Dressings: 5 ranch, 5 balsamic vinaigrette Dessert: 15 mini-cannoli NOTE: Plates, napkins not included...see extras.
  $244.00
- 30 Person Lunch - 7 pies/4 options
  Serves 30. Meat pizza (4): 2 Pepperoni and 2 Buffalo Chicken. Vegetarian pizza (3): 2 ASONY Margarita and 1 Times Square (all veggies). Dressings: 15 ranch, 5 balsamic vinaigrette Dessert: 30 mini-cannoli NOTE: Plates, napkins not included...see extras.
  $433.00
- 45 Person lunch – 10 pies/5 options
  Serves 45. Meat pizza (6): 2 Coney Island (ham, pineapple), 2 Rockefeller Center (all meat) and 2 Buffalo Chicken. Vegetarian pizza: (4) - 3 ASONY Margarita and 1 Times Square (all veggies). Salad: 5 individual house salad - iceberg/spring mix base, diced roma tomatoes, sliced black olives, sliced fresh mushrooms, and sliced red onion. Dressings: 15 ranch, 5 balsamic vinaigrette Dessert: 48 mini-cannoli NOTE: Plates, napkins, forks, salad tongs not included...see extras.
  $650.00
- 60 Person lunch – 14 pies/6 options
  Serves 60. Meat pizza (9): 2 Pepperoni, 2 Coney Island (ham, pineapple), 2 Rockefeller Center (all meat) and 3 Buffalo Chicken. Vegetarian pizza (5): 3 ASONY Margarita and 2 Times Square (all veggies). Salad: 1 Tray salad - iceberg/spring mix base, diced roma tomatoes, sliced black olives, sliced fresh mushrooms, and sliced red onion. Dressings: 20 ranch, 10 balsamic vinaigrette Dessert: 60 mini-cannoli NOTE: Plates, napkins, forks, salad tongs not included...see extras.
  $885.00
- 100 Person lunch – 23 pies/7 options
  Serves 100. Meat pizza (16): 2 Pepperoni, 3 Pepperoni, Mushroom, 4 Coney Island (ham, pineapple), 3 Rockefeller Center (all meat) and 4 – Buffalo Chicken. Vegetarian pizza (7) - 4 ASONY Margarita and 3 Times Square (all veggies). Salad: 2 Tray salad - iceberg/spring mix base, diced roma tomatoes, sliced black olives, sliced fresh mushrooms, and sliced red onion. Dressings: 40 ranch, 20 balsamic vinaigrette Dessert: 96 mini-cannoli NOTE: Plates, napkins, forks, salad tongs not included...see extras.
  $1,463.00

Menu Photos

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

A Slice of New York Menu

Customer Favorites

ASONY Margarita - Personal 10"

Garlic Knots

Large 18”

Small 14”

ASONY Margarita - Large 18"

Mini-Cannoli (set of 3) - From NY!

Tiramisu - From NY!

The City (Combo) - Large 18"

Ranch Cup - 1.5oz

Personal 10”

Large 18” - Specialty Pies

The City (Combo) - Large 18"

Buffalo Chicken - Large 18"

Rockefeller Center (All Meat) - Large 18"

Bensonhurst (Chicken) - Large 18"

Times Square (All Veggie) - Large 18"

ASONY Margarita - Large 18"

Munchie Lunchie - Large 18"

Coney Island (Hawaiian) - Large 18"

White - Large 18"

Panini - Large 18"

Wall Street - Large 18"

Small 14” - Specialty Pies

The City (Combo) - Small 14"

Buffalo Chicken - Small 14"

Rockefeller Center (All Meat) - Small 14"

Bensonhurst (Chicken) - Small 14"

Times Square (All Veggie) - Small 14"

ASONY Margarita - Small 14"

Munchie Lunchie - Small 14"

Coney Island (Hawaiian) - Small 14"

White - Small 14"

Panini - Small 14"

Wall Street - Small 14"

Personal 10” - Specialty Pies

The City (Combo) - Personal 10"

Buffalo Chicken - Personal 10"

Rockefeller Center (All Meat) - Personal 10"

Bensonhurst (Chicken) - Personal 10"

Times Square (All Veggie) - Personal 10"

ASONY Margarita - Personal 10"

Munchie Lunchie - Personal 10"

Coney Island (Hawaiian) - Personal 10"

White - Personal 10"

Panini - Personal 10"

Wall Street - Personal 10"

Build Your Own Pie

Large 18”

Small 14”

Personal 10”

Other Eats

Garlic Knots

House Stromboli

Veggie Stromboli

House Calzone

Meatball Parm Sub Sandwich

Chicken Parm Sub Sandwich

House Salad

Desserts

Cannoli (large) - From NY!

Mini-Cannoli (set of 3) - From NY!

Tiramisu - From NY!

NY Cheesecake - From NY!

Drakes Cakes - From NY!

Mini-Cannoli (one) - From NY!

Drinks

Manhattan Special Soda

Can Soda

Bottled Water

Merch!

Long Sleeve Shirt

Bottle Opener / Carabiner

Stickers

Sauces/Extras

"TIP" the Crew (service charge)

Ranch Cup - 1.5oz

Side of Marinara Sauce - ~4oz

Frank's Red Hot - Buffalo Spicy (2 Containers)